In Playing God, Henry Bial examines the history of portraying the religious in general, and the Almighty in particular, on the Broadway stage. The topic is fascinating, and his examination often rewarding. Bial explores the hazards of portraying God onstage, where, he argues, people of faith view flawed theatrical representations as offensive, even blasphemous. Beginning with late nineteenth-century opposition, the narrative reveals gradual acceptance over ensuing decades through several case studies. Bial suggests that, beyond the usual vicissitudes of finding commercial success, productions depicting religion face additional obstacles due to scrutiny from believers, who guard against what they perceive to be misrepresentations of their beliefs.
The book's introduction lays out the methods by which playwrights and producers have approached religious material, from efforts to adapt sections of text directly from biblical passages, to what Bial terms “fan fiction,” whereby playwrights invent tales from gaps in biblical narratives. The introduction also discusses several contemporary authors of culture and religion in order to devise a compounded rubric that is then applied in subsequent chapters. In particular, Bial cites theatre historians Amy Hughes and Jill Stevenson, literary critics Lionel Trilling, Matthew Stratton, and Henry Jenkins, and folklorist Barbara Kirshenblatt-Gimblett. Although it is unclear how Bial arrived at the rubric from these authors, he identifies four main elements that create feelings of “reverence” (25) or “transcendence” (27) for spectators at religious Broadway plays: spectacle, leading to a “powerful aesthetic response” (28); authenticity, which he describes as “irreducible reality” or “legitimating discourse” (28); sincerity, or nonhypocritical behavior; and irony, or “sophisticated” (29) contradictions. Acknowledging the complexity of this “schematization” (31), Bial offers several combinations and antitheses among the four elements. Even as he grants that there is no “magic formula that determines which plays succeed” (31), he asserts this rubric throughout the text seemingly to credit whether a faith-based production worked or failed.
After establishing the central argument in the introduction, chapters are organized chronologically via groupings of biblical stories: efforts to stage Christ indirectly with Ben-Hur; plays about Adam and Eve; various Noah plays; treatments of Job. Next come 1970s Broadway musicals about Christ and finally a chapter on two Broadway flops. Historical events are peppered throughout to provide context and color. Bial is also adept at offering lively anecdotes that animate subjects, making for an engaging read. His close readings of plays are subtle and insightful, and soar when he contrasts plays around a shared topic, such as Noah and Two by Two. High points include his placement of Jesus Christ Superstar within the story of the Mark Hellinger Theatre, ironically later transformed into a church, and his commentary about how God was first successfully shown onstage, significantly in the African American–cast, gospel-inspired The Green Pastures.
Despite its strengths, Playing God also suffers from limitations and gaps, many caused by asserting the rubric rather than exploring the variations and degrees to which it may apply. So even as there is much good in Bial's book, there are also method-based problems. The book would benefit from a closer consideration of shifting national attitudes toward both religion and theatre that made such depictions increasingly possible over time, as well as more attention to ethical works of a lighter tone discounted when the subject is taken more literally. While Bial builds his thesis upon recent scholarship, he ignores its particular content, depriving us and himself of critical background information. For example, Amy Hughes's work includes how Puritanical opposition to theatre gradually ebbed when nineteenth-century ministers encouraged their flocks to attend temperance plays in harmony with their sermons. Other pertinent aspects of this rich topic of religion in American theatre are also omitted, such as how eighteenth-century itinerant theatre companies performing in New England billed productions as “moral dialogues” to dodge Puritanical restrictions. Nor is there mention of Uncle Tom's Cabin, nineteenth-century America's most popular production; when it opened in New York City, theatre owner “Captain Purdy” displayed a large lobby painting of himself, with one hand holding Stowe's book and the other the scriptures.
Similarly, the book considers Archibald MacLeish's drama JB, in which God bets Satan that Job will suffer without losing faith. Focusing solely on the rubric, the obvious contradiction between JB's biblical source and its use of pagan Greek staging, including robes and large masks, is lost. The emphasis instead is on actor sincerity, even though one could argue that actors aim for sincerity regardless of the roles they play. Elsewhere in the book, spectacle is often credited as a central component of a successful staging of God or biblical events; lacking is discussion about the fundamental contradiction that staged spectacle is inherently artificial. Period audiences likely applauded Ben-Hur’s chariot race much as they did comparable effects in countless secular melodramas. In this American stew of faith and theatre, Bial's argument does not offer tools to explore the marriage of belief and theatrical convention.
In the end, Playing God raises interesting questions but sidesteps fascinating aspects of its subject. The topic is intriguing, and the content and chronological review raise some excellent analyses. At the same time, it is frustrating that the complexities of religion and theatre in America are not fully explored. The book neglects pertinent pillars of theatre convention that inform spectator experiences, such as the complex connection between Coleridge's “willing suspension of disbelief” and the Christian emphasis on faith, Plato's distrust of actors because they could appear sincere when not, and Aristotle's assertion of theatre's value in offering moral and ethical lessons. There are moments when as theatre artists we are fortunate enough to stumble upon the depths of religious belief through our work in this form. There are complexities in both religion (spirituality versus organization) and theatre (sincerity versus artifice). It is some of that “spirit” that I would have wished could be explored in this focused, fascinating exploration of putting God onstage in America.
