This volume is the product of a three-day symposium hosted by the Institut für Historische Ethnologie at Johann Wolfgang Goethe University, Frankfurt am Main, in October 2004, under the title “Anthropological Perspectives on Iran: The New Millennium and Beyond.” Fifteen anthropologists participated, of whom roughly a third were Iranians resident in Iran, a third Iranians resident in the West, and a third American, English, or French. All started research in Iran before the revolution and continued to be involved in the anthropology of Iran to varying degrees down to the time of the symposium. Two of the Iranians resident in Iran did not contribute to the volume.
The book sets out to be an account of “anthropology in and of Iran” (p. 225, passim). It promises to span and to explain an interesting period—one that has been transitional not only for Iran but for anthropology and for the world as a whole—for which a review of “the anthropology in and of Iran” might provide an illuminating case study. Although this opportunity is certainly not ignored, either by the editor in her introduction or by the individual contributing authors, it does not get the attention it deserves. The book does, however, serve a subsidiary purpose in that the chapters read as a series of texts that help the reader to learn from Iran's unique experience in this transitional period and anthropology's relation to it.
Among all the processes that led to global change starting in the 1960s, the emergence of new opportunities and interest in anthropology led to fundamental changes in both anthropology and in Middle East studies that are only now beginning to be fully appreciated. It was the beginning of a new phase in the history of the field, a phase that has given anthropology a different part to play in Middle East studies from those it has played in other regional fields of study.
There were a number of reasons for this. The most important of these was no doubt the increase in the number of doctoral students looking for field research opportunities at a time when the traditional areas of anthropological interest (in territories that had been under colonial administrations) were becoming less welcoming and less secure. But anthropology began to change its geographic focus before that, by turning to research not only in urban situations in the United States and England, as well as Vaucluse in France, but also more significantly in the successor states to Asian civilizations and perhaps most importantly in the countries of the Mediterranean littoral, including the Muslim east and south. This move was especially encouraged in England in the 1950s by E. E. Evans-Pritchard at Oxford, leading to a series of conferences that brought together a new generation of anthropologists working in different Mediterranean countries. These conferences led to the publication of a number of valuable collections, beginning with Honour and Shame: The Values of Mediterranean Society (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1966). William Schorger, an anthropologist who directed the Center for Near East and North African Studies at the University of Michigan in the late 1960s and early 1970s, presided over a generation of students who worked in Morocco and other Muslim countries. The work of Fredrik Barth, which began to appear in the mid-1950s, inspired a number of American and English students to go to Iran in particular. The numbers going to Iran increased through the mid-1970s until the revolution, after which Yemen began to serve a similar purpose. By the mid-1970s, the Middle East had become a well-established subfield among anthropologists, with Iran holding a special place in that subfield, and anthropology was beginning to be recognized as a significant subfield in Middle East studies. Both fields were changing in increasingly obvious and conscious ways. But they were not prepared for the transformation of the social order in Afghanistan and Iran that took place in 1978 and 1979 and that caused shock waves through both fields, impacting the careers and professional productivity of each of the contributors to this volume.
The Iranian Revolution, from the rise in the incidence of popular demonstrations in 1978 to the cultural revolution that followed in the wake of the student takeover of the U.S. embassy in November 1979, caused a number of anthropological field research projects, many of which included significant collaborative work with Iranian scholars and Iranian government programs, to be aborted. The following decade, the 1980s, redefined Iran's place in the region and the world. The Iraq–Iran War, the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan, American alienation from Iran, and active U.S. support of the Afghan Mojahedin in Pakistan have been shown to be precursors to the emergence of al-Qaʿida and the landmark event of 9/11. The relationship between the West and the Middle East will never be the same again.
At the same time, the larger scene of international interaction throughout the world and of the place of anthropology and Middle East studies in national curricular and research agendas (associated with the budgetary initiatives of the Reagan–Thatcher years) were also changing. As a result, anthropology was developing new agendas, and the field of Middle East studies began to look very different.
