Danny Hoffman's Monrovia Modern is well-theorized ethnography of four buildings in post-civil-war Monrovia, Liberia. It is appropriate for graduate and undergraduate courses in anthropology, African studies, architecture, and urban planning. The book is based upon ethnographic research conducted by Hoffman in Liberia in 2012 and combines his multiple talents. Before becoming an academic, Hoffman worked as a photojournalist, and most of his academic research has focused on young male combatants in Sierra Leone and Liberia. Monrovia Modern is amply illustrated with Hoffman's photographs, but more important, it is a meditation on politics and aesthetics that explores the interrelationship between citizens and buildings in a postwar setting. Many of the citizens Hoffman consults are themselves former combatants in the region's roving wars of 1989–2003.
The four buildings he examines all made statements about the country's aspirations toward modernity. The Ministry of Defense and Liberian Broadcasting System buildings were built for the Samuel Doe government in the 1980s and both were unfinished when the war broke out. The Ministry of Defense headquarters was built by an Israeli company drawing on Brutalist architectural styles developed by Marxist modernist architects in England and elsewhere, who sought to ‘drag a rough poetry out of the confused and powerful forces’ shaping postwar English life (76). Relying on design principles that emphasized a simple layout and an open display of building materials and structural supports, the style was also adopted in many parts of Africa.
The E.J. Roye building is the oldest of the four and sits in downtown Monrovia. Completed in 1965, it was the headquarters of the True Whig Party, controlled by the descendants of freed American slaves who came to Liberia in the 1830s and controlled the country's politics and economy until Doe took power in a coup in 1980. Although gutted, it retains the form of the impressive nine-story mini-skyscraper it was 47 years before Hoffman's research. Hoffman compares it to Mies van der Rohe's Seagram Building in New York, while emphasizing that it also served as a monument to the once-unassailable control exercised by the tiny Americo-Liberian elite over the levers of power. Given its central location and all that it represented, it is not surprising that the building came in for a fair amount of damage during the repeated rebel attacks on Monrovia. Hoffman found it with only a small number of squatters inhabiting it, and no one who could articulate what it might become, if renovated.
Even more abandoned was the Hotel Africa, once one of the two fanciest hotels in Monrovia, and site of the Organisation of African Unity's continent-wide meeting of heads of state in 1979, just a few months before president William Tolbert was assassinated and Samuel Doe seized power. At the time of Hoffman's research, the building was uninhabitable even by squatters used to sleeping rough. The copper electrical wiring had been chiseled out of the walls and the floors were covered with debris and had dangerous holes in them.
By contrast, both the Ministry of Defense and the Liberian Broadcasting System buildings had large populations of Liberians living in them. Many of these inhabitants had been combatants in the war. At both sites, the Liberian government demanded that everyone leave. Many people told Hoffman that they were eager to leave the sites and indeed Monrovia, but that they were holding their spots for as long as possible in hopes of receiving compensation from the government. Hoffman argues that such tactical reasoning bodes ill for Liberia's future. He writes that hopes that Muammar Gaddafi would refurbish the hotel (which died with Gaddafi's own demise) were ‘a conservative, reactionary fantasy’ (139), given that the Liberian civil war ‘seemed to go nowhere, and for many young people the end of fighting has not produced a material change in their lives or their prospects in the city’ (112).
Hoffman shows the reader how the monumental concrete structures around which the book is organized were meant to symbolize and enact a politics of inequality and exclusion that helped to produce the war. Faced with their ruin and the large numbers of people making do living in and around the buildings as squatters, he argues against some of the more celebratory strands of Africanist urban scholarship that applaud bricolage and débrouilliardaise from the relative comfort of academic sinecures. Considering the possibilities proffered by ‘minor’ and ‘insurgent’ architectures, he generally finds them lacking in Monrovia in 2012. He writes of one inhabitant of the former Liberian Broadcasting System headquarters, ‘He and hundreds of other squatters had established a place for themselves in the LBS, mostly through creative and bold improvisation. But it was hard to read their presence as anything other than a precarious response to an impossible situation’ (170).
Still-poor cities a decade out from devastating wars may be difficult places to find encouragement for a people's politics organized to hold elected officials to a high standard. At that point mere survival may constitute victory for most poor people. Hoffman's great contribution in this book is to point us toward the central importance of the built environment in preparing the scene for creating such politics in the second and third decades after war's end.
