This volume, edited by anthropologist Denise Arnold and Latin American literary specialist Carlos Abreu Mendoza, examines from a cross-disciplinary perspective the concept of lo andino (‘the Andean’). A theme running through the essays is how the Andean in countries that are not only Andean has been emphasised as a central feature of national identity since the achievement of independence in the early nineteenth century by Bolivia, Peru and Ecuador in particular. These essays question assumptions regarding the centrality of the Andean in these countries and investigate how Andean identity has become so central in a region that historically has been characterised by its connections between highlands and lowlands. Regional divisions are questioned as a colonial construct that disempower Native Peoples across the continent.
The book is divided into six chapters, some in English, others in Spanish. In the introduction, Abreu Mendoza describes ‘lo andino’ as a term that arises from a transnational discourse grouping together diverse identities through a global context of imagined communities, and outlines the aim of the book as being to ‘construct a genealogy of the Andes … through history and from different points of the continent’ (p. 2; reviewer's translation). The book does this successfully in the chapters that follow, which examine lo andino through a variety of historical, geographical and disciplinary lenses.
In the second chapter, ‘Beyond “lo andino”: Rethinking Tiwanaku from the Amazonian Lowlands’, Arnold examines the historic site of Tiwanaku as an Andean symbol in the construction of national identity in Bolivia. From the archaeological focus on Tiwanaku after Bolivia's 1952 National Revolution, to its use as a site of political rituals under both the neoliberal government of Gonzalo Sánchez de Lozada in the 1990s and Evo Morales’ decolonising agenda in the 2000s, the pre-Incaic site has been made a central stage for governments that have privileged the Andean component of Bolivia's identity. Arnold argues that Tiwanaku has been presented as an ‘almost exclusively highland phenomenon’ (p. 27), ignoring historical links between highlands and lowlands, and constructing artificial regional boundaries that place the highlands as the civilising centre, and the lowlands as uncivilised peripheries. Truly rethinking Bolivia as a plurinational state, she argues, should mean ‘rethinking the Andes from the lowlands and vice versa’ (p. 46), countering notions of centre and periphery that highlight regional separations rather than connections.
Caroline Garriott's chapter ‘Carrying Water on Both Shoulders: Material Archives and Andean Ritual in Mid-Colonial Huamanga, Peru’ studies a 1684 manuscript by Jesuit priest Nicolás de Talavera to chart the ‘diachronic, contested process of Andean religion formation during the late sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries’ (p. 63). She uses an ethnographic analysis of Talavera's description of the Native reception of Christian symbols such as the cross to argue against the priest's analysis that the Catholic church had uprooted Andean idolatry, and instead that aspects of Christianity were incorporated as subordinate elements into pre-existing local religious practices thereby suggesting a continuity between pre-Hispanic times and the present day, rather than seeing the Spanish invasion as a rupture in Andean history.
Chapter 4, ‘Sobre la noción de lo andino: Ciencia, literatura y consumo’ (‘On the Notion of the Andean: Science, Literature and Consumption’) by Jorge Coronado, traces the evolution of the concept of lo andino from the mid-nineteenth century until the mid-twentieth century, and its contribution to Peruvian national identity. Coronado firstly examines through Antigüedades peruanas (Peruvian Antiquities, by Mariano Eduardo de Rivero y Ustáriz and J. J. von Tschudi, two vols., 1951) how a pre-Hispanic imperial past was used to give identity to a national Peruvian project. Coronado also charts the development of lo andino through twentieth-century Peruvian writers and artists Julio Tello, José Mariátegui and Elena Izcue, through whose work we see the influence of the local and the global in the emergence of Andean identity. Coronado identifies a national and international cross-fertilisation in the construction of lo andino in cultural, political and academic discourse. He sees the North American university as having played a particularly significant role in the emergence of the latter, through homogenising distinct but similar concepts as Andean.
In the fifth chapter, ‘Gamaliel Churata y esa beligerancia estética conceptualizada como “Andinismo”‘ (‘Gamaliel Churata and that Aesthetic Belligerence Conceptualised as “Andeanism”’), Elizabeth Monasterios Pérez further examines the emergence of an Andean aesthetic in the early twentieth century, through the literary production of a group of mestizo and Indigenous writers in Puno – the ‘Vanguardia del Titikaka’ – whose work questioned the Spanish civilising impulse and twentieth-century utopian ideals of mestizaje. The ‘Andinismo’ that emerged was an aesthetic born of political and cultural struggles that was not tied to any one country, but was a geopolitical strategy to promote continental leadership among people speaking the same language. The term ‘Andean aesthetic’, we learn, first appeared in the pages of the group's magazine Boletín Titikaka in 1926, in discussion of the style of another publication the same year, Ande, a book of poems by Alejandro Peralta.
The last chapter of the book is ‘Interrogating Indigeneity: A Comparative Perspective on Social Change in the Andes and United States’ by Hannah Burdette. Burdette examines Andean, Indigenous, Latin American and Native American identity from a comparative perspective, arguing that the division of Indigenous identities along national and regional boundaries inhibits the possibility of transnational identification and joint political struggles across the continent. In asking what happens to the identity of Indigenous Peoples when they migrate across the continent and come into contact with other Native Americans, she highlights not only the contingent nature of identity but that, as Arnold shows in her own chapter, Indigenous Peoples themselves are not static, they travel, trade and migrate, and always have done. Burdette argues for the need to ‘move beyond divided and conquered mentalities’ to create ‘a hegemonic project’ (p. 160) taking into account the similarities between Native Peoples in the continent as a starting point. Her and Arnold's chapters highlight that it is simplistic to talk about the Andean without the Amazonian or in isolation from a Native American identity in general.
