The Zapatista movement marked a turning point for the indigenous movement in Mexico, creating opportunities for local groups to join forces and form national organizations to challenge the state (Montemayor, Reference Montemayor2009; Nash, Reference Nash2001; Stavenhagen, Reference Stavenhagen, Tulchin and Selee2002; Stephen, Reference Stephen2002; Velasco Cruz, Reference Velasco Cruz2003). This movement also created an unprecedented opportunity for indigenous women to position themselves as political actors (Espinosa Damián, Reference Espinosa Damián2009; Speed et al., Reference Speed, Castillo and Stephen2006). A national indigenous movement emerged from this political context and indigenous women framed a specific discourse that would lead to the creation of a national indigenous women's movement (Speed et al., Reference Speed, Castillo and Stephen2006). Zapatista women's contribution to the integration of gender into indigenous discourse is key for understanding how indigenous women began to voice demands articulating gender and indigeneity and how this later influenced the indigenous movement's dynamics (Gutierrez and Palomo, Reference Gutierrez and Palomo2000; Lovera and Palomo, Reference Lovera and Palomo1997). In the aftermath of the Zapatista uprising, women from different movements and regions of the country began identifying with Zapatista women, framing a specific discourse on indigenous women's collective identity. For this reason, the Zapatista movement is considered a particularly important actor that contributed to positioning indigenous women as political actors (Hernández Castillo, Reference Hernández Castillo2001; Millán Moncayo, Reference Millán Moncayo, Speed, Castillo and Stephen2008; Sanchez Néstor, Reference Sánchez Néstor2005). Moreover, participation in meetings in preparation for the Continental Encounters of Indigenous Women of the Americas as well as for the Women's International Conference in Beijing were key moments for indigenous women to develop an agenda situating gender demands within the frame of the indigenous movement—particularly its core demand for self-determination—as well as an incentive to organize together at the national level (Blackwell, Reference Blackwell, Speed, Castillo and Stephen2006; Rivera, Reference Rivera, Navaz and Hernández2008; Valladares de la Cruz, Reference Valladares de la Cruz2008).
Although this national and international context facilitated the creation of networks among indigenous women, the latter faced significant obstacles when they brought women's rights to the agenda of indigenous organizations. In the assemblies of the Pluralistic Indigenous National Assembly for Autonomy (Assamblea Nacional Indígena Plural por la Autonomía, ANIPA) indigenous women aimed to integrate women's rights into the discussions around self-determination (Sanchez Néstor, Reference Sánchez Néstor2005). As well, indigenous women strategically mobilized to integrate their demands into the agenda during the meetings of the National Indigenous Congress (Congreso Nacional Indígena, CNI) (Lovera and Palomo, Reference Lovera and Palomo1997). In both organizations, indigenous women tried to open spaces to discuss women's rights and self-determination or incorporate their perspectives into the discussions; however, they faced resistance. Indigenous women's efforts to gain greater independence to discuss specific demands provoked strong reactions on the part of indigenous organizations, which tried to restrain women's activities and goals (Sánchez Néstor, Reference Sánchez Néstor2005). Although indigenous women's political experience was largely shaped by their historical participation in peasant and indigenous organizations, it was within these same organizations that their actions were circumscribed when they made efforts to introduce a perspective on self-determination that includes women's rights.
Indigenous women arrived at the conclusion that in order to have a greater impact within the indigenous movement they needed a space of their own that could facilitate the analysis and mobilization from a perspective that articulated gender and indigeneity (Blackwell, Reference Blackwell, Speed, Castillo and Stephen2006; Espinosa Damián, Reference Espinosa Damián2009; Gutiérrez and Palomo, Reference Gutierrez and Palomo2000; Hernández Castillo, Reference Hernández Castillo2001; Millán Moncayo, Reference Millán Moncayo, Speed, Castillo and Stephen2008; Rivera, Reference Rivera, Navaz and Hernández2008; Sánchez Néstor, Reference Sánchez Néstor2005; Speed et al., Reference Speed, Castillo and Stephen2006). Members of ANIPA and CNI combined their efforts to organize the first national meeting of indigenous women in 1997 in the city of Oaxaca, which led to the creation of an independent organization at the national level, the National Coordination of Indigenous Women (Coordinadora Nacional de Mujeres Indígenas, CONAMI). CONAMI became the primary space for formulating and representing indigenous women's demands and interests at the national level (Blackwell, Reference Blackwell, Speed, Castillo and Stephen2006). It was instrumental in providing a space for co-ordinating indigenous women at the national level but more importantly, it organized numerous workshops for training indigenous women to develop tools to push for increased rights and to train other women from their communities and groups.
