It would be no small miracle if historians of the modern Middle East wrote nothing but books that appealed to a wide audience yet simultaneously advanced original arguments that both challenged conventional wisdom and fostered critical debate. Indeed, setting aside a handful of textbooks that are pitched at this level for teaching purposes, to varying degrees of success, one would perhaps have to return to Albert Hourani's A History of the Arab Peoples (Cambridge, Mass.: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1991) in order to identify a historical work that combines broadmindedness and scholarly acumen. In fact, both books under review owe much to the life and pioneering work of Hourani himself, and both admirably respond to the challenge posed by his enduring legacy for historians of the modern Middle East with accessible history that should also greatly satisfy specialists.
Eugene Rogan provides a compelling account of modern Arab history, which “begins with the Ottoman conquests of 1516–1517” (p. 6) and concludes with “George W. Bush's departure from the White House on January 20, 2009” (p. 495), striking a fine balance all the while between a brisk narrative and panoramic sweep. Lively and engaging, and illustrated with attractive color images, The Arabs: A History will interest a wide audience. Rogan proposes a four-part periodization scheme, proceeding from “the Ottoman era through the European colonial era, the era of the Cold War, and the present age of U.S. domination and globalization” (p. 6), capably guiding the reader through a tremendous amount of characters, processes, movements, and events: Ottoman expansion and contraction, modernization, and reform; French and British meddling in Arab affairs that swiftly developed into colonial aggression and imperial domination; the rise of provincial notables in the 18th century who gradually coalesced into a significant political force that would shape Arab nationalism and other political currents, including Communism and political Islam; Cold War politics that played out alongside and through various national histories and international struggles, including the Arab–Israeli conflict; and the transformation of the Middle East through its encounter with oil and the wars and corporations that oil attracts. The matter of oil, to take one example, is richly described through the story of the peripatetic Saudi-cum-Libyan oil minister and adviser Abdullah Turayqi (pp. 357–60).
To be sure, the very scope of the book precludes a detailed analysis in the limited space of this review. But through a confident voice and economic plot transitions, Rogan leaves clear signposts of his conclusions all along this rocky terrain: “After the post-World War I partition of the Middle East, the Palestine disaster stands as the most important turning point in twentieth-century Arab history. We are still living its consequences today” (p. 275); “by 1970 the Arab world was firmly divided into distinct states with their own interests to uphold” (p. 354). It is precisely this kind of historical concision and moral clarity that stand out among the key strengths of the argument. French and British imperial administrators, Arabs and Zionists in pre-1948 Palestine, populist and authoritarian leaders in the Arab world, secular and religious intellectuals—all are subject to the same kind of analytical scrutiny. Rogan is particularly good on analyzing the Arab east—the mashriq—but as opposed to conventional narratives that would give shorter shrift to zones along its periphery, much attention is paid here to related and parallel developments throughout North Africa and across the Arabian peninsula, including Yemen and the Gulf emirates. Particularly memorable are his vivid discussions of the Algerian War through literary, memoir, and filmic sources (pp. 322–31) and his reconstruction of the torturous complexity of the Lebanese Civil War and the Arab–Israeli conflict between 1976 and 1985 based on important primary sources (p. 410–23).
Rogan concludes on a note of guarded optimism with respect to the prospect for “constructive engagement by the United States, as the dominant power in a unipolar age, [which] is only part of the solution to the ills that face the Arab world in the twenty-first century. The Arabs too must assume responsibility for a better future” (p. 496). Readers will have to judge whether “responsibility” is the appropriate bellwether for contemporary historical analysis, especially in light of the fundamental multipolarity of our current world-historical moment. At any rate, Rogan insists, “Westerners need to pay far more attention to the way that history has been experienced and understood by the Arabs themselves” (p. 4). This laudable sentiment runs throughout the book, but is there not an implicit danger here of sliding back into untenable ways of conceptualizing such a relationship between an essentialized “West(erner)” and “the Arabs themselves”? Rogan is quick to complicate his seemingly all-encompassing title, however, arguing that “the Arabs . . . are one people and many peoples at the same time. . . . All of these peoples have their own, distinct history, but they all see themselves bound by a common Arab history” (p. 11).