Iran is the modern exemplar of the Persianate tradition in Islamic civilization that was identified by Marshall Hodgson in his The Venture of Islam (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1974) and is not only an integral part of the modern Islamic world but also both socially and culturally distinctive within it. Iran had, and continues to have, a special place in the intensifying processes of historical and modern change, right down to the present. It will probably continue to hold a special place in the Western understanding of the Islamic world due to the place of Iran in recent and longer-term history and the amount of anthropological data generated in Iran in the middle decades of the 20th century.
Although we in the West have been slow to recognize it, the historical significance of what Khomeini achieved is becoming increasingly clear to specialists as well as nonspecialists. Not only was he able to bring to fruition what he had been seeking for several decades but also he finally achieved the first non-Western revolution to be based on an indigenous intellectual tradition rather than on the expropriation of a Western ideology (as with the Russian, Chinese, Ethiopian, and other non-Western cases). Khomeini had been ready for this since the 1940s, but the general populace was not. He lived long enough to see the social conditions ripen as a result of social change in the population at large, aided by the White Revolution of the 1960s and social reforms resulting from American pressure, on the one hand, and increased domestic suppression of political dissent, on the other. Iran's earlier Constitutional Revolution, in which the clerisy played a leading role, as well as the secular democratic activity under Mossadeq were also significant developmental stages for which it is not easy to find points of comparison elsewhere in the Middle East. On the anthropological side, ethnographic data from Iran is probably more significant to anthropology as a whole than that from any other single Middle Eastern country, and (pace Bromberger, p. 195) includes work—by Barth and others—that is commonly read by non-Iranists.
By the time anthropologists began to reconnect with Iran in the 1990s, anthropology had become a very different field of study from what it had been before the revolution in the 1970s. It moved from filling in gaps in our cultural map of the world to providing a vision of cultural differentiation on a global scale. The seeds of change were apparent a decade or more earlier, but by the 1990s they had grown and borne fruit. While the identity of anthropology remained intact, the conception of its objectives and of the relationship between researcher and researched changed.
The writers in this volume are preoccupied with the problems emerging from anthropology's reorientation—defining their objectives and their relations with the people they study. But they show relatively little awareness of the larger historical context. Most of the contributions are highly personal. Rather than dealing with the field as a whole, each author has his or her own memories and perspectives. With a couple of exceptions, they fail to introduce data or ideas that are likely to attract a non-Iranist audience, and they include unsubstantiated statements that other Iranists (anthropologists among them) may question. Reminiscence appears to have been considered more important than research in these contributions; the nostalgia for past experience left no time for fact checking.
Consequently, although the book does provide “Past and Present Perspectives,” it does not succeed in “Conceptualizing Iranian Anthropology.” The text is valuable on another level, however, in that we can mine a great deal of personal data about how these particular anthropologists have accommodated the historic transitions in Iranian society and in academic anthropology.
Globalization has changed and continues to change the arena of anthropological and Middle East research. Social science tools and methods, and those of anthropology in particular, were developed after the great divergence between the Western economies and those of the rest that began with the Industrial Revolution in the 18th century. By the middle of the 19th century, the divergence was complete. The great convergence of world economies that began after World War II has changed, slowly at first, the anthropological research arena out of recognition in most parts of the world over the past thirty years. All of the basic questions that have beset anthropology in the last two decades of the 20th century are illustrated in this volume: among them, “what anthropology is for,” “us or them” or “absolute truth,” and “science or policy.” The revolution provided a cusp that allowed “the anthropology in and of Iran” to accentuate the transition from the age of postcolonialism to the age of globalization and anthropology's accommodation of that transition.
This book is also important for the number of references it provides to postrevolutionary publications that have escaped other bibliographies. However, the bibliography is by no means exhaustive. Each author selects texts according to personal perceptions of the field. But the “Select Bibliography” at the end, while useful and containing much that is otherwise difficult to locate, omits any statement of the criteria used for selection. A well-researched history of anthropology in and of Iran remains to be written.