A few years after its creation, CONAMI promoted the creation of state or subnational organizations to bring together local processes and to bridge the local and national levels. The Coordination of Indigenous Women of Guerrero (Coordinadora Guerrerense de Mujeres Indígenas—CGMI) was created in 2003, followed by the creation in 2010 of the Indigenous Women's Assembly of Oaxaca (Asamblea de Mujeres Indígenas de Oaxaca, AMIO). That same year indigenous women began a process to create the Indigenous Women's Coordination of Chiapas (Asamblea de Mujeres Indígenas de Chiapas, COEMI). The reasons that motivated the creation of a national organization are similar in the creation of state or subnational organizations by indigenous women, whether in Guerrero, Chiapas or Oaxaca (Espinosa Damián et al., Reference Espinosa Damián, Chautla and Néstor2010). For instance, the co-ordinator of the Alliance of Indigenous Women from Central America and Mexico's Youth Section explains that the creation of the Indigenous Women's Assembly of Oaxaca (AMIO) was motivated by the need “to strengthen and articulate indigenous women's organization” (interview with Dalí Ángel Pérez, December 2011). This motivation was echoed by the founding member and former co-ordinator of Services of the Mixe People (Servicios del Pueblo Mixe—SER), who explained: “The majority of us were trained in mixed-gender organizations and I continue to believe that I want to be here, and that I want to continue to promote indigenous rights, women's rights, but I also think that there needs to be autonomous processes for women” (interview with Sofia Robles, July 2011). These organizing trajectories are characterized by struggles for organizational autonomy, which involve constant negotiations to gain recognition for specific demands,Footnote 1 but also collaboration and alliances with different actors.
The collaboration developed between indigenous women and feminist organizations was critical in the process leading to the creation of organizing spaces for indigenous women (co-operatives and productive projects related to craftwork, farming, nutrition, education, health, and so forth). They facilitated the integration of gender within indigenous organizations and supported indigenous women's processes to create spaces within organizations to elaborate political discourses and the capacity to bring their demands forward (Bonfil, Reference Bonfil2012; Castro Apreza, Reference Castro Apreza, Eber and Kovic2003; Eber and Kovic, Reference Eber and Kovic2003; Hernández Castillo, Reference Hernández Castillo, Lammel and Mercado2002; López Cruz, Reference López Cruz2009). However, this collaboration is not between actors who have equal positions within society, and this affects organizational dynamics. The collaborations between mestiza (non-indigenous Mexican women) feminists and indigenous women are embedded in power relations that are shaped by the colonial structures that characterize Mexican society. Therefore, if indigenous women benefited from such collaborations to gain more autonomy within the indigenous movement, these collaborations did not necessarily lead to a transformation of feminist spaces involved and of power relations between women.
I argue that the redefinition of collaboration has been key for the organizing capacity of indigenous women to position themselves as autonomous political actors, independent from indigenous as well as feminist organizations. While collaboration has facilitated indigenous women's organizing process overall, it has nonetheless limited the creation of fully autonomous spaces in the long term largely due to colonial power relations and their impact on representation and access to resources. A comparison of mobilization trajectories reveals substantial differences in how collaborations have evolved and affected indigenous women's struggles for organizational autonomy.
This article seeks to better understand the role of collaborations and alliances in the process of constructing organizational autonomy by indigenous women. The analysis is based on a multiple case study research methodology from an inductive approach. The field work conducted for my doctoral thesis, in which this analysis is grounded, involved primarily semi-structured interviews conducted in Spanish with indigenous women leaders of local and subnational organizations in 2010 and 2011, as well as observations in meetings, conferences and workshops that took place in different regions of the country; the translations of interview quotations from Spanish to English are mine.Footnote 2 Among the women interviewed were those involved in the formation of the first indigenous women's organizations at both the local and national level in Mexico.