Although reference is made throughout the book to the diversity of the Arab world, the inclusion of more concrete details of this diversity would have strengthened the argument. Furthermore, scant attention is paid to the cultural, intellectual, and social history of the Arab world beyond the purview of political titans and intellectual elites. One gets the distinct impression that the experiences of ordinary people are somehow incidental to the inexorable flow of history; although “the masses” and “mass politics” make cameo appearances throughout the book, this is a narrative of modern history told through the eyes of great men and world leaders. The Arabs is predominantly history from above. Now more than ever, historians must provide better social, cultural, and political analysis of the making of the modern Middle East, particularly in light of the surging popular activism that is identified with the “Arab Spring” and its aftermath.
Rogan has synthesized a tremendous amount of secondary literature and primary sources in French, Arabic, and English. Unlike many previous narrative histories of the modern Middle East, this book continues into the first decade of the 21st century, including a stimulating discussion of the first Gulf War, the Israeli–Palestinian “peace process,” and the Lebanese civil wars. The Arabs is at once a tremendous resource for specialists and nonspecialists alike as well as a monumental achievement of accessible narrative history. The book opens with vignettes describing the assassinations of former Lebanese prime minister Rafiq al-Hariri and Lebanese journalist Samir Kassir; it closes with the attacks of 11 September 2001. Although these are central events in recent Western engagement with “the Arabs,” it is unclear whether 11 September 2001 will ultimately “prove the moment of greatest tension in modern Arab history” (p. 482).
If Rogan offers a panoramic overview from the soaring heights of modern Arab history, Patrick Seale is right at home writing from its trenches. In his latest book, The Struggle for Arab Independence: Riad el-Solh and the Makers of the Modern Middle East, Seale is interested in other moments of tension, using the life story of Riad el-Solh (1894–1951) as a lens through which to examine the broader Arab Middle East during the late Ottoman and interwar period. Born into a notable Sunni Muslim family from Sidon, el-Solh had a political education and social formation that took him all over the eastern Mediterranean and Europe and that would locate him squarely at the heart of key issues confronting the new state of Greater Lebanon, including its identity vis-à-vis the “internal” problem of sectarianism, neighboring Syria, the Arab region, and the broader Middle East. El-Solh is thrown into relief against the backdrop of one of the most eventful periods in modern Middle East history—the heyday of Ottomanism in the early 20th century and the collapse of the Ottoman Empire following World War I, the rise of Arab nationalism and local patriotism, the formation of the Arab state system, the volatile early years of the Arab–Zionist conflict and the 1948 war of Palestine, and the flourishing of modern Arab politics despite budding struggles among more radical political and ideological forces in the Arab milieu. Seale is best at laying bare the weft and woof of modern Arab political history. Through the experiences of larger than life personalities he repeatedly finds contingency and possibility at the heart of older historical narratives about state formation, identity construction, nationalism, and political life in the Arab East during the first half of the 20th century.
Here is the social biography of an entire generation: “Old enough to have had firsthand experience of the Ottoman world yet young enough to throw all [their] energies into the new struggle for Arab independence” (p. 121), they were “a distinguished body of men—educated, refined, resolute, of international outlook yet highly conscious of their Arabism. They had experienced in their formative years the collapse of the multi-ethnic, multi-religious Ottoman world under the assaults of Balkan nationalism, Young Turk chauvinism, European imperialism and the Great War. Their Arab nationalism was not a mere drawing-room affectation” (pp. 123–24). The book is based on research in the British Foreign Office, the Başbakanlık Arşıvı in Istanbul, and the diplomatic archives of the French Ministère des affaires étrangères; contemporary press materials and extensive secondary literature in French, Arabic, and English (and even some Hebrew); and substantial interviews with family and friends of el-Solh, including several in-depth conversations with his daughter, Alia el-Solh. High-stakes international diplomacy and the colonial administration of the Mandate system are woven together with the making of Lebanese political institutions such as the unwritten National Pact of 1943 and even the banalities of everyday life: chapter sections can vary within a matter of ten pages from staid description (“From Henri Ponsot to comte Damien de Martel” [p. 266] or “Riad opens a law office” [pp. 255–56]) to more thrilling fare (“Riad el-Solh takes a wife” [p. 267], in which we learn of el-Solh's betrothal to Fayza al-Jabiri of Aleppo, niece of the Syrian nationalist leader Saʿdallah al-Jabiri).
