On the eve of the American Civil War, the district surrounding Natchez, Mississippi was not only a vital epicenter of Southern cotton production, but also host to an enormously wealthy class of slave-owning planters who constituted perhaps the nation's greatest concentration of millionaires outside of New York City. Occupying the pinnacle of this Natchez slaveholding class was native Pennsylvanian Steven Duncan. Mary Jane Brazy's An American Planter: Steven Duncan of Antebellum Natchez and New York carefully traces Duncan's transformation from eastern blueblood to Mississippi transplant who not only dominated cotton and sugar production in Mississippi and Louisiana, but also developed far-flung business interests and political connections that reached nationwide. Brazy digs deeply into manuscript sources to reveal a complex man enmeshed in business networks that reached across the two worlds of the urban Northeast and agricultural Southwest, whose “uniqueness lies in part in his embodiment of both North and South at a crucial juncture in American history” (p. 158).
Brazy's chronologically arraigned effort offers a succinct overview of the unusual trajectory of Duncan's life, ably demonstrating that he may very well have been one of the wealthiest and most influential American planters by the Civil War era. It was unusual for a major southern slaveholder to emerge from the northeast, yet Duncan spent most of his early years in Pennsylvania before attending Dickinson College in his native Carlisle to become a medical doctor in the first decade of the nineteenth century. Duncan had wealthy relatives already residing in the newly established Mississippi Territory and moved to Natchez in 1808 to seek a career in the emerging economic opportunities of the Natchez District.
This study shows how Duncan displayed a sophisticated ability to network and create opportunities through his familial and business associations. After arriving in Natchez he established a successful medical practice, and soon “secured his place within the nascent power structure of Natchez” by marrying into an important and wealthy local “Nabob” planter family—and in the process became a cotton planter and slaveholder (p. 10). Duncan was a shrewd businessman and keen study of cotton agriculture, and quickly left medicine to become a full-time planter. He became a major player in the plantation elite, and within two decades built one of the largest portfolios of lands and slaves of any Natchez Nabob, owning over 13,000 acres on a dozen cotton and sugar plantations in four Louisiana parishes and three Mississippi counties—with almost 2,300 slaves.
Brazy offers in Duncan a powerful example of planter as capitalist. Duncan operated in a world in which slaveholding planters were capitalists by nature, that their activities were driven by rational economic choices, and that slave-driven agriculture was as good an investment or business as any available at the time. This work details the capitalistic endeavors Duncan engaged in, particularly the variety and diversity of his many business interests and investments. In addition to his southern agricultural holdings, Duncan owned property in the northeast and spent half of his time there, but also owned a host of other investments including northern railroad securities, stocks, bonds, and at one time a substantial stake in the Bank of Mississippi. For years Duncan served as the president of the Bank of Mississippi and wielded extraordinary economic power as a prime administrator and benefactor of this “banking monopoly,” occupying a perfect position to manipulate Mississippi economic and political concerns.
This work excels at delineating Duncan's familial, social, and business networks, illuminating how Duncan serves as a classic example of the power of social capital, to shape networks for power, advancement, and profit. Duncan had many powerful friends—including fellow Whig Henry Clay—and this work details Duncan's proclivity for lending large amounts of cash from his large reservoir of liquid assets to friends and associates, creating leverage over others and placing himself in a position of patronage. Brazy does not portray Duncan in a particularly favorable light as slave owner, painting him as a cynical nonpaternalist who viewed his chattel slaves as nothing more than an economic asset and a means to wealth, presented in juxtaposition to keen coverage of Duncan's reservations about the institution of slavery and his involvement in the state and national Colonization Societies to eventually return the blacks to Africa. The complexity and irony of Duncan's life as an American hybrid of both northern and southern loyalties is carefully followed through to the Civil War years, when Duncan took significant wartime losses in both Mississippi and Louisiana before he finally gave up his life in the South for good in 1863, residing in New York City until his demise in 1867.
Brazy's meticulously researched study draws upon a large number of manuscript collections, federal census schedules, and a host of county courthouses in Mississippi and Louisiana, to recreate Duncan's antebellum world and his networks of associations. Particularly impressive is Brazy's ability to ferret out the myriad records that demonstrate of the extent of Duncan's landholding and business transactions at the local level, revealing a large business empire that portrays Duncan as a diversified and shrewd capitalist. Some small concerns are evident however. In places Brazy's desire to portray Duncan's personal outlook and mental inner-workings seems to lend itself to a certain level of conjecture. Also, Brazy makes much of Duncan's diverse business holdings and investments beyond his agricultural business, yet names no specific examples of the Northern stocks or bonds he held; a better example can be found in an older survey by D. Clayton James (Antebellum Natchez. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1968: 150–53). But this is an important book that provides impressive social-economic history, and makes a valuable contribution to the growing scholarship on the antebellum Southern slaveholding planter class.