Two cases are compared in this article, Oaxaca and Chiapas. These two states have seen substantial indigenous mobilizations in both early and recent history. Indigenous women have been active in such movements at the local and more recently at the regional level. In both cases indigenous women engaged in the past decade in a process of co-ordination at the subnational level. However, if these cases share similar historical, social and political processes, indigenous women's organizing faces major obstacles in Chiapas. This is particularly puzzling since the indigenous women's movements in Mexico identify the uprising of the Zapatista movement in Chiapas and the favourable context it created for women as a key point in their organization process. This article aims to illustrate, through the comparison of the two cases,Footnote 3 the role played by collaborations in the processes.
Intersectionality in the Study of Social Movements Dynamics
Feminist research in the field of social movements has shown how gender dynamics within social movements are among the major causes of the creation of women-only organizations. When women challenge gendered internal dynamics in social organizations, the tension they create often leads to the emergence of new political actors and social organizations (Alvarez, Reference Alvarez, Alvarez, Dagnino and Escobar1998; Roth, Reference Roth2004). However, gender is far from being the only dynamic at play in the creation of feminist and women's movements. The complexity of women's diverse experiences of oppression is translated into a broad diversity of women's self-identification and consequently the type of collective actions women undertake (Yuval-Davis, Reference Yuval-Davis2006). In Mexico, this is illustrated by the emergence of different types of feminism—historic, popular, civic and indigenous—which expresses the diversity of social positions occupied by women and how they define their identity and organize collectively accordingly to this (Espinosa Damián, Reference Espinosa Damián2009).Footnote 4 Indigenous women in Mexico as well as in other parts of Latin America have organized to build autonomous spaces, independent from feminist movements (Valladares de la Cruz, Reference Valladares de la Cruz2008).
The formation of movements' collective identities raises the question of how multiple identities are dealt with and how movements are able or unable to represent this diversity and to change the power dynamics within. It is from this perspective that the integration of an intersectional analysis into the study of social movement dynamics is central. In social movement studies, processes of boundary making and collective identity formation have been analysed from an intersectional perspective (Bernstein, Reference Bernstein, Reger, Myers and Einwohner2008; Nash, Reference Nash2008; Taylor and Whittier, Reference Taylor, Whittier, Morris and Mueller1992). While previous studies have explored how intersectionality affects women's decisions to organize in autonomous spaces, they have not explored why these decisions yield varying results in terms of the consolidation of autonomous spaces and agendas (Roth, Reference Roth2004). In her study of Black, Chicana and White feminisms in the US, Roth considers both intra- and inter-movement dynamics to explain their emergence and trajectories. For Roth, the different social locations of women and structural inequalities were central to activists' political choices concerning collective action. Less attention has been given to the effects of intersectional dynamics of power in the organizing structures of social movements, particularly to the efforts of certain groups to foster organizational autonomy and the role of collaborations and alliances in this process.
The analysis of collaborations in the creation of autonomous organizations in the cases presented here is based on the concept of brokerage that refers to the “production of new connection between previously unconnected sites” (Tilly and Tarrow, Reference Tilly and Tarrow2007: 215), thus enabling actors to establish or increase co-ordination within a social movement or between different movements. In this process, collective actors can potentially challenge the distribution of positions grounded in gender, class and race dynamics. Consequently, new groups mobilize to access resources, activate boundaries and position themselves as equal actors. When this happens, these new groups are usually active in creating new ties and/or redefining previous relationships. And the types of alliances endorsed will have an effect on their level of structural autonomy.
However, brokerage can take different forms, particularly if we analyse the relationships that exist between social movement actors from an intersectional perspective (Morales Hudon, Reference Morales Hudon2014). The intersectional perspective adopted in this article considers structural inequality as a complex reality resulting from the intersection of varied systems of oppression that are articulated, relational and contextual, involving dynamic relations of production and reproduction of social structures (Bilge, Reference Bilge2010; Crenshaw, Reference Crenshaw1991; Hill Collins, Reference Hill Collins1991; hooks, Reference hooks1984).
