In a recent production of A Midsummer Night's Dream (2008) at the Hartford Stage, the actor playing “Wall” in the play-within-the-play dissolved into helpless giggles at the antics of Bottom. That her colleague's acting, four weeks into production, could still make her laugh revealed much about the actor's ability to keep his physical comedy fresh. However, director and teacher John Wright would say that the actor had found the right game.
Why Is That So Funny? is Wright's immensely readable instruction book for performing physical comedy. Part performance study, part collection of improvisational exercises, this book analyzes comedy as a technical art for the scholar, performance critic, and theatre director alike. The varying fonts used in the text highlight the different discussions that are woven together; the theatre games are distinct from the analyses of these games, which are further set apart from the theoretical discussion of comedy. The term “theoretical” is perhaps misleading, because Wright offers down-to-earth explanations for why a scene, gesture, or character is funny. He discusses exercises and their effects within the context of plays and workshops he has directed, indicating their potential as well as their risks in falling flat. For example, in one game where the group collaboratively invents a preposterous physical action based on an incomprehensible directive, Wright recommends that they take their actions seriously rather than try and invent mistakes.
It is a challenge to write about the physical nature of comedy because it requires a concrete vocabulary; Wright provides this vocabulary as well as a helpful organizing schema. The first part of the book introduces his concept of “play”—a process that involves getting rid of the superego's critical voice and fostering creativity through free association, inventing new games, and reacting to the absurdity of others. “Play” is a collaborative art, and Wright focuses on games that allow actors to find “complicity” with one another so that they can react to cues from other actors and provoke responses in turn.
The first part of the book conveys the vital importance of games for constructing dramatic action, comic or otherwise. “Theatre as game and acting as play” (80) is one of Wright's central tenets, and he proposes games that generate subtexts for the actors to play. He provides one example from a play he wrote, She'll Be Coming Round the Mountain, in which a soldier rapes a young girl. In order to develop a credible tension for this scene, Wright created a “game” for the actors to discover movements that would translate into a necessary level of commitment. The episode is all the more shocking because the actors focused on the “games” of chase and struggle; they found and played the game of an action rather than simply enacting the rape itself.
Actors performing naturalistic drama derive their character's motivation from a back story they create based on the text, but physical comedy, with its chaos and confusion, does not typically demand Method acting preparation. The dramatic pattern of comedy typically follows three steps: the anticipation, release, and payoff of the action, and actors depict this process by manipulating the tension, rhythm, and timing. Thus, the second part of Wright's book encompasses these technical aspects of comedy. The most basic, the states of tension, enable the actor to envision mentally a physical state that corresponds to the required energy level, whether to be “laid back” (103) or whether to wonder “Is there a bomb in the room?” (116). Rhythm in turn is the physical manifestation of this state of tension on the body. Wright provides specific exercises to train the actors in the eight states of tension the body can manifest; an actor who moves the body from “exhausted”—the first state of tension—all the way through “The bomb is about to go off!” learns to shift his or her center of gravity, the speed of movement, and the directional flow of energy.
If the first half of the book is a tool kit for comic actors, the second half categorizes the structural elements of comedy: the distinct comic personalities, which he identifies as clowns, and the subgenres within comedy. Wright devotes a chapter to clowning because this role is the most elemental position from which to develop a relationship with the audience, and the exercises in this section help the actor “read” an audience and respond to their approval or boredom. Wright draws perspicacious distinctions among kinds of clowns; Pathetic Clown, for example, with his optimism and ridiculous naïveté, differs from the dignity of Tragic Clown, who earns our admiration. Clowning, more than any other performance role, captures the human condition in a nutshell; the perplexity a clown experiences by his surroundings is a metaphor for the human condition.
In his final part, “The Gentle Art of Ridicule,” Wright categorizes the components of parody—caricature, satire, pastiche, burlesque, and buffoonery—not according to the literary sense by which they are typically understood, but rather according to how they are performed. They all incorporate imitation, analysis, and attack, but to varying degrees, and Wright identifies the differing levels of mimetic exaggeration and the specificity of the satirical target in performance. Parody and its concomitant forms, come from a deep human desire to misbehave as well as to assail institutions, and the actor must maintain a balance: a “gamble between giving pleasure and causing offence” (262). While parody is not an acting style, Wright teaches it because it comprises a great deal of physical comedy. Games such as the Exaggeration Game or the Nationalities Game, which focus on mimicking an individual's movement or alignment, or a country's spoken language, compel actors to identify and imitate personal idiosyncrasies in others.
Wright does not draw upon many comic theorists; his primary references for directing comedy are Jacques Copeau, Jacques Lecoq, and Philippe Gaulier. His study is less about the tradition of comedy and more about managing the crucial dynamic between actors and audience. Wright's own careful attention to the psychology of human relations translates well into the theatre, and his exercises capture the comic interactions between people and the serious games they play.
