Although there are nearly 700 chapters of Pi Sigma Alpha located throughout the United States and Guam, many chapters do not take full advantage of the opportunities provided by the honor society. In addition to the resources the national organization makes available to chapters, a number of learning opportunities can occur through active involvement with the organization. Conventional classroom interactions may not expose students to these new learning opportunities. This article describes one chapter's experiences with Pi Sigma Alpha and the many benefits available to faculty and students alike.
For many students, honor societies are largely thought of as filler for their resumes. Students pay their initiation fees, elect officers for the organization, and might even have a banquet. Beyond that, many honorary organizations are largely inactive. Young faculty who are asked to serve as advisors are typically swamped with other duties and the prospect of anything useful occurring through an honor society seems to be unlikely. However, this is a real mistake—particularly when it comes to Pi Sigma Alpha.
There are a number of programs sponsored by the national office of Pi Sigma Alpha. It provides scholarships for graduate study and for Washington, D.C., internships, and it recognizes excellence for undergraduate papers, theses, and chapter advisors. Additionally, the national organization sponsors a program designed to stimulate local chapter activity. According to the national office, the Chapter Activity Grant Competition “provides the means for chapters to put together projects with a broader scope than they otherwise could afford, and gives students excellent experience in writing proposals and budgets, carrying out funded activities, and writing reports” (Pi Sigma Alpha 2009a).
In 2005, the budget for the Chapter Activity Grant Competition was $55,000. In that year, 91 chapters submitted grant proposals. Thus, only 13% of all chapters applied for grant money. In 2006, the budget increased to $80,000 and still, only 92 chapters submitted proposals. Finally, in 2007 the budget increased again to $90,000 and the national office received 116 proposals. While it is encouraging to see that both the amount of available money and the number of proposals have increased, clearly most chapters are not taking full advantage of this exceptional opportunity. The remainder of this article describes our experience at Ohio Northern University as a recipient of Chapter Activity Grants over the past four years.
STARTING SMALL
I had been a member of Pi Sigma Alpha as an undergraduate in the early 1990s. A few short years later, like many newly minted Ph.D.s, I found myself as the advisor to the organization. As in my own undergraduate experience I found that the organization was not very active. This was true of several other honor societies to which I was a member. As the advisor, however, I was now privy to the many opportunities Pi Sigma Alpha presented. In my first year as the chapter advisor, I decided to do something that had not happened when I was an undergrad—call a meeting of members and share with them the information I had about the organization. I was able to explain to the students that Pi Sigma Alpha was more than a line on their resumes. The idea of pursuing a Chapter Activity Grant was particularly appealing to the group.
Given the lack of previous experience with the organization, we decided to aim for something that was attainable. Toward that end, we perused the suggested activities contained in the Chapter Activity Grant announcement as well as winning grant proposals from past years. Because Pi Sigma Alpha is an extracurricular organization and students tend to weigh decisions in terms of costs and benefits, it was important to start small. By starting small, I did not want to ask too much of the students, yet wanted them to achieve something that would register as an important venture. Consequently, I explained the significance of gaining experience in writing a grant proposal. I cast the idea as a win-win situation where regardless of the outcome they would be able to note that they had experience writing grants. Obtaining money from the organization to pursue a specific activity would only sweeten the reward.
In that initial year, we proposed to hold an essay contest and publish the winning entries in a journal. Working with several students, we were able to craft the proposal and were ultimately awarded funding by the national chapter. Students were delighted at the news. We were able to hold the contest and award money to the winning contestants. I spoke with the students about the possibility of getting the journal into the hands of others. In particular, I was interested in sharing the journal with alumni and prospective students. After the journal was published in the summer months, I was able to do just that—through aid from the alumni and admissions offices. Starting small (an essay contest) provided many benefits to the students. Several students helped write the grant proposal, others organized the contest, and yet others found themselves winning money for their papers. Students were also able to see how the organization could gain credibility and notice around campus (as evidenced through the money given to us by the alumni and admissions offices).
THINKING BIG
The following year worked to build on that initial success. Consequently, members came to school thinking about ideas for a new grant proposal. Not only was it expected that the organization was going to be active, students were already plotting their next move. They did not want to do something they had already done. Recognizing the fact that they could obtain money from other outlets, our chapter sought money from the student senate to carry on the essay contest and subsequent journal. The students presented their request and were among the few groups on campus to be awarded the full allotment of their appeal.
The idea of doing a research project was especially attractive for the students. Engaging them in a large-scale research endeavor was of real interest to the group as many were planning on postgraduate study. We met on several occasions to discuss different research projects until it was decided that we would conduct a survey of presidential electors. This was a project that I thought the students could all benefit from—given their different interests. Specifically, they could learn about survey research and the Electoral College as an institution. We spent a great deal of time discussing what a research project is like for political scientists. I wanted to convey to them that what we were about to undertake was very different from writing a literature review for a class assignment. Because of the paucity of research on presidential electors, I articulated to them how important this project was to our understanding of the institution. They were quite receptive to the idea of doing something that had not been done before. This was a strong motivating force for the entire group—to learn something that nobody else knew.
