Obama's nomination of Broadway producer Rocco Landesman to head the National Endowment for the Arts once again links the federal government to professional theatre. As soon as his name was made public, however, concerns were raised about his suitability as a guardian of public artworks, given his background of producing plays for profit. It seemed unprecedented that commercial theatre and federal arts programs could find common ground. Yet he had championed works by Tony Kushner and August Wilson, bringing Angels in America from the Public Theatre to Broadway, for instance, suggesting he will be attentive to artists, arts organizations, and audiences. Landsman's nomination at this moment of economic disaster second only to the Great Depression recalls the enormous but brief investment in the arts made possible by the New Deal's Federal Arts Projects, usually considered unique in the history of the United States. However, an interest by the federal government in theatre dates to the Liberty Theatres dotting WWI-era army bases. Weldon B. Durham's Liberty Theatres of the United States Army, 1917–1919 and Ilka Saal's New Deal Theater: The Vernacular Tradition in American Political Theater, though very different in tone and method, offer insights into the odd logics behind two twentieth-century American forays into state-sponsored (and thus political) performance.
With its association to burlesque, vaudeville, and minstrel, theatre in America has always held a certain risqué and populist sensibility—often at odds with civic campaigns. Yet it was precisely this legacy that brought theatre to several military bases in 1917. Designed to provide a “constructive” alternative to honkytonks, Liberty Theatres were devised by the education section of the United States Army through the War Department's Commission on Training Camp Activities (CTCA), under the leadership of Raymond Fosdick, as tools to “uplift” morale and morals among bored troops soon to be mobilized overseas. Theatre historian Weldon Durham details how Progressive-era concerns over the commercialization of theatre, which limited the concept of community plays by turning the public into consumers rather than participants, were hastened by the advent of motion pictures. These fears fed plans to control draftees after Wilson entered the war. With a captive audience of hundreds of thousands of working-class men, drafted from farms and cities and far less educated than expected, the Training Camp Activities were designed “to police the camps and supply recreation programs” by insuring that wholesome recreation would keep draftees busy during leisure time (41). Almost fifty Liberty Theatres were constructed on bases across the country, bringing musicals, melodramas, and domestic comedies by Broadway professionals, touring shows, and stock companies; these joined impersonators, soldiers' talent shows, Chautauqua tent lectures by the Red Cross, and D. W. Griffith's Intolerance to provide wholesome entertainment. Theatres would be more playgrounds than cabarets.
This microhistory, based on Durham's extensive research at the National Archives, details how the War Department tried and ultimately failed to emulate the settlement house movement's use of pageant and community plays to instill a sense of citizenship among urban immigrants. Tensions over professionalism and amateur volunteers, commerce and community, patriotism and subversion, as well as the speed of the war's end and the influenza epidemic contributed to the demise of these federally funded theatres, because the needs of the armed services were often at odds with those of theatre professionals—actors, stagehands, and producers—recruited to develop the Liberty Theatres. Nevertheless, the legacy of government sponsorship of the arts as part of a concerted effort at social amelioration—either for audiences or practitioners—permeated the armed services, and ultimately contributed to enabling Federal Project Number One, which comprised the New Deal's arts projects, including the Federal Theatre Project.
Hallie Flanagan, the brilliant mother of the FTP, whose background in community experimental theatre at Vassar matched Fosdick's (who came from Henry Street Settlement to the CTCA), understood how to fashion an American political theatre from exactly the same residues of melodrama, pageantry, and social welfare that animated the Liberty Theatres. Ilka Saal's inquiry into New Deal theatre does not offer the usual history of the FTP, Living Newspapers, or the Group Theatre, and so on. Instead, relying on her extensive knowledge of the history of European avant-garde theatre—from Piscator to Brecht—Saal demonstrates how the New Deal theatre projects, especially those receiving government funding through the FTP, played to middlebrow American sensibilities by converting estrangement into empathy, abstraction into verisimilitude: in short, using the tradition of melodrama and its serialized popular forms on radio and in the movies to enter into a comfortable vernacular recognizable to working-class militants and middle-class reformers alike.
Much of this material has been thoroughly analyzed by Wendy Smith (Real Life Drama: The Group Theatre and America, 1931–1940 [1990]) and Colette A. Hyman (Staging Strikes: Workers' Theatre and the American Labor Movement [1997]), both curiously ignored by Saal. Still, what Saal brings to this study is a close archival analysis of Brecht's first foray into Broadway, with the 1935 production of The Mother, in which the play was derailed from a critique of capitalism and war to become a sentimental tale yoked more to Al Jolson's plea to his “Mammy” in The Jazz Singer (1927) than to Gorky. Likewise, through reading drafts of Pins and Needles, the 1937 musical production by the ILGWU (International Ladies' Garment Workers Union), Saal shows how successfully the play's producers relied on both workers' agit-prop theatre and music-hall acts to convert a strike into a fun-filled frolic for nonprofessional actors and audiences alike. In both cases, she bemoans how political theatre became vernacular.
Ironically, the closest the FTP and other “political theatre” of the 1930s came to European ideals of avant-gardism occurred by happenstance at the premiere of Marc Blitzstein's musical The Cradle Will Rock. After its opening on 16 June 1937, the production was abruptly halted by a federal decree that no FTP performances occur before the new fiscal year began on July 1. Orson Welles and John Houseman, the play's producer-directors, clearly understood this brazen act—federal marshals padlocked the Maxine Elliott Theatre—as censorship; they spontaneously rented an empty theatre twenty blocks away and staged one of the legendary events of U.S. theatre history by marching actors, stagehands, and audience through midtown Manhattan to the bare stage of the Venice Theatre. There, Blitzstein sat down at the piano and sang the first number when Actors' Equity and the Musicians' Union balked at allowing the performance under nonunion conditions; he was joined from the balcony by the voices of the actors dispersed among the audience, turning this “incidental minimalism” into a riveting stage event (114).
Saal sees this momentary break from melodrama's conventions, even if the plot itself owes much to melodrama, as an aberration during the 1930s, one that was trapped in left-wing middlebrow aesthetics. However, it ultimately contributed to what she views as a reflowering of genuine “political theatre” during the 1960s in the street theatre and puppetry of El Teatro Campesino in California and the Bread and Puppet Theatre of New York (now in Vermont). For Saal, these theatrical movements—themselves tied to political movements: the United Farm Workers and antiwar organizing—meld the American vernacular traditions with avant-gardist stagings, offering another way of conceiving modernism and arguing against U.S. government intervention into art. Both books suggest that past attempts to bring federal funding to theatre were ultimately mired in bourgeois taste and in fears of importing un-American activities and methods.
