Published online by Cambridge University Press: 29 March 2005
One of the most entrenched commandments in medicine is: “Never take away a patient's hope!” Often it is issued during the treatment of a terminally ill patient to spur and justify the continuation of aggressive life-prolonging efforts. Hope has been called one of a patient‘s “most powerful internal resources,” and “a powerful ally, our last defense against despair.” One editorialist confidently stated: “[C]ommunicating hope can improve patients’ prognosis.”
One of the most entrenched commandments in medicine is: “Never take away a patient's hope!” Often it is issued during the treatment of a terminally ill patient to spur and justify the continuation of aggressive life-prolonging efforts. Hope has been called one of a patient‘s “most powerful internal resources,”1
Johnson LH, Dahlen R, Roberts SL. Supporting hope in congestive heart failure patients. Dimensions in Critical Care Nursing 1997;16:65–78.
Bone RC. Benediction: A farewell to my medical colleagues. The Journal of Critical Illness 1997;12(7):139–40.
Ubel A. Truth in the most optimistic way. Annals of Internal Medicine 2001;134:1142–3.
Advocates claim that hope, optimism, and a “will to live” prolong life.4
Maruta T, Colligan RC, Malinchoc M, Offord KP. Optimists vs. pessimists: Survival rate among medical patients over a 30-year period. Mayo Clinic Proceedings 2000;75:140–3; Levy BR, Slade MD, Kunkel SR, Kasl SV. Longevity increased by positive self-perceptions of aging. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2002;83:261–70.
Stern SL, Dhanda R, Hazuda HP. Hopelessness predicts mortality in older Mexican and European Americans. Psychosomatic Medicine 2001;63:344–51.
Reed GM, Kemeny ME, Taylor SE, Wang H-YJ, Visscher BR. Realistic acceptance as a predictor of decreased survival time in gay men with AIDS. Health Psychology 1994;13(4):299–307.
Taylor SE, Kemeny ME, Reed GM, Bower JE, Gruenewald TL. Psychological resources, positive illusions, and health. American Psychologist 2000:55(1):99–109.
In fact, none of the above claims stand up to careful scrutiny with respect to serious illness.8
Affleck G, Tennen H. Construing benefits from adversity: Adaptational significance and dispositional underpinnings. Journal of Personality 1996;64(4):899–922; Rabkin JG, Ferrando SJ, Lin S-H, Sewell M, McElhiney M. Psychological effects of HAART: A 2-year study. Psychosomatic Medicine 2000:62:413–22.
Greer S, Morris T, Pettingale KW. Psychological response to breast cancer: Effect on outcome. The Lancet 1979;2:785–7.
Watson M, Haviland JS, Greer S, Davidson J, Bliss JM. Influence of psychological response on survival in breast cancer: A population-based cohort study. The Lancet 1999;354:1331–6.
Cassileth BR, Lusk EJ, Miller DS, Brown LL, Miller C. Psychosocial correlates of survival in advanced malignant disease? New England Journal of Medicine 1985;312:1551–5.
Petticrew M, Bell R, Hunter D. Influence of psychological coping on survival and recurrence in people with cancer: Systematic review. BMJ 2002;325:1066–76.
See note 12, Petticrew, Bell, Hunter 2002.
Angell M. Disease as a reflection of the psyche. New England Journal of Medicine 1985;312:1570–2.
The belief in the medical value of hope15
Cutliffe JR, Herth KA. The concept of hope in nursing 5: Hope and critical care nursing. British Journal of Nursing 2002;11(18):1190–5; Cutcliffe JR, Herth K. The concept of hope in nursing 1: Its origins, background and nature. British Journal of Nursing 2002;11(12):832–40.
Kutner JS, Steiner JF, Corbett KK, Jahnigen DW, Barton PL. Information needs in terminal illness. Social Science & Medicine 1999;48:1341–52.
See note 3, Ubel 2001.
Referring to what are acknowledged to be overlapping psychological states, some psychologists have tried to distinguish hope, an “'emergent property' engendered by serious, or persistent illness and other profound life challenges,” from optimism, which mediates “more routine or minor hassles.”18
Scioli A, Chamberlin CM, Samor CM, Lapointe AB, Campbell TL, Macleod AR, McLennon J. A prospective study of hope, optimism, and health. Psychological Reports 1997;81:723–35.
Optimistic bias, the tendency to believe that one is immune from laws of chance, might “seriously hinder efforts to promote risk-reducing behaviors.”19
Weinstein ND. Optimistic biases about personal risks. Science 1989;246:1232–3.
