Ernest P. Young's history of the French Religious Protectorate in China is the best existing overall analysis of how France claimed for some 100 years (1844–1946) to be the guardian of all Catholic peoples and properties in China. This masterpiece of scholarly research weaves together a vast number of documents in French, Chinese, Latin, and Italian, creating a narrative that is sad and disturbing at times, but altogether fascinating and compelling. Conjured by French diplomats as essential to France's prominence in China, reinforced by demands for help from Catholic missionary bishops, the “Religious Protectorate,” as it is referred to in French official documents, became an institutionalized policy of France. Young's calling it an “Ecclesiastical Colony” is therefore both clever and accurate.
Young describes how while the Portuguese ecclesiastical jurisdiction (Padroado) over China was coming to an end, and the Vatican was attempting to stitch together the remnants of an eighteenth-century native Chinese Church, France stepped in to claim the role of de facto protector of the Catholic Church on Chinese soil. Through a mix of diplomacy and forceful coercion spanning the period from the 1844 treaty of Whampoa (Huangpu) to the 1895 Gérard Convention, the French government established the juridical basis that legalized the practice of Christianity, allowed proselytism by foreign missionaries, and protected Chinese converts throughout China. Young shows how much the international Catholic missionary community relied on this protection and benefited from it. In fact, it was this reliance on French protection that helped France maintain a prominent position among foreign powers in China. France's desire to maintain this privileged role also meant that it vigorously opposed attempts by China and the Vatican to establish diplomatic relations with each other.
Because French authorities in China considered the Protectorate so crucial to France's influence there, they more than once acceded to dubious requests from missionaries, threatened China with the use of force, and exacted extravagant compensations from the Chinese government for proven or alleged losses by missionaries and Chinese Christians. In the early twentieth century, internal opposition to this collusion between French authorities and the foreign-led Catholic Church began to emerge. Notable detractors included Chinese Catholic intellectuals like Ying Lianzhi and Ma Xiangbo as well as a group of foreign and Chinese priests led by Fathers Vincent Lebbe and Anthony Cotta. Although the impetus for this dissident movement was its opposition to the 1916 French land-grab of an area of Tianjin known as Laoxikai, its central proposition was that the link between France and the foreign-run church was prejudicial to an in-depth evangelization of China. The church needed to distance itself from French policy and allow the rise of a Chinese Church led by Chinese bishops. By calling for a Chinese episcopacy, the dissenters directly contradicted the logic of a French protectorate that depended on a foreign Catholic hierarchy to justify its existence. Their arguments also threatened the hold of foreign-led missionary societies over Chinese mission territories and the wealth they had accumulated.
Although French officials and many foreign bishops and missionaries tried to repress and disparage the opposition, the pleas of the dissenting laymen and priests reached sympathetic ears in the Vatican, which consequently enacted changes in policy.
Benedict XV sent Archbishop Celso Costantini as apostolic delegate to China in 1922, and Pius XI consecrated six Chinese bishops in 1926. In 1943, the Chinese government dispatched an ambassador to the Vatican, and three years later Pius XII sent an internuncio to China. The French Protectorate in one form or another still managed to survive until 1946, when the French government formally renounced its old treaty rights and its concessions. That same year, Pius XII appointed the first-ever Chinese cardinal and replaced apostolic vicariates with dioceses, thereby elevating most of China from mission territory to local church. Yet the sinicization of the hierarchy proceeded at a slow pace. By 1948, fewer than thirty-five of these dioceses were headed by Chinese prelates.
Rightly so, Young spends many pages analyzing the important role of Father Lebbe in this process of sinicization. His portrayal of Lebbe is well balanced, giving equal treatment to the Belgian missionary and his detractors and pointing to the strengths and weaknesses of each party. Young also aptly describes the importance of the papal apostolic letter Maximum Illud and the encyclical Rerum Ecclesiae. However, he neglects the letter of admonition Ad Ipsis Pontificatus Primordiis that Pius XI notably addressed in June 1926 to the bishops of China. The pope declared that his recent encyclical Rerum Ecclesiae was written primarily with the situation of the church in China in mind. He deplored abuses found in that church and spoke against the slow responses of its leadership. Pius XI could not have been clearer in his support of the indigenization of the Chinese Church. Four months later, he further emphasized his position by personally consecrating six Chinese bishops.
The success of the French Protectorate often hinged on subtle, yet hardheaded tactics; as French authorities were quick to point out, the Religious Protectorate had not been conferred by the pope but had been obtained from China by the might of French arms and the cunning of French diplomats. There are spots where Young's narrative could have highlighted the nuances of diplomatic wrangling more clearly. For example, he should have mentioned that Théodose de Lagrené bypassed his original instructions because the diplomat realized that France, with an annual commerce with China of barely two million francs, would gain little with a treaty like the ones signed by Britain and the United States. Lagrené's success in weaving moral and religious issues into negotiations led to the imperial rescript of 1844 and the imperial decree of 1846 at the root of the French Protectorate over Christianity in China. He might also have mentioned the role of Zhéphyrin Guillemin, bishop of Guangdong and Guangxi, in pressuring Napoléon III to declare war on China after the murder of Father Auguste Chapdelaine in 1856. Similarly, Young's treatment of Bishop Johann Baptist Anzer, which tends towards caricature, could have been more factual.
Although Young relies on an imposing array of sources, may I suggest that his research would have been further enriched by making use of relevant articles I penned, such as “The Legacy of Father Vincent Lebbe” (International Bulletin of Missionary Research, January 1999), or “Bringing Christ to the Nations: Shifting Models of Mission in China” (The Catholic Historical Review, October 1997). I am also surprised that Young did not seem to be aware of my Ph.D. dissertation (Catholic Activities in Kwangtung Province and Chinese Responses, 1848-1885, University of Washington, 1977), even though his analysis of the emergence and development of the French Religious Protectorate closely coincides with this earlier study.
A map or two in addition to the photographs provided would have facilitated the reader's understanding of the many sites discussed.
