In Nicaragua: Navigating the Politics of Democracy, the political scientist David Close discusses the four moments of political transition that have occurred in Nicaragua since 1979, the year of the Sandinista Revolution. These moments of transition, the author underlines, were more than simple changes of government. Rather, they were ‘full-scale makeovers of the political system’ that drastically changed the way the Nicaraguan state functioned (p. 4). Relying on political theory and case studies, Close traces how the two regime changes that occurred in 1979 and 1984 brought Nicaragua closer to democracy, while the last two moments of political transition, in 2000 and 2011, ‘moved away from democracy’ (p. 2). The book's narrative of how the power to govern Nicaragua slowly became concentrated in the hands of one man is particularly relevant seen in the context of Nicaragua's most recent election in November 2016, which allowed Daniel Ortega to embark on his third consecutive term in office. What is more, using a comparative perspective the author challenges the reader to think about the complex question of how it is possible that ‘political leaders can, given the right circumstances, overcome institutions designed to favour democracy’ (p. 163).
Indeed, Daniel Ortega, the former guerrilla commander and current president, is the central figure of this book, as he appears to have impacted all the major turning points in recent Nicaraguan history. Already in the late 1970s, as a left-wing revolutionary fighting for the Frente Sandinista de Liberación Nacional (Sandinista National Liberation Front, FSLN), Ortega played a key – although perhaps not a crucial – role in the overthrow of the Somoza dictatorship. Only five years later, after an intense and highly scrutinised election campaign, Daniel Ortega became Nicaragua's first democratically elected president in almost half a century. Although his Sandinista party lost power in the elections of 1990, Ortega continued to dominate the country's political landscape as ‘the personification’ of the Sandinistas (p. 187). Surprisingly, as Close describes in detail in the sixth chapter of the book, Ortega managed to get back into power through a pact with his former enemy Arnoldo Alemán, the leader of the Liberal Party (p. 114). The ‘power-sharing duopoly’ between Ortega and Alemán lasted until 2011 when, after the Liberals received only 5.9 per cent of the vote and Sandinistas won with a landslide of 62.5 per cent, Daniel Ortega became the country's single leader once again (p. 150).
Overall, this book focuses more on institutions and political systems than on individuals. In particular, Close analyses how the four regime changes have influenced the strength and quality of Nicaraguan democracy. And as the author notes, this is certainly not the first scholarly work to deal with this important topic, as ‘from 1979 to 1990, Nicaragua and the FSLN were big news and a hot topic for academic research’ (p. 3). Indeed, throughout most of the 1980s, supporters and enemies of the Sandinista government were engaged in a highly politicised debate over the question as to whether the 1979 revolution had changed Nicaragua for the better or, as the Reagan administration in particular liked to emphasise, had created a Soviet-style totalitarian state in Central America. While reading the book, I wondered if high levels of international interest in the 1980s might have influenced the political developments in Nicaragua described by the author. Either way, after the end of the Cold War and the Sandinistas’ electoral loss in 1990, foreign political and public concern for Nicaragua's internal developments disappeared. And although the declining international interest in Nicaraguan politics is perhaps not justified since, as Close rightly notes, ‘Nicaragua did not stand still’ after the early 1990s, it certainly caused the scholarly debate to become more nuanced and less polarised (p. 3).
Close's analysis of Nicaragua's path ‘to, through, and from democracy’ starts in 1979, when triumphant Sandinista revolutionaries installed what he calls a ‘revolutionary vanguard regime’ (p. 155). This regime, the author writes, was not fully democratic and ‘allowed the Sandinistas to pursue their goals with few procedural obstacles’ (p. 77). Nevertheless, through the implementation of popular educational, healthcare and social reform programmes, as well as by allowing a certain level of political pluralism, the Sandinista revolutionaries succeeded in improving the overall quality of democracy in Nicaragua. The author then identifies another positive development in 1984, as by holding ‘acceptably free and fair’ elections Nicaragua's revolutionary vanguard regime transformed itself into a functioning electoral democracy (p. 89). It is only in the year 2000 that Close thinks ‘the quality of the nation's democracy’ started to worsen, a trend that eventually turned the Sandinistas into the undisputed ‘masters of the state's machinery’ (pp. 129 and 151).
This is a thoughtful and well-written work for anyone who wants to learn more about Nicaraguan history and politics. Furthermore, the book demonstrates how little scholarly knowledge we actually have about the complex range of domestic and international factors that have shaped Nicaraguan history since the late 1970s. To give a specific example, when discussing the Nicaraguan election in 1984, the author rightly notes that it was highly unusual that a revolutionary vanguard regime ‘designed and held’ such an election (p. 88). And in his introduction, Close briefly mentions – but does not elaborate on – the ‘three sources’ that put pressure on the Sandinista leadership to organise democratic elections. According to the author, ‘counterrevolutionary insurgents’, ‘Western European social democratic parties’, and Nicaragua's ‘domestic loyal opposition’ all played a crucial role in this transition to democracy (p. 2). Further archival research into the question of how and why these actors were able to influence the Sandinista regime to make such an unusual move might provide more insight into this important topic. I hope this interesting book encourages scholars to delve even more deeply into the question of how Nicaraguans since 1979 have navigated the politics of democracy.