Scheier MF, Carver CS. Optimism, coping, and health: Assessment and implications of generalized outcome expectancies. Health Psychology 1985;4(3):219–47.
See note 8, Rabkin, Ferrando, Lin, Sewell, McElhiney 2000.
Brody H, Lynn J. The physician's responsibility under the new Medicare reimbursement for hospice care. New England Journal of Medicine 1984;310:920–2; Parkes CM. Commentary: Prognoses should be based on proved indices not intuition. BMJ 2000;320:473; Wolfe J, Klar N, Grier HE, Duncan J, Salem-Schatz S, Emanuel EJ, Weeks JC. Understanding of prognosis among parents of children who died of cancer: Impact on treatment goals and integration of palliative care. JAMA 2000;284:2469–75; Pearlman RA. Inaccurate predictions of life expectancy. Archives of Internal Medicine 1988;148:2537–8.
Christakis NA, Escarce JJ. Survival of Medicare patients after enrollment in Hospice programs. New England Journal of Medicine 1996;225:172–8.
These are only speculative concerns, of course. But there is also empirical evidence to suggest that unrealistic hope in a dying patient does cause harm. For example, SUPPORT researchers found that critically ill patients whose own prognostic estimates exceeded their physicians' prognostic estimates demanded more aggressive and invasive life-sustaining treatments than did patients with more realistic estimates of their prognoses. Increasing these aggressive and invasive treatments only increased burdens and harms—rather than maximizing comfort—without improving hospital survival in the slightest.24
Weeks JC, Cook EF, O'Day SJ, et al. Relationship between cancer patients' predictions of prognosis and their treatment preferences. JAMA 1998;279:1709–14; Phillips RS, Wenger NS, Teno J, Oye RK, Younger S, Califf R, Layde P. Choices of seriously ill patients about cardiopulmonary resuscitation: Correlates and outcomes. American Journal of Medicine 1996;100:128–37.
Grasping at hope is understandable—patients want to be cured. Unfortunately, most patients obtain their hope from dubious sources, particularly television and the misinformation highway known as the Internet. For example, success rates for CPR on popular shows like ER, Chicago Hope, and Rescue 911 are “significantly higher than the most optimistic survival rates in the medical literature.”25
Diem SJ, Lantos JD, Tulsky JA. Cardiopulmonary resuscitation on television—Miracles and misinformation. New England Journal of Medicine 1996;334:1578–82.
Murphy DJ, Burrows D, Santilli S, Kemp AW, Tenner S, Kreling B, Teno J. The influence of the probability of survival on patients' preferences regarding cardiopulmonary resuscitation. New England Journal of Medicine 1994;330:545–9; Schonwetter RS, Walker RM, Kramer DR, Robinson BE. Resuscitation decision making in the elderly: The value of outcome data. Journal of General Internal Medicine 1993;8:295–300.
Lack of knowledge and denial, perhaps “reinforced unwittingly by the physician,” may also account for unrealistic hope of cure and belief in quack therapies by many patients with metastatic cancer.27
Eidinger RN, Schapira DV. Cancer patients insight into their treatment, prognosis, and unconventional therapies. Cancer 1984;53:2736–40.
Andrykowski MA, Brady MJ, Greiner CB, Almaier EM, Burish TG, Antin JH, et al. “Returning to normal” following bone marrow transplantation: Outcomes expectations and informed consent. Bone Marrow Transplantation 1995;15:573–81.
Several research groups report that physicians hold more pessimistic prognoses than do their seriously ill patients.29
Mackillop WJ, Steward WE, Ginsburg AD, Stewart SS. Cancer patients' perceptions of their disease and its treatment. British Journal of Cancer 1988;58:355–8; Lee SJ, Fairclough D, Antin HJ, Weeks JC. Discrepancies between patient and physician estimates for the success of stem cell transplantation. JAMA 2001;285:1034–8; Arkes HR, Dawson NV, Speroff T, Harrell FE, Alzola C, Phillips R, et al. The covariance decomposition of the probability score and its use in evaluating prognostic estimates. Medical Decision Making 1995;15:120–31.
Perkins HS, Jonsen AR, Epstein WV. Providers as predictors: Using outcome predictions in intensive care. Critical Care Medicine 1986;14(2):105–10; Heyse-Moore LH, JohnsonBell VE. Can doctors accurately predict the life expectancy of patients with terminal cancer? Palliative Medicine 1987;1:165–6; Christakis NA, Lamont EB. Extent and determinants of error in doctors' prognoses in terminally ill patients: Prospective cohort study. British Medical Journal 2000;320:469–72.
