The first of “The Great Debates” in CQ occurred more than 3 years ago when John Harris and Julian Savulescu engaged in conversation concerning stem cells, embryos, research, and reproduction (CQ 13(1):68–95). The format was simple and yet somewhat novel: Get noted scholars in the field to speak directly to each other through the pages of a journal about a topic that matters to them. Have them engage each other's ideas by reducing mediating factors—reading some article in a journal, then writing some response to another journal, then awaiting some letter to an editor or later paper presentation at a professional conference. Simply put, find thoughtful, well-respected people who want to put their arguments forward in conjunction with those who might disagree or simply might want differing emphases.
This next installment of “The Great Debates” (admittedly there is possible hyperbole in this title, but the quality of the exchanges is pretty darn high) begins with an argument by Mary B. Mahowald about the validity of the “expressivist argument” in the discussion of disability rights. The argument trades, in part, on a point explained by Adrienne Asch,1
Asch in Parens E, Asch A, editors. Prenatal Testing and Disability Rights. Washington, D.C.: Georgetown University Press; 2000:13.
Cf. Nelson in note 1, Parens, Asch 2000.
