Who was Brutus? A parricide or a liberator? In an attempt to address these questions, his contemporaries and later generations have come to polarised conclusions: as Kathryn Tempest rightly points out, the verdict is heavily affected by one's view about the messy transition from the Roman Republic to the Empire and, especially, about the figure of Julius Caesar. After a brief survey of different views, ancient (introduction) and modern (preface), T. takes a balanced middle course, which allows for perceptive appreciations of both sides. She realistically admits that we simply cannot answer those questions and retrieve the ‘real’ Brutus: he was an enigma to his own contemporaries and to ancient historians who had access to much more information than we can dream of. The monograph, then, focuses on ‘how Brutus’ life has been recorded and transmitted from antiquity to today’ (xi). Since ‘the reception of Brutus in the western tradition — that is, his portrayal in art, literature, historiography and scholarship — is as much part of his story as the man himself, it will necessarily form a part of this investigation’ (10). Indeed, throughout, T. successfully blends close readings of ancient sources, bits of reception and modern scholarship, demonstrating that Brutus displayed an impenetrable personality and tracing the clashing of opposed ancient and modern interpretations back to this very impenetrability.
The portrayal of Brutus that emerges from this analysis is refreshing and convincing: he seems passionate and rational, loyal and opportunistic, idealistic and political. Organised in broad chronological order, each of the eight chapters explores ‘a central aspect of Brutus’ lived experience’ (14) from various perspectives. Brutus valued his reputation and vividly felt the pressure resulting from the ideals and expectations that his name elicited in his contemporaries; his education and early career illustrate his struggles for personal advancement, in an attempt to bank on the advantages offered by his family and upbringing (ch. 1) and to shape his own public identity and political career (ch. 2). The advent of the civil war between Caesar and Pompey strained Brutus’ loyalties and forced him, along with his contemporaries, to take sides. But unlike many contemporaries, Brutus could not see the end of the civil war as the end of his personal dilemma (ch. 3): having been defeated, pardoned and recruited by Caesar for his staff, he found himself thinking about tyrannicide and, once again, caught between conflicting obligations, ideals and expectations (ch. 4). Here T. superbly teases out various intertwined threads which led to his decision to assassinate Caesar, tracing them back to Brutus’ personal connections, pressure felt from public opinion and peers, political ambition, philosophical ideas, and to fortuitous events. Chs 5, 6 and 7 read more like a traditional biography: they mostly summarise what happened between the assassination of Caesar and Brutus’ death, drawing on a wealth of information, especially from Cicero. T.’s style remains lively, thanks also to some juxtaposition of different views of Brutus’ personality (e.g. 129–35 and 185–8). Insights from later traditions here yield to primary evidence, but they return to centre stage in the next and last chapter, dedicated to the death and legend of Brutus. Readers are treated to a sample of verdicts pronounced through history, including assessments by Shakespeare, John of Salisbury, Dante, Thomas Aquinas and all the way to the HBO Rome series.
The book is well researched and well written, and T. manages to strike an ideal balance in more ways than one: secondary literature is carefully handled to avoid oversimplifications and excessively detailed discussions, and sources and references are wisely distributed between the main text and the endnotes. As a result, students, scholars and lay readers have much to gain from this enjoyable read, and the endnotes provide guidance to know more. I have found only a few mistakes and inconsistencies (e.g. ‘The outbreak of the civil war in 48 B.C.’, 33; copiossime, 66; ‘nothing happened bar a few preliminary skirmishes’, 198; cf. 103). All in all, the book is nicely produced and reader-friendly, thanks especially to T.’s engaging style, various visual aids such as plates and maps, and the appendixes neatly listing the most important dates and sources.