In Mexico, relationships between indigenous women's organizations and mestiza feminist groups are complex and need to be situated in a context where social relations continue to be shaped by colonial structures. This is a key element to take into consideration in the analysis of the specificities of power relations between mestizas and indigenous women in Mexico, as the different collaborations that emerge in such contexts have often led to exclusionary discourses and practices that reproduce social relations of power based colonial and class structures (Figueroa Romero, Reference Figueroa Romero2006; Hernández Castillo, Reference Hernández Castillo2001). The power imbalance existing between middle class mestiza women and indigenous women is visible in the distribution of positions within social movements organizations as well as in their differing levels of access to resources: social, political, economic and symbolic. This uneven distribution of positions has provoked significant tensions as it also creates imbalances in decisional power within organizations. These dynamics vary from one political context to another and it is crucial to take this into consideration when analysing social movement dynamics from an intersectional perspective. The comparison of two cases in this article aims to contribute to understandings of how power relations affect the organizing processes of social movements through an analysis of dynamics of representation and access to resources, as well as by examining how organizations and social actors respond to and challenge such relations.
Collaborations and Organizing Trajectories in Mexico
Indigenous women's struggles for organizational autonomy in Mexico involved collaborations with women's and feminist organizations, which supported the framing of a new collective identity as well as a strengthening of the indigenous women's national organization (Bonfil, Reference Bonfil2012; Eber and Kovic, Reference Eber and Kovic2003). This support—manifested through collaborative projects, workshops, training and financing aiming to promote women's rights—intensified with the Zapatista movement, particularly the different spaces the movement opened for discussion, reflection and debate. One example was the workshop on women's rights and customs, Los derechos de las mujeres en nuestras costumbres y tradiciones, organized by feminist activists and scholars in Chiapas in May 1994 (Duarte Bastian, Reference Duarte Bastian2005; Eber and Kovic, Reference Eber and Kovic2003; Millán Moncayo, Reference Millán Moncayo, Speed, Castillo and Stephen2006). The workshop examined the implications of constitutional reforms on traditional indigenous practices and customs from the perspective of women's rights. Later that year, Zapatista leaders also convened a workshop on “The Condition, Rights and Culture of Indigenous Women.” Non-indigenous women presented information on international agreements on indigenous peoples' and women's rights, which served as a reference tool for thinking about the articulation of gender and indigeneity in terms of human rights (Gutiérrez and Palomo, Reference Gutierrez and Palomo2000). The workshop offered not only a space for dialogue and sharing, but also for the formulation of indigenous women's discourses on women's rights.
Feminist organizations also supported indigenous women in the consolidation of their networks, as with the preparation for the first national meeting of indigenous women in 1997 and the creation of CONAMI. This was particularly the case for Kinal Antzetik, a women's civil association actively involved in promoting indigenous women's projects. As explained by the co-ordinator, Kinal Antzetik and CONAMI's collaboration was significant: “It was a process where the goal was clearly to help strengthen indigenous women leaders to advocate within the indigenous movement; … part of the role Kinal played there was to enable those spaces, those resources for transportation. … So it was like having a periodic space for meeting and construction” (interview with Lina Rosa Berrio Palomo, April 2011). The space, resources and workshops provided by Kinal Antzetik greatly facilitated meetings and activities among indigenous women from different regions. While Kinal Antzetik is one of the best-known organizational allies of indigenous women, other organizations have also been of pivotal importance, for example, Comlatezin, which supported the creation of indigenous women's autonomous groups, such as the Centre for Women Rights, Nääxwiin. Moreover, international organizations and networks were also important allies, facilitating the participation of indigenous women in international meetings, forums, and workshops (Valladares de la Cruz, Reference Valladares de la Cruz2008).
The collaborations developed between indigenous women and feminist organizations were critical for the creation of networks for indigenous women leaders, as well as for the access to resources to promote women's rights and support organizing processes. These collaborations enhanced the analysis of gendered dynamics within indigenous organizations, opening of spaces where women were able to co-ordinate and determine political agendas.
