In a subfield that tends to focus on government organizations and political elites, it is refreshing when scholars succeed in shifting the lens. Carol Nackenoff and Julie Novkov’s edited volume Statebuilding from the Margins challenges much of the conventional wisdom in American Political Development (APD) by focusing on the role of non-state actors at the subnational level. The authors in this book remind us that non-elites and independent organizations can play a considerable role in development and should not be ignored in our analytical frameworks. Stated most succinctly by Nackenoff and Novkov, “the authors of the chapters in this volume find that understanding state formation often requires looking outside the state” (p. 4). Seven essays in this collection take this charge seriously and chart new paths for its analysis.
The authors center their analyses on the period from the end of the Civil War until the beginning of the New Deal, arguing that this timeframe marked an overlooked period of state expansion. The authors are writing against the more compact, dare I say “neater” account of statebuilding that has dominated the subfield. Over the past several years, there has been a lively debate in the subfield about what constitutes statebuilding. Is it strictly political institutions or should it include ideas as well? And what about the role of non-elite actors? With the publication of this volume, it seems the contributors are making a case for a more porous understanding of development—one that encompasses ideas, the public and the private realms, and the local. Throughout this edited volume, the authors make clear that development is not just a top-down or a bottom-up story; there is a dynamic feedback loop. The recentering of statebuilding on a new cast of actors in different locations is a significant move. As such, the publication of this book provides an opportunity to identify the contours of this more expansive approach as well as to assess its usefulness.
Julie Novkov’s “Making Citizens of Freedmen and Polygamists” examines two seemingly disparate stories of how state officials and activists redefined the meaning of citizenship. Specially, Novkov focuses on the campaign to protect freedwomen and freedmen’s civil rights and the campaign to suppress polygamy in the Utah Territory. By considering these two campaigns together, her work illustrates how the expansion of national capacity to protect a certain meaning of citizenship was constructed by state and private actors at a key moment in APD. In doing so, Novkov’s convincing analysis shows that federal notions of citizenship were greatly influenced by people outside of the federal government. Novkov’s unlikely pairing of these campaigns underscores the rule of law in statebuilding as well as the regulation of intimate familial relationships as a conduit for increasing national governing capacity.
Mark Steedman’s “Demagogues and the Demon Drink: Newspapers and the Revival of Prohibition in Georgia” puts independent newspapers and their editors at the crux of understanding Georgia’s decision to adopt prohibition in 1907. Steedman argues that newspaper editors in Georgia exerted a considerable amount of control in politics and in the shaping of public opinion. He exposes how editors linked racist and sexualized fears of black men to liquor and how the support for prohibition in Georgia was actually a story about the protection of white womanhood. In doing so, Steedman drives home a central tenant of this book: “nonstate actors drive the development of state authority” (p. 80).
Proving that all corners of society are political, Kathleen Sullivan and Patricia Strach focus on the contestation surrounding waste management in a chapter titled “Statebuilding Through Corruption: Graft and Trash in Pittsburg and New Orleans.” The authors juxtapose the failure of New Orleans to build and use a reduction plant to the success of Pittsburg and conclude that the success of the latter was due to the strength of its political machine. That is, a strong machine system can more readily utilize corruption as a resource in the execution of public-private contracts. The authors’ findings are buttressed by impressive archival data. The chapter is both counterintuitive and a brilliant analysis of the way reformers and machines worked to enhance state capacity. As a result, scholars of state and local politics should find this chapter especially useful.
In “Developing the Animal Welfare State” Susan Pearson and Kimberly Smith critique traditional accounts of the building of the welfare state for excluding preceding campaigns around animal rights. Pearson and Smith contend that welfare regimes were path dependent on the states capacity to protect animal welfare. Specially, Pearson and Smith focus on the ideational shift from animal protectionism to that of children and argue that the concept of animal rights “supported the view that the state is justified in intruding into the domestic sphere in order to protect the welfare of children” (p. 132) This chapter persuasively demonstrates that local and state campaigns to protect animal rights are a neglected area of development.
