The last decade has witnessed a substantial broadening and deepening of the analysis of science, technology and academic institutions under National Socialism. The former Kaiser Wilhelm Society, the German Research Foundation, the German Physical Society and various other organizations have all decided to have professional teams of historians work on their pasts, devoting special attention to any possible misconduct during the German dictatorship and to sociopolitical continuities persisting into the post-war era. The museums for science, technology, medicine and related fields had hitherto been an exception to this trend. Therefore this anthology of eighteen papers on the history of the Deutsches Museum in Munich (DMM) is a pioneering study – p. 23 provides a survey of ongoing projects to study other museums. Most of the authors are curators at the museum, Germany's largest and oldest for the history of science and technology. A few contributions come from outside historians, such as Wolfgang Benz and Wolfgang König (both from the Technische Universität in Berlin). This brief review will summarize just a few of the anthology's main findings.
Given the fact that Munich was arguably the centre of the Nazi movement, it is no surprise to learn that the DMM did not escape tendencies and pressures to realign itself politically after 1933. From the 181 co-workers of this institution, only four had to leave after the National Socialists rose to power because they were either Jewish or politically ‘unreliable’ (p. 29); roughly fifty became party members (pp. 14, 118), across all layers of this strictly hierarchically structured institution, from technicians to curators and librarians. After the Nazi regime collapsed in 1945, only thirty low-ranking employees of the then remaining 150 had to leave (p. 58). None of the top-level administrators and representatives (like Jonathan Zenneck, who features in special studies in this anthology) were among those dismissed. Until very recently, the myth of an ‘apolitical’ attitude and merely functional adaptation was still alive, which is part of the explanation why this study was begun so late despite such an obvious and urgent need for it.
De facto, many things changed at the DMM during the years of National Socialism: Jews were forbidden access to the library and museum (p. 272), their books were relegated to a dark corner of the library or removed completely (pp. 32, 276), Jewish members of the Board were exchanged, and certain exhibits in the museum were removed. More striking than these negative measures is the direct influence of Nazi ideology on the form and content of the exhibits. The latter is vividly illustrated throughout the volume, not only textually, but also in photos that have been preserved: Hitler inspecting a display of polished German stone samples (highly important for his gigantomanic building projects); special displays of substitute materials (a big theme for an autarkic economy); a new hall for car and truck displays complete with highway settings (consonant with the Nazi emphasis on mobility); and finally even special shows of purely political propaganda, most prominently in 1937–1938 on the ‘Eternal Jew’. Precisely this infamous exhibition attracted 412,000 visitors to the DMM (pp. 38, 672), a figure amplified by regularly organized bus tours funded by the Nazi ‘Kraft durch Freude’ social organization (p. 74). All of the above amounted to the DMM becoming a cogwheel in the propaganda machinery of the Third Reich despite its self-image as a pure promoter of factual and historical information on scientific and technical issues. How long this heavy burden of complicity in a nationalistic ideology lasted is exemplified by the tortuous path taken over the issue of mounting a bust of Einstein in the museum's hall of fame, the centre of this museum's symbolic politics. When this gap, felt by many soon after the end of the Second World War, was finally filled in 1972, the subtext ‘forced into emigration in 1933’ that Einstein's estate executor and representatives of the Weizmann Institute had demanded was deliberately omitted (p. 358).
Altogether, the anthology under review is of considerable merit and value to anyone interested in instutional history and/or the history of the Nazi period and its aftermath. I recommend it especially to people interested in the history and politics of museums of science and technology, and of museum displays more generally.
