For historians of Chinese architecture, Wutai is most important as the site of one of only four extant timber structures from the Tang: the Buddha Hall at Foguang Monastery. Lin gives some attention to the Foguang Buddha Hall, noting that it was first studied by the pioneering scholar of Chinese architecture Liang Sicheng (1901–72) in the 1930s, and even subjected to an exhaustive x-ray analysis in 2006. A rare remnant of the intricate, technically sophisticated architecture that dotted the cities and Buddhist mountains of the Tang empire, the Foguang Buddha Hall has been so thoroughly examined that it is hard to imagine what more can be said about it. Lin steers clear of extended formal analysis of the Buddha Hall, and says little about its legacy in the architecture of Wutai today, most of which is fairly recent and follows on dramatic changes to the layout of monasteries there in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. He instead attempts to reconstruct the first stage of the mountain's Buddhist history from the fifth century to the tenth.
By the end of the Tang, when the Buddha Hall at Foguang was built, Mount Wutai was one of China's premier Buddhist pilgrimage sites, attracting travelers from Japan, Tibet, and perhaps even as far away as India. Drawing on a wide range of sources—including paintings at Dunhuang, archaeology, miracle stories, travel accounts, and scripture—Building a Sacred Mountain charts the rise of Wutai from a backwater that received no attention in ancient sources to its recognition as the first distinctly Buddhist mountain in China, and perhaps anywhere.
After providing extensive background information (the first chapter is a rich but tangential survey of Buddhist monasticism in China), Lin turns to the role of the visionary in the formation of Wutai as a Buddhist mountain. It is here, I think, that he makes his greatest contribution. Starting in the second half of the sixth century, Wutai was associated with Mount Qingliang, mentioned in the Buddhāvataṃsaka-sūtra, and so became recognized as the home of Mañjusrī. From this time on, meditators were drawn to Wutai in hopes of receiving visions of the great bodhisattva. And miracle tales testified that the fortunate did in fact see visions of Mañjusrī upon arrival. The Zhulin Monastery was built in an attempt to make tangible the monastery perceived in a vision by the monk Fazhao. And a similar claim was made for the equally spectacular Jin'ge Monastery. Stories of these monasteries captured the imagination of Buddhists across East Asia, along with the mysterious Diamond Grotto (said to have been visited in a vision by the Indian monk Buddhapālita), and an image of the bodhisattva at Wutai, itself inspired by yet another vision.
In other words, though inspired by visions, these monasteries, images, and caves were not confined to the minds of mystics but were identified, sculpted, or built as the mountain was gradually “mapped with traces of miraculous events” (p. 93). The most important pilgrimage to Wutai for modern scholars is that of Ennin, who, in his ninth-century diary, describes visiting all of the major pilgrimage sites: the Diamond Grotto, the Jin'ge and Zhulin monasteries, and the “true-presence” icon of Mañjusrī on a lion (p. 160). Ennin was exceptional only in that his account of his pilgrimage survives; countless monks and lay people made the journey to Wutai in medieval times. Tibetans too began to make the pilgrimage to Wutai starting at least as early as the beginning of the ninth century. An interesting section of the book on the detailed depiction of Wutai in Cave 61 far to the west in Dunhuang suggests how the painting could be used by those unable to make the trip further east as a tool for virtual pilgrimage.
Lin might have given more attention to the more prosaic reasons for Wutai's success. Jacques Gernet argued long ago for the economic resources available in mountains—primarily timber and water—as a reason for their prominence in Chinese Buddhist monasticism.Footnote 4 The pull of visions of the sacred on the mountain was no doubt fueled in part by the economic concerns of those charged with building and maintaining Wutai's extensive monastic architecture. Little space is given to merit-making and prestige as driving forces behind construction at Wutai. And at times Lin's connections between Buddhist doctrines and practices—eschatology (mofa), the bodhisattva path (marga), the use of cave temples in meditation—are strained. But the overall themes of visions, buildings, and pilgrimage that run throughout this beautifully illustrated, meticulously documented book are consistently compelling; there was, Lin demonstrates, much more to building Wutai than buildings.
