During the Nehru years (1947–64) and beyond, despite India's stated commitment to a foreign policy based on the principles of nonalignment and Gandhian nonviolence, it did not stop New Delhi from conducting a “peaceful nuclear explosion” in 1974—thereby joining the elite nuclear club made up of the United States, the Soviet Union, the United Kingdom, France, and China. As Anderson's exhaustive and richly textured account shows, however, the foundations of the technological and managerial expertise that went into producing the Indian bomb were laid many decades earlier, going as far back as the 1920s.
To tell this long forgotten, yet important and inspiring story of “why India developed an atomic bomb, … how this was done, by whom, and with what means and objectives,” (p. 4) the author had to begin literally from scratch. As the preface notes, the author's interest in Indian science, scientists, and key policymakers was kindled several decades ago, and in what clearly became his labor of love, Anderson has doggedly pursued the subject ever since—and how very fortunate for us that he did. The author's many years of painstaking toil, during which he dug deep, unearthing every bit of research and following every bit of lead there is on the topic, has allowed him to piece together a truly seminal account of the intricate relationships that developed between the Indian scientific and technocratic establishment, the domestic institutional arrangements under which these scientists worked, the many international networks they collaborated and interacted with, and the complex interpersonal relationships they diligently cultivated with those in power.
Most insightful and gripping are the vivid and nuanced portraits of the extraordinary individual personalities whom the author aptly refers to as the “nucleus” consisting of a small group of influential scientists behind the formative Indian science and nuclear program. These include the eminent physicist and first chair of India's Atomic Energy Commission Homi Bhabha, his successor, Vikram Sarabhai, distinguished mathematician P. C. Mahalanobis, and equally renowned (yet lesser-known and long overshadowed) scientists like Meghnad Saha, Shanti Bhatnagar, C. V. Raman, K. S. Krishnan, and many other personalities working quietly behind the scenes. Anderson lucidly and compellingly illustrates, how, despite the many domestic and international constraints they faced, these determined, spirited, ambitious, and often self-interested individuals, especially Bhabha, were still able to create quality, indeed, world-renowned scientific and technological institutions.
They were able to achieve this, in large measure, because their broad view of what constituted a “scientific community” not only included physicists, but also legions of highly accomplished chemists, mathematicians, astronomers, engineers, doctors, and technicians. Equally fascinating are the author's accounts of the complex and intricate relationships these individuals developed with influential political leaders like prime ministers Jawaharlal Nehru and Indira Gandhi, and how the scientific community, both willingly and unwittingly, became part of Nehru's ambitious nationalist project to transform India into a self-reliant, modern industrial and scientific power. Anderson compellingly shows “that there would not have been a sustained atomic energy program without a coevolving relationship between science and politics, which resulted in a large scientific community. A single political party and four prime ministers—all closely related (two were Nehrus)—were responsible for the justification for and furtherance of ‘the scientific community’ and the atomic energy program within it through to 1980, the end of the book” (p. 17). Moreover, Anderson provides a rich and insightful discussion of the “creative tension running through the Indian scientific community between the idea of science as a movement and science as an institution” (pp. 538–39, italics in the original), and its varied intended and unintended ramifications.
Nucleus and Nation is a scholarly masterpiece—an indispensable text. Anderson fills in a huge scholarly gap by telling a big, complex, fascinating, and important story exceedingly well—with a judicious mix of empathy and a scholar's critical distance. This highly accessible, nuanced, balanced, thoroughly researched, profoundly thought-provoking, and lucidly written book should be a “must read” for anyone interested in science, nuclear power, technology, colonialism, or modern Indian politics.