Beyond the facilitating role that collaborations have had on the organizing processes of indigenous women in Mexico, collaborations have also taken various forms and have differently affected the construction of autonomous spaces. The collaborations are embedded in the intersection of multiple structures of oppression and thus have paradoxically both facilitated and constrained organizing processes. In many cases, these hierarchies have positioned indigenous women in secondary roles within organizations, thereby impeding organizational autonomy. Feminist and women's organizations continue to be predominantly led by mestizas, even in organizations where the principal goal is the promotion of indigenous women's rights.
Indigenous Women's Organizing in Chiapas
Indigenous women's organizing in Chiapas has received considerable attention, which is a direct consequence of the interest engendered by the Zapatista movement and in particular the role of gender in the movement's discourses. The Zapatista movement was instrumental in making indigenous women visible, as women's participation in previous movements had been limited to a secondary role since they were excluded from decisional spaces and leadership. Clearly the political and social context of Chiapas in the 1990s was an opportunity for indigenous women to co-ordinate previously isolated organizational processes, but also to organize what was going to be the national organization of indigenous women (Espinosa Damián; Reference Espinosa Damián2009). More than two decades later, however, the indigenous women's movement in Chiapas—beyond Zapatista women—is surprisingly disarticulated, as there is little collaboration between organizations working on similar issues or projects.
In 2010 indigenous women began a process of creating a state or subnational organization to represent and give voice to indigenous women's demands in Chiapas, outside the Zapatista movement and its organizations.Footnote 5 However, this has been more complex than in other states of Mexico, such as Guerrero and Oaxaca (Morales Hudon, Reference Morales Hudon2014). Although the indigenous women's national organization's goal of promoting state-level organizations has largely been realized in other regions, it has not in Chiapas, where the process is relatively recent and faces more obstacles.
Although the collaborations established with mestiza feminists were important for indigenous women's processes of articulating gender and indigeneity in the 1990s, collaborations were less successful in bringing about the development of independent organizational structures for indigenous women. Power relations between indigenous women and mestizas in Chiapas have delimited the participation of indigenous women and the representation of their interests within different social organizations where indigenous women work or with which they collaborate—constraining the development of independent organizing spaces.
Some feminist and women's organizations mobilized in solidarity with indigenous women for decades in Chiapas, particularly the Women's Rights Center of Chiapas (Centro de Derechos de la Mujer de Chiapas-CDMCH); Kinal Antzetik; and the Diocesan Council of Women (Coordinadora Diocesana de Mujeres-CODIMUJ). These organizations promoted women's rights by supporting indigenous women's projects and their participation in rural communities (Millán Moncayo, Reference Millán Moncayo and Hernández2008). Further, mestiza feminists played a pivotal role in the integration of indigenous women's demands in indigenous movements. For example, they were key allies of indigenous women in advocating for the integration of women's rights into the peace dialogues in 1995 and 1996 and in promoting the Zapatista Women's Revolutionary Law.Footnote 6
However, if these collaborations were key to strengthen indigenous women's organizing processes within the indigenous movement, this did not translate into a similar process within the feminist movement. The organizations with which indigenous women collaborated were shaped by power dynamics between mestizas and indigenous women, which was visible in the forms of participation and roles. The leaders of women's organizations supporting indigenous women's rights were not indigenous women, but mestizas. Moreover, indigenous women's participation within the women's and feminist movement was secondary. An example is the Women's State Convention in 1994, where the goal of the meeting was to “elaborate a program of strategic demands from a gender perspective; promote and fortify the structure and organization of women in the State of Chiapas” (Gil Tebar, Reference Gil Tebar1999: 38–39). This event took place in the context of Zapatista mobilizations, and therefore in a context where indigenous rights were central in social mobilizations, but indigenous women were not visible. As explained by Micaéla Hernández Meza, former co-ordinator of Jolom Mayaetik, an indigenous women's co-operative, indigenous women played a secondary role in the women's movement, particularly in the movement's meetings. Referring to the Women's State Convention, she recalls: “We were only accompanying in this meeting but did not give our opinion and all that, we were only seeing what happened” (interview, December 2011). That is, indigenous women were not at the forefront, even in a context of strong indigenous mobilizations that created opportunities for different social sectors to organize collectively.