As we were conducting a mail survey of presidential electors, responsibilities were divided among the students. The president and vice president of the organization worked especially hard in keeping the entire group focused. From obtaining addresses to creating labels, all of the students contributed a great deal. It was clear that a real sense of ownership emerged during the project. While we encountered many issues that we did not anticipate, the experience taught the students a great deal about the bumpy road of the research process. It was especially rewarding to me as I was able to observe the excitement of the students once the surveys started coming back to us. Each day, I was greeted by a chorus of “How many did we get today?” from the students. It was an exciting time for all. As a testament to the students' work, we achieved a response rate of over 60%.
Once the data were collected, I worked with students on coding and interpreting the results. Several students in particular were deeply involved. Two of those students used data for their senior research papers. I thought so much of their work that the three of us then developed a manuscript that we planned on submitting to an academic journal. The result of that collaboration appeared in PS: Political Science and Politics (Alexander, Brown, and Kaseman Reference Alexander, Brown and Kaseman2004). Perhaps most amazing, the project went from an idea at the beginning of one school year to a published article at the beginning of the very next school year.
Throughout the process, I had explained to the students that we should think big regarding the project. I sought to convey to the students that we should work to share our knowledge with others. While we were able to share our findings with political scientists in PS, we decided to organize an Electoral College panel the following year (2004).
Consequently, we put together a panel of four presidential electors from the 2000 election. The presentation took place a few days before the November election. The students were responsible for creating programs for the event, escorting the electors around campus, and they were invited to various dining engagements with the panelists. These experiences brought the data to life and gave the students an opportunity to engage these gladiators of American politics in a way few others are able to.
The panel presentation generated a great deal of media attention. C-SPAN taped the presentation and it was featured on the network the night of the presidential election. This was quite an exciting evening for all of the members of our organization—a real crowning achievement. What had been an idea in November of 2003 became a reality in just under a year. That the students had the opportunity to conduct research, have face-to-face interactions with several of the respondents, and see the fruit of their labor on display for others was quite unexpected.
The success of our Electoral College research project worked to fuel the group's desire to continue more research. In subsequent years we have conducted another survey and sent students to the Midwest Political Science Association's annual meeting to present papers. Each endeavor was primarily funded through Chapter Activity Grants. When students are now inducted into the organization, they recognize that the chapter is quite active and that they will be expected to participate in a number of activities throughout the year. Our chapter's recognition as an “outstanding chapter” by the national organization has provided students with great pride and ambition to undertake new projects.
More importantly, our chapter's experiences have exposed students to the discipline of political science, and those experiences are difficult to replicate in the conventional classroom setting. Kim Quaile Hill (Reference Quaile Hill2002, 113) suggests that undergraduates “should understand the character of political science as a scientific enterprise, how scientific work is carried out in the field, the current level of scientific advancement and achievements therein, and the most notable challenges to the discipline's progress.” The research program we have undertaken has engaged students across semesters, years, and academic conferences. They have gained valuable insights as to what it takes to conduct research as well as what may come of that research. Quaile Hill (Reference Quaile Hill2002, 113) further contends that students should recognize the “important applied role that the social sciences play in the world.” The media attention directed at our chapter illustrated the applied nature of our subject matter. The public's interest in our research suggested the real-life import of our endeavor. Moreover, bringing presidential electors to campus literally put human faces on our data.
LESSONS LEARNED
This article set out to explain how one chapter of Pi Sigma Alpha was able to make full use of the Chapter Activity Grant Competition sponsored through the national office of the organization. While hundreds of chapters exist, a very small number of chapters take advantage of programs sponsored by the national office. Although working to establish a more active chapter takes time and energy, the payoffs are considerable. Young faculty should not be discouraged from active participation as chapter advisors. Rather, this article points to the many benefits they and their students can derive from focused, motivated leadership. This is especially true at smaller universities where teaching is emphasized. Moreover, tenure and promotion committees appreciate those who prepare students to engage in the research process through programs such as this.
Many benefits were able to accrue from this one program. Most of these were unanticipated. While the initial goal was to provide an opportunity for students to gain experience in the grant-writing process, our chapter has gained so much more. Students have learned a great deal about planning events, marshalling resources, being engaged in the research process, collaboration, and leadership. More concretely, they have participated in grant writing, conference presentations, and the publication of a scholarly article. Pi Sigma Alpha states that one of its purposes is “to stimulate scholarship and intelligent interest in political science” (Pi Sigma Alpha 2009b). We believe our chapter has indeed met this worthy goal. I believe more chapters should and can work to achieve this as well.
POSTSCRIPT
Thanks to funding from the Chapter Activity Grant Competition, my students and I are currently collecting data on members of the 2008 Electoral College. This is the third cohort of students to conduct a survey of presidential electors over the past six years.
