
‘To be affected by suicide’, writes Sam Wells, ‘is to be surrounded by enemies’ (p. 91). Memories, fear, isolation, shame, guilt, loss, failure and doubt are familiar foes in psychiatry. They inhabit not only the minds of patients, but also those of families, friends and colleagues affected by suicide. They inhabit the minds of psychiatrists too, not least when our patients die by suicide. In the face of these enemies, Wells suggests, we need to be aware of our vulnerability and gentle with ourselves. Psychiatrists are not taught gentleness when training, and vulnerability does not come easily to us, so how can we help our patients, and others impacted by suicide, to be vulnerable and gentle with themselves?
To be gentle, Wells suggests, we need first to be comfortable with silence, then willing to touch, and only then use words. I was left reflecting how little time busy clinical practice leaves for silence, how easily touch is seen as breaching professional boundaries and how soon we rush to words; however, words in the absence of silence and touch, Wells cautions, easily seem ‘disembodied, arbitrary, meaningless’ (p. 92).
The heart of this book, with its diverse perspectives upon the losses that suicide bequeaths, is deeply relational. It looks at suicide from every conceivable perspective, patient and professional, as well as family, friends and colleagues. I was struck by how Wells sees medical professionals as ‘working’ (not ‘being’) and ‘for’ (not ‘with’) those who face despair and distress. What does this tell us about the human (or not so human) face of psychiatry, I wonder?
The book draws on experience of annual services at St Martin-in-the-Fields church, in central London, over a 10-year period, for those affected by suicide. Some Christian prayers and thoughts creep in towards the end of the book, but the services are (and thus also, the book is) intended for people of all faiths and none. It addresses the core spiritual, relational and emotional dynamics of suicide in such a way as to be conducive to almost any spiritual or faith tradition. (There is also, however, a short section on how various faith traditions differently address the issue.)
The authors approach the topic from perspectives of a faith leader (Wells), loss of a son by suicide (Feloy and Mosse) and anthropology (Mosse). There is very little about psychiatry and this is why I (as a psychiatrist) think it is such a refreshing read. There is so much that happens in our patients’ lives’ that is not determined by neuroscience, pharmacology or psychological therapy. It is possible to talk about all that humanly matters in relation to suicide without the academic or scientific voices of psychiatry. This is a language in which good psychiatrists need to be more fluent.

eLetters
No eLetters have been published for this article.