Ann-Marie Szymanski’s “Wildlife Protection and the Development of Centralized Governance in the Progressive Era” stresses the blurriness in distinguishing between bureaucrats, state actors, and activists. Szymanski’s chapter examines why a coalition of sportsmen, naturalists, and progressive women lobbied state governments for greater wildlife protections and then garnered considerable success at the national level. Focusing on the transitional phase of development, Szymanski argues that public officials “borrowed” state capacity from social actors to achieve their goals. In other words, private organizations and activists facilitated the build up of state regulatory power.
Carol Nackenoff and Kathleen Sullivan’s “The House that Julia (and Friends) Built: Networking Chicago’s Juvenile Court” is one of the standout chapters of this edited volume. It uses the early development of the juvenile court system as a case study to understand the role of public-private collaborations during the Progressive Era. Nackenoff and Sullivan make a compelling case that organized interests were largely responsible for the development of the Juvenile Court of Cook County. Their analysis details how reformers developed the rationale for its creation, supplied personnel and funding for its operation, and convinced policymakers to assume responsibility for its continued administration. And after the Juvenile Court of Cook County became part of the state, reformers placed some of their own activists in public offices. Nackenoff and Sullivan thus illustrate how the demarcation line between public and private actors can be hard to determine and how a more complete account of development emerges when they are theorized together. This chapter represents a significant contribution to the growing body of research arguing that statebuilding is often nonlinear.
James Greer’s “The Better Homes Movement and the Origins of Mortgage Redlining in the United States” challenges the traditional narrative of mortgage redlining as associated with the New Deal and instead locates it with the work of women’s civic organizations in the aftermath of World War I. Specifically, Greer examines the origins of the Federal Housing Authority’s (FHA) extensive appraisal standards that informed the agency’s willingness to extend mortgage guarantees. Greer brilliantly exposes how Better Homes in America (BHA), a private and prominent organization, defined and then popularized a model of what a proper American home should look like. Greer’s analysis of BHA culminates with the publication of a Better Homes Manual, which essentially was a building guide for the ideal home for middle-class America. It was the findings in this manual, Greer argues, that was later adopted by the FHA as the accepted framework for American homes. Greer writes, “the standards were so completely elaborated in the Better Homes Manual that they were one and the same as the underwriting standards adopted by the FHA” (p. 209). In this way, Greer’s research demonstrates the considerable influence of private organizations in the creation and administration of public agencies and the development of national policy.
Every now and then, academic fields of inquiry need a jolt. The contributions in this book and the well-crafted introduction provide a sort of shaking of the ground. The work in this volume makes it hard to look at past studies in American Political Development and not wonder: Where is the local? Where are the private actors and organizations? How did ideas get transferred from activist organizations to government agencies? And how do individual activists work in tandem with government officials? Statebuilding from the Margins makes it clear that we have not sufficiently interrogated the past. This is a significant achievement.
This edited volume represents a considerable undertaking and the editors and contributors should be commended for taking up such a large task. Statebuilding from the Margins is a persuasive book but there are also challenges that arise with such an ambitious project. As much as I enjoyed the different accounts of the development of the capacity of the American state, some chapters were more convincing than others. I couldn’t help but wonder where and how should we identify statebuilding from the margins? I’m willing to accept that traditional notions of statebuilding need to be expanded. Surely, the analytical frame should be wider than the one cast by more traditional works in the field. Yet, how far should these new boundaries extend and what should they include and exclude? And when does a more porous sub-national view of APD become unwieldy? Finally, are there distinguishing markers between those marginal accounts that are better suited to the field of political history and those historical case studies from the margins that lend themselves to an APD analysis?
While some of the authors in this edited volume appear to explicitly shy away from larger generalizations about their case studies, it does seem from the introduction that the book is oriented toward advocating for a broader approach to statebuilding that is closer to the work of Elisabeth Clemens, William Novak, and Pamela Brandwein than it is to the scholarship of Karen Orren, Stephen Skowronek, and Daniel Carpenter. By aligning themselves with the work of the former, this edited volume joins an important vein of scholarship in reorienting the field. My only quip as a young scholar trying to navigate the contours of this sub-field is that I would have liked a more precise definition of what constitutes this new area of statebuilding from the margins. I commend the authors of this edited volume for moving us towards a more nuanced discussion of statebuilding and for exposing important silences in our research on development.