The Struggle for Arab Independence is a baggy book (weighing in at over 700 pages of text!), and, much like The Arabs: A History, it is primarily concerned with the struggle among politicians and political elites. Seale spins riveting historical yarns, but when this style veers too hard toward the colloquial, the dispassionate historian and probing journalist seems to get pushed aside by a more credulous chronicler, and readers will need to exercise caution and judgment in separating the anecdotal from the archival. Consider this concluding paean: “Riad el-Solh had great qualities—courage, charm, shrewdness, a quick wit, pragmatism, and a great deal of patience—but at heart he was an idealist, a visionary, a fighter for freedom rather than a conventional politician. There was something of the inspirational teacher about him” (p. 734). Such historical credulity buckles when large chunks of el-Solh's writing are included with nothing more than a pithy remark that the latter “was both accurate and shrewd, as events were to prove” (p. 339), or mention is briefly made of how “Riad . . . gave powerful expression to his views” (p. 558), or materials such as the memorandum el-Solh sent to Iraqi Prime Minister Muzahim al-Pachachi are reproduced without any comment or analysis whatsoever (pp. 696–701).
Seale heroically delivers an impossible volume of information, and fascinating tidbits may be profitably strained out of this torrential flow. For example, Chapter 22, “Goodbye to the French,” depicts el-Solh and Hamid Frangieh, then Lebanese foreign minister, parlaying a bit of playful chicanery at an official social function into concrete political gains; Seale asserts that this forced the hand of Count Stanislas Ostorog, then French délégué général in Lebanon, and in turn French Foreign Minister Georges Bidault and the entire French delegation, to speed along the negotiations for complete withdrawal of French forces from the Levant by the end of 1946, at which point el-Solh returned to serving as prime minister (pp. 594–96). The close personal relationship between el-Solh and Sir Edward Spears as well as the latter's complex involvement in Middle East affairs during this tumultuous period are also richly evoked (esp. Chap. 17, “Riad Bey and General Spears,” pp. 434–55).
The details and consequences of the unsuccessful attempt on el-Solh's life in Beirut on 9 March 1950 are similarly gripping (pp. 691–92). The book concludes with a thoughtful discussion of the hotly contested and as yet unresolved intrigue surrounding his assassination on 16 July 1951 in Amman. Seale faithfully relates the official version of events (as does Rogan), which pins culpability on King ʿAbdallah, who seems to have been in cahoots with Syrian Social Nationalist Party cadres including Georges ʿAbd al-Massih (who was also involved in the assassination plot against Syrian Colonel ʿAdnan al-Malki in April 1955) (pp. 714–25). But the possibility of British and Israeli collusion, if not direct responsibility, is also held open, especially in light of new details exposed by Yosef Argaman in Milhemet ha-Tslalim: 25 Parshiyot Modiʿin u-Vitahon be-Yisraʾel: ha-Sipur ha-Male (War of Shadows: 25 Intelligence and Security Episodes in Israel, The Full Story) (Tel Aviv: Misrar ha-Bitahon, ha-Hotsaʾah le-Or, 2007) (pp. 725–27). Whatever the truth of the circumstances surrounding his assassination in July 1951, the passing of Riad el-Solh represented the end of an era for both Lebanese and Arab politics. The Struggle for Arab Independence is a fitting tribute to a man whom Seale describes as “the nearest Lebanon had come to producing a statesman of international stature” (p. 599).
Rogan and Seale are two of the most astute observers of modern and contemporary Arab history, and each has the distinction of being a wonderful writer; both books are signal achievements. As a practical matter, however, and despite all their engaged storytelling, both books are simply too long and lumpy for undergraduate- or graduate-course adoption. An adequately comprehensive history of the modern Middle East would not be restricted to elite political and intellectual history. Even as these two books attest to the current flourishing of modern Middle East studies, one may still hope for the historiography to evolve further in order to make way for similarly readable and erudite studies but which account for aspects of the region's social, intellectual, and cultural past that continue to be overlooked and underappreciated.