This situation continues to prevail in Chiapas, for example, within the network aiming to co-ordinate women's political actions in the region, the Independent Women's Movement (Movimiento Independiente de Mujeres, MIM). The Indigenous women I interviewed in Chiapas reported that they do not really identify with the MIM, nor do they feel represented by it. One of the reasons cited for this lack of identification and representation was the MIM's organizational structure, particularly the power dynamics embedded within it and how they impact participation as well as representation. As a respondent pointed out, the MIM “arrives with a determined structure, they arrive with the agenda written and the agenda does not emerge from the [meetings]” (interview with Georgina Méndez, June 2011). Participating in a meeting on November 25 2010, that preceded a march for the International Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women, an event organized by one of the largest women's organization in Chiapas, I had the opportunity to observe that there was indeed little room for debate. The workshops operated according to a top-down model, where the co-ordinators and staff largely determined their priorities and objectives. Indigenous women who worked at the community level for the promotion of women's rights also attended the meeting. However, while these women were the ones doing concrete work in their communities, mestizas were the ones who facilitated the workshops and formulated the priorities. Mestizas had clear directions for the formulation of demands for the march, which took place the following day.
The interviews I conducted in Chiapas confirmed the observation that indigenous women do not have much influence over organizations working on the promotion of indigenous women's rights. As reported by Margarita Gutiérrez Romero, a founding member of CONAMI, “In Chiapas there are movements, there are a bunch of NGOs; however, indigenous women are not protagonists” (interview, June 2011). Mestizas co-ordinate most of the organizations working “with” indigenous women and “for” the defense of their rights, as Margarita Gutiérrez Romero explained: “They employ indigenous women but the latter are not the leaders and are not the protagonists” (interview, June 2011). This internal division of labour within women's groups reveals persistent hierarchies that constrain the participation and leadership of indigenous women. Many indigenous women work in these organizations, but largely as promoters; they are the ones doing work on the ground while more powerful decision-making positions are occupied by mestizas, who define agendas, organize campaigns, represent the organization and establish collaborations with other actors. Indeed, there are very few organizations led by indigenous women; in the majority of NGOs and civil associations, indigenous women do not hold representation and decisional positions.
Power relations between women have therefore restricted indigenous women's leadership positions and limited the consolidation of a regional indigenous women's movement. Indigenous women are not protagonists in state-level women's organizations in Chiapas nor in the indigenous movement (with the exception of the Zapatista movement). Consequently, this prevents them from collective participation in decisional spaces at the state level and from establishing stronger relationships with other indigenous women's organizations.
Indigenous Women's Organizing in Oaxaca
In contrast to the case of Chiapas, indigenous women in Oaxaca have created an autonomous state-level organization that co-ordinates indigenous women from different regions. They have effectively positioned themselves as actors with specific agendas, goals and a representational structure that is recognized both by local indigenous women's groups, different social organizations, and the state of Oaxaca (Becerril Albarrán and Bonfil, Reference Becerril Albarrán, Bonfil and Bonfil2012).
As in Chiapas, indigenous women collaborated closely with feminist and women's organizations to promote women's rights within indigenous organizations and communities, mainly through the implementation of projects to promote women's rights, as well as through the organization of workshops. Furthermore, the collaborations between feminist organizations and indigenous women led in some cases to the creation of local organizations of indigenous women. For example, the Grupo de Mujeres 8 de Marzo was formed in 2000 with the collaboration of feminist academics; in 2003 the Centro para los Derechos de la Mujer Nääxwiin was formed with the support of Comaletzin; and in 2005, the Red de Mujeres Mixes was formed with the collaboration of Consorcio, a feminist organization in Oaxaca.
As opposed to the case of Chiapas, where indigenous women were not represented in the broad women's movement, in Oaxaca indigenous women had a major presence. However, as in Chiapas there were tensions between women concerning the movement's priorities. As Sofia Robles explained (interview, July 2011), indigenous women had been invited to participate in spaces such as those that aimed at establishing a women's political agenda, to pressure the government during political transitions in Oaxaca. In such spaces, indigenous women faced obstacles in prioritizing the inclusion of their specific needs on the agenda. But even while such tensions existed, contrary to Chiapas, indigenous women in Oaxaca positioned themselves as independent actors with specific demands.
