Anyone who is teaching a contemporary Western art-history survey these days and using the readily available textbooks knows that they inculcate our students with a teleological narrative of avant-garde practices in New York. For all the evidence that supports the rectitude of such an approach, it stands to reason that there was creative innovation elsewhere.
The anthology West of Center: Art and the Counterculture Experiment in America, 1965–1977 confirms our suspicions. The publication offers twenty essays focussed on the American West as a liberating space that attracted artists who wanted to work outside traditional and modernist conventions and to separate themselves from art markets located on either side of the Atlantic. Counterculture signified dropping out and away from mainstream society, and, for some, dropping acid, too. According to West of Center coeditors Elissa Auther and Adam Lerner, it also meant developing new “life frames” designed to eliminate distinctions between being and making, boundaries between individuals and communities, and alienation from the immediate environment whether urban or rural. Characterized as freestyle (by Ant Farm cofounder Chip Lord) and called “life acting” (by the San Francisco Diggers), these experiments in the 1960s and 1970s are positioned as utterly different from preceding US and European artists’ nonconformist, bohemian, and often romantic proposals to reject the autonomy of art. Instead, the heroes of West of Center provided a model of counterculture that, the volume's coeditors assert, survives today and inspires young artists.
West of Center starts off boldly with a foreword by Lucy R. Lippard. It's a gutsy move by Auther and Lerner to let the venerable activist–critic and art historian who made her name in the 1960s (and who vividly remembers the era) have the first assessing word. Lippard's foreword, titled “Memory as Model,” is an even-keeled consideration of Auther and Lerner's project that starts off with an autocritique of her position as a New York-based observer. “West of Center,” she writes, “exponentially expands common knowledge about the arts … Reading it, I realized how much I missed by being (as we presume) ‘at the center’ in those decades when many of the things I cared most about had been happening on the edges” (ix). From there, Lippard effectively summarizes each essay and its value to US art history and visual-cultural studies: she articulates her appreciation for “new information” on photographer Ansel Adams's work at the Esalen Institute in Big Sur; the Oakland Black Panther Party artist Emory Douglas; and pre-Internet-age workshops on using video technology to disseminate ideas by the San Francisco collectives Ant Farm, Media Access Center, and TVTV. Generally praising in her comments, Lippard expresses only a few disappointments about West of Center. One regret is that some of the contributions did not provide “a sense of context, of landscapes, and place, of western identity and its responses to the counterculture in these accounts” (xii). On the New York scene in the 1960s and 1970s and “living off the grid on solar in semirural New Mexico” (xii) since the 1990s, Lippard is keenly aware of the stakes of white cultural producers’ flight to “nowhere” places that “of course [were] already inhabited (xiii).” What, she rightly asks, did the long-time residents of Trinidad, Colorado (site of the Drop City commune from 1965 to 1973) think of “this new wave of colonization” (xiii)? She also wishes that there were “more on the politics of sexual liberation” in West of Center, for, in addition to its essays that discuss the work of artists Bonnie Ora Sherk and Yolanda M. Lopéz in San Francisco, there ought to have at least been one dedicated to the feminist installation and performance space Womanhouse and more on the founding of the Los Angeles Women's Building.Footnote 1 As the specificity of her suggestions indicates, Lippard is uniquely well positioned to recall important interventions, identify connections among experimental artists and creative communities, demand acknowledgement of their legacies, and ultimately pronounce our debts to them: they cannot be dismissed as utopian dreams that only failed, for they give us “something to brainstorm about, something to long for, something to work for, something that cannot yet be put behind us” (xv).
The essays in West of Center are sensibly organized under four headings whose rhetoric resonates with contemporary vocabularies concerned with situated cultural production: “Communal Encounters” (Part I), “Handmade Worlds” (Part II), “Cultural Politics” (Part III), and “Altered Consciousness” (Part IV). Nonetheless, as Auther and Lerner avow in their introduction, there are “crisscrossing threads” throughout the volume (xxxiv). For instance, collectives and other intentionally formed groups are discussed throughout West of Center, not just in the first section. Moreover, while Part III focusses on minority cultural producers and subject matter – nonwhite and feminist artists, American Indian iconography, queer back-to-the-land movements – politics and the political are rubrics that could be applied to each contribution in West of Center. The best of essays in West of Center are persuasive discussions on the fracturing of categories, from craft to architecture, and on the introduction of new concepts such as “critical rusticity” as productive moves that might even interest people outside academia.Footnote 2 Learning about utopian efforts undertaken half a century prior is unlikely to provoke most readers of West of Center to denounce 4G technology and head for the proverbial hills in solar-powered cars. Instead, because this volume's accounts of countercultural artistic action and activism speak to the pressurized conditions of the 1960s and 1970s that engendered those of the present, the most obvious takeaway is that success and failure are not ultimate. Rather, they are provisional assessments that are subject to revision.
