This compact, well-illustrated book sheds new light on the history of a canonical building of Islamic architecture: the Friday or Congregational Mosque of Isfahan in central Iran. Several campaigns of excavations conducted during the 1970s by an Italian team from IsMEO (Istituto per il Medio ed Estremo Oriente) directed by Umberto Scerrato and Eugenio Galdieri documented the fundamental change there from the hypostyle mosque, typical of the ‘Abbasid period and sometimes dubbed the ‘Arab-style’ plan, to the four-iwan or ‘Iranian-style’ plan that became standard in much of Iran and Central Asia. In addition to structural concerns, the excavators also uncovered fragments of painted stucco and plaster, mostly in the area around the mihrab. This book analyzes these 104 fragments, which were stored in some two dozen wooden boxes following the abrupt suspension of excavations due to the Islamic Revolution in 1978.
An opening section (pp. 11–14) by Michael Jung, curator of Islamic art and archeology at the Museo Nazionale d'Arte Orientale in Rome, sets the scene with a brief review of the mosque's complicated history. Around 156/772–73 under the ‘Abbasid caliph al-Mansur, a first mosque with a flat-roofed prayer hall and an arcaded court was built on the site of older Sasanian building(s) in Yahudiyya. This first mosque was replaced ca. 840 during the caliphate of al-Mu‘tasim by a second ‘Abbasid mosque of the same type but much greater in size and rotated some 15° to better match the direction of the qibla. Minor changes of the tenth century included the addition of an arcade around the courtyard and some annexes probably lying outside the mosque proper, but the major transformation of the mosque took place in the Saljuq period. Under the Saljuq sultan Malik Shah, two-domed chambers were constructed: one in front of the mihrab by Nizam al-Mulk datable around 479–80/1086-87, and a second at the opposite end of the mosque by his rival Taj al-Mulk dated two years later in 481/1088-89. At some point four iwans were introduced around the courtyard of the mosque. Jung suggests that this last work was done before 511/1118 and that the fire of 515–16/1121-22 necessitated only the rebuilding of the northeast gate. A very useful plan (Fig. 3, p. 18) highlights the various building phases in different colours.
The heart of the book (pp. 15–60) analyses the painted fragments of the pre-Saljuq mosque found mainly beneath the floor in the area around the qibla (sector 190 on Eric [not Ernst, as indicated in the caption on Fig. 9] Schroeder's well-known plan of the mosque published in the Survey of Persian Art). As in many buildings in the region, the wall surface was divided into two parts: a dado with carved and painted stucco decoration beneath a plaster wall with painted murals. Jung groups the tiny (the largest were 22 x 18.5 cm, but most were smaller) fragments in ten categories on the basis of the subject matter (inscriptions, pearl bands, linked trefoil arches, geometric and plants forms, etc.). There seem to have been several stages of repainting, whether due to earthquake, siege, plague, humidity or some other cause, but nonetheless virtually all of these fragments belong to the pre-Seljuq renovations, as they were found beneath the Seljuq-period pavement of baked bricks (ca. 42 x 42 cm) that sealed the fill layers below it.
A subsequent, shorter chapter by Jung (pp. 61–76) treats the post-Seljuq wall paintings found in different areas of the mosque. A few painted fragments displaying floral patterns with slender twigs and leaves were found around the southern iwan of the Muzaffarid madrasa added in 768/1366 under Qutb al-Din Shah Mahmud. Several paintings of mosques and handprints are much more recent. The most unusual are two landscapes with silhouetted trees, bushes, tufts of grass and flowers, birds and animals set on facing sides of the vault in the gav-chah, the area in the northwest of the mosque where water was collected and conserved for ritual ablutions, cleaning and sanitation. According to an inscription the landscape scenes were added by Mir Qasem Husseini in 1199/1784, and hence date from the period of the Zand ruler ‘Ali Murad Khan.
The last major chapter (pp. 77–108), written with the co-authorship of the research scientists Paolo Cornale, Fabio Frezzato and Claudio Seccaroni along with Jung, contains technical analyses of the paintings, investigating the materials used for the polychrome red and blue painting and the gilding. This is followed by a brief essay (pp. 109–110) by Antonella Altieri that tries to identify the individual botanical specimens in the paintings, but their fragmentary state means that much is speculative. A summary and an extensive bibliography give extra substance to the volume.
We tend to think of the architecture from the first centuries of the Islamic period as black-and-white in contrast to the brilliant Technicolor of the later, post-Seljuq periods. This book shows that this characterisation is wrong. Instead mosques — like the example in Isfahan — of the ‘Abbasid-period hypostyle were in fact brightly coloured, albeit through the use of coloured paint rather than through the use of coloured tiles, which came later. These small fragments provide some of the earliest evidence for wall painting in Iran, especially for the uses of writing. For its careful documentation, clear articulation and handsome production, this book makes an important contribution to the history of Islamic architecture in Iran and the development of the congregational mosque there.