Wilson DK, Kaplan RM, Schneiderman LJ. Framing of decisions and selections of alternatives in health care. Social Behavior 1987;2:51–9; Pearlman RA. Variability in physician estimates of survival for acute respiratory failure in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Chest 1987;91(4):515–21; Zimmerman JE, Knaus WA, Sharpe SM, Anderson AS, Draper EA, Wagner DP. The use and implications of do not resuscitate order in Intensive Care Units. JAMA 1986;255:351–6.
Physicians sometimes intentionally mislead their patients,32
Christakis NA, Iwashyna TJ. Attitude and self-reported practice regarding prognostication in a national sample of internists. Archives of Internal Medicine 1998;158: 2389–95; Lamont EB, Christakis NA. Prognostic disclosure to patients with cancer near the end of life. Annals of Internal Medicine 2001;134:1096–105.
See note 31, Zimmerman, Knaus, Sharpe, Anderson, Draper, Wagner 1986.
See note 32, Christakis, Iwashyna 1998.
Several explanations have been offered for this tendency of physicians to accentuate the positive, including a reluctance “to acknowledge that patients they know well are close to death;”35
Smith JL. Commentary: Why do doctors overestimate? British Medical Journal 2000;320:472–3.
Poses RM, McClish DK, Bekes C, Scott WE, Morley JN. Ego bias, reverse ego bias, and physicians' prognostic Critical Care Medicine 1991;19(12):1533–9.
Lynn J, Teno JM, Harrell FE. Accurate prognostications of death: Opportunities and challenges for clinicians. Western Journal of Medicine 1995;163:250–7.
As already noted, hope is almost always promoted for its impact on a single dimension—life prolongation. In a thoughtful commentary, Christopher suggests “we distort the meaning of hope when we make it depend on the possibility of physical survival,”38
Christopher M. My mother's gift—The link between honesty and hope. Bioethics Forum 1999:15(1):5–13.
A oft-cited testimonial to the life-prolonging effect of hope is Viktor Frankl's description of his experiences in the Nazi concentration camps.39
Frankl V. Man's Search for Meaning. Boston: Beacon Press; 1962.
Frankl VE. Man's Search for Ultimate Meaning. Cambridge, Mass.: Perseus Publishing; 2000 at p. 139.
See note 40, Frankl 2000.
Ezzy explored this notion of hope-as-meaning in the narratives HIV patients use to make sense of their life-threatening illness.42
Ezzy D. Illness narratives: Time, hope and HIV. Social Science and Medicine. 2000;50(5):605–17.
Linear restitution narratives are characterized as clinging to normal life goals and expectations in spite of the disease. Hope for these patients focuses on specific future objectives, like seeing a child grow up and get married, and depends on an optimistic bias that empirically derived prognostic probabilities do not apply to them. Their expectation (and hope) is that normal life will go on for many years by means of successful—and sometimes miraculous—medical interventions. These patients, often in unpremeditated collusion with their physicians, maintain their hope by denying the possibility of death.
Linear chaotic narratives, as the name implies, are characterized by anger and despair because their promising, often idealized, life has been fractured and destroyed by illness. These patients have no hope for the future, no explanatory narrative, no simple organizing principle around which to integrate their experience. To them reality is a meaningless chaos. But, as Ezzy points out, underlying that chaotic narrative is an implied belief in a lost and longed-for linear narrative “as an ideal, or an imagined solution that would resolve the chaos of the present.”43
See note 42, Ezzy 2000.
Neither of the above two narratives serves their owners well. Seemingly at opposite poles, both are, in the most important sense, unrealistic, and therefore unhelpful. The most beneficial form of hope is based on a polyphonic narrative. As the name implies, patients who discover and accept this form of narrative are “many voiced.” Rather than focusing on preexisting milestones, these patients are open to “uncertainty about the future, a more communally oriented morality and politics, and an acceptance of the reality of death at some stage in the future.”44
See note 42, Ezzy 2000.
See note 42, Ezzy 2000.
I believe that the difficult but essential task for physicians in the modern medical era is to discard the conventional, narrow view of hope as a means to prolong life. That version of hope is perilous. Rather, hope should provide a wider illumination. For the physician that means revealing to the patient the best in the life that is left and assuring that when it is inevitable the exit will be a good death. Is that not the hope we all hope for?