In their struggle for organizational autonomy, indigenous women in Oaxaca felt the need to redefine the forms of collaboration they undertook with other actors, challenging power relations at the organizational level, and particularly in forms of representation. As expressed by Dalí Angel Pérez, there have been instances where the involvement of mestizas displaced indigenous women leaders: “There have been compañeras Footnote 7 who arrived in indigenous communities to speak on behalf of indigenous women, to represent us, help us, support us … and we are grateful for their support because thanks to some of them indigenous women have achieved many things. But there are many who do not respect the fight or process that we have had as indigenous women. And there have been cases where they displaced the natural leaders and position themselves in those roles and we do not agree with that” (interview with Dalí Ángel Pérez, December 2011).
It is in reaction to such power dynamics that indigenous women in Oaxaca decided to create the Indigenous Women's Assembly of Oaxaca (AMIO). This was clearly expressed by one of the founder members of the AMIO, Flora Gutiérrez, who explains that “One of the resolutions was to create an autonomous space for us, where we no longer want others to speak on our behalf. They have spoken sufficiently. I think it was important that they spoke on our behalf because in one way or another, our voice, our words, needed to have resonance, someone had to speak on our behalf. But now that we are present, now we have to speak on our own behalf” (interview, April 2011).
In this effort to reclaim representation of their own peoples and interests, indigenous women also aimed to create autonomous spaces that were free of power relations between women. This was clearly explained by one of the founding member of AMIO, Sofia Robles: “We have alliances with women from social organization in Oaxaca, in Mexico, but we think that we need our own space as indigenous women because we feel that we come together as equals, with common conditions to discuss, to identify problems” (interview, July 2011).
What is clear from these quotations is the expression of a need to change the form of existing collaborations. Seeking to organize autonomously, indigenous women were no longer willing to accept that others—be they indigenous men or non-indigenous women—speak on their behalf. And this has had an impact on key debates such as the one over the articulation of women's and collective rights as indigenous women. Members of AMIO have challenged external actors' interventions and imposition of their categories, understandings and agendas. As explained by Flora Gutiérrez: “There are some things that are wrong in the system of customs and traditions that we need to modify but from our reality, not from outside, because this is what has happened” (interview, April 2011). This is clearly expressed by Carolina Vásquez who insists that “there is the need for us to elaborate our own terminology to work in communities, there is also the need to begin to theorize our own vision of gender” (interview, April 2011).
With the creation of AMIO, the first state level structure to define and promote an agenda by and for indigenous women in Oaxaca, indigenous women effectively positioned themselves as autonomous actors with specific demands and agendas. They created a regional organization that allows them to co-ordinate local groups and individuals, one that is recognized by indigenous women from different regions of Oaxaca as the one that advocates for their interests to the state and other social actors.
Contrasting Chiapas and Oaxaca
Contrasting the two organizing processes in Oaxaca and Chiapas reveals that in one case indigenous women found it necessary to define clear organizational boundaries to construct their autonomy, while in the other the redefinition of collaborations was not clear. In interviews conducted with indigenous women leaders in Oaxaca, it was apparent that the goal of creating an autonomous organization was to appoint indigenous women as the ones who would speak on their behalf. However, there is no consensus in Chiapas regarding the need—or lack thereof—to redefine boundaries towards the promotion of organizational autonomy.
Indeed, in Chiapas, there is no consensus on the question of whether indigenous women should create spaces exclusively for indigenous women. As Margarita Gutiérrez Romero explained, some women would like to integrate indigenous and non-indigenous women into their activities to construct alliances, while others argue for the need to have spaces reserved strictly for indigenous women. For Margarita Gutiérrez Romero, the creation of such spaces would be an important means of gaining leverage, as in the case of Oaxaca: “I always provoke them, let's see, when will you be autonomous and independent and will not have to ask permission to your supervisor who is non-indigenous? … It is not the same compañeras. Let's build something different” (interview, June 2011).
Despite the fact that many indigenous women in Chiapas criticized power relations within women's organizations and voiced the need for an autonomous space at the state level, there has not been a process to reconfigure the forms of collaboration with non-indigenous women organizations. Moreover, the obstacles indigenous women face in gaining leadership positions within women's organizations affect their capacity to transform power relations within these organizations, many of which paradoxically promote intersectional politics. The situation in Chiapas stands in marked contrast with the one in Oaxaca, where there appears to be more consensus on the need to redefine collaborations and construct alliances where indigenous women position themselves alongside non-indigenous women's organizations.
This redefinition of alliances seems to be a determining factor facilitating the development of organizational autonomy, as it gives them the possibility to hold leadership positions, determine their agendas and represent their own interests. These processes nonetheless remain complex, as they require indigenous women to contest power relations within the movements and organizations that have been allies in their struggles. The redefinition of alliances may threaten established practices and long friendships between allies, but it has proven to be essential in other cases for the development of concrete organizational autonomy.
Conclusion
A social movement's relationship to other social movements and actors is of critical importance because it affects the movement's organizational structure, mobilization, actions and discourses. Through the comparison of two indigenous women's organizing trajectories in Mexico, Chiapas and Oaxaca, I have illustrated how collaborations can facilitate organizing process while at the same time limit the creation of fully autonomous processes and spaces in the long term, largely due to power relations between actors, in this case class and colonial power relations.
It is clear that in the process of creating autonomous organizing spaces in Mexico, indigenous women challenged not only indigenous movements but also feminist organizations (Hernández Castillo, Reference Hernández Castillo2010). They also cleared a path towards the development of new forms of collaboration and alliances to position themselves as autonomous political actors, independent from indigenous and feminist organizations. Indigenous women's organizing in Oaxaca reveals how in the march towards organizational autonomy, organizations reposition themselves through a renegotiation of their collaborations with actors and movements that were earlier instrumental in their organizing processes, such as women's and feminist organizations, to stand as equals.
The analysis of indigenous women's organizing processes in Mexico sheds some light on the complexity of collaborations between movements, as well as the need to think critically about the impact of power relations on social movement dynamics, particularly when the sharing of common frames—such as women's rights—can render the power dynamics within collaborations invisible. The struggle for organizational autonomy involves challenging those collaborations that do not favour the positioning of indigenous women at the centre of struggles aiming to defend their rights. This process involves a redefinition of alliances that at some point were facilitators of the organizing process but can also represent obstacles for consolidating organizational autonomy. Allies, individuals and organizations alike, are not exempt from reproducing power relations, even those they aim to transform. It therefore seems important that actors diligently reflect on structural power relations and their impact on their organizational dynamics. When collaborations reproduce hierarchies, whether through roles assumed by actors, access to resources, forms of representation, this limits the development of organizational autonomy.
These observations generate important questions, both for future research as well as for social movement actors. It is clear that social movement organizations benefit greatly from alliances and collaborations. However, as argued by Grey, an alliance is “a strategic partnership, organized around specific projects, rather than a long-term unity” (Reference Grey2004: 17). Perceived as contextual and punctual, alliances and collaborations can effectively be key for mobilization and social movements. But “the tasks assumed by non-native feminists in such alliances call for humility, and absolutely demand that the terms of cooperation are dialogic” (Grey, Reference Grey2004: 17). This is of great importance considering that structural inequalities position individuals and organizations differently in coalition building, alliances and other forms of collaboration. Indeed, some actors could benefit and gain positive attention garnered by their support of other movements and actors, while others may find that their experiences and leadership are undermined. These situations benefit some at the expense of others and negatively affect the organizational dynamics of movements and their capacity to consolidate. For this reason, it is key to integrate not only an intersectional perspective into our analyses of social movements dynamics but as well to recognize the coloniality of social structures and its effects. As argued by Avin and colleagues in their proposition for a “greater engagement between native feminist theories and other feminisms” (Reference Arvin, Tuck and Morril2013: 10), the contributions of indigenous feminist theories offer new perspectives to think alliances, both theoretically and politically. To nurture fruitful alliances there is a necessity to constantly question organizing dynamics to challenge and disrupt the reproduction of colonialism: “Whatever that future brings in terms of alliance, non-native feminists must become, and strive to remain, cognizant of their own histories and the ‘baggage’ those histories carry into even the most constructive dialogues” (Grey Reference Grey2004: 19). The failure to do so leads to the perpetuation of asymmetrical power relations, organizational dependency, and the reproduction of privilege.
