No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 July 2005
As one of the very few books on postwar Lebanon, this work by Carol Dagher deserves some of our attention. The book aims to show the importance of Christians in the Middle East at large, and in Lebanon in particular, in the development of the region in light of the rapid decline of their numbers due to emigration to the West. Dagher views Lebanon as an exception in the region and the Lebanese experiment of Christian–Muslim coexistence as a crucial element for the future of the Arab world, contending that “Lebanon's failure as a meaningful experience will toll the demise of a once vibrant Arab culture and will impact the nature of Islam” (p. 4). This simplistic view, typical of some groups of Lebanese, grants Lebanon a more important role than it deserves in the regional constellation.
The book deals with some of the most important issues one has to contend with when dealing with Lebanon—namely, the issue of the identity of the state (chapter 1), the role of Muslims in postwar Lebanon (chapter 2), the problem of Christian emigration from Lebanon (chapter 4), the internal displaced (chapter 5), the exacerbated religiosity in Lebanon and the identification with the community in the postwar period (chapter 8), the circumstances of the Lebanese Christians in the years following the war, analyzing the role of “substitute leader” assumed by the Maronite patriarch (chapter 9), the role of the army in postwar Lebanon as an element for Lebanese integration (chapter 10), and, finally, the issue of political confessionalism (chapter 11). Nevertheless, these important issues come as an aside, as an explanation in Dagher's impassioned plea for Lebanon's Christians and mainly its Maronites.
Yet while the book addresses an important topic, it is also disappointing. The main argument of the book is somehow lost in all the anecdotes and stories, left unsupported by the historical, sociological, and political explanations needed to buttress the main thesis. This problem is also evident in the bibliography, which is sadly lacking, especially in terms of Arabic sources. For example, Waddah Charara's seminal book on Hizbullah, Dawlat Hizbullah, lubnan mujtama

an islamiyyan, is not even referenced. In addition, important works in English are not referred to, such as the articles written in the postwar period by Richard Norton on Hizbullah and the volume edited by Deirdre Collings titled Peace for Lebanon? From War to Reconstruction (1994). Furthermore, the issue of Arab Studies Quarterly dedicated to Lebanon (Winter 1999), with contributions by Michael Hudson and Sami Ofeish, who deal with some of the arguments Dagher is analyzing when she broaches the issues of confessionalism and the role of religious leaders in postwar Lebanon, is not included.
In short, this book is more a descriptive than an analytic work; it is not a scientific study of Lebanon in the postwar years. It is, rather, a journalistic account of some of the main events that followed the Ta[right-curve]if Agreement in Lebanon. Dagher falls for the common fallacy in Lebanon of calling the country a “democracy” (pp. 52, 57, 159) while a more accurate description would speak of “the existence of democratic practices.” In addition, Dagher is not striving for objectivity. Some of her statements are highly debatable, such as her affirmation that Lebanon “is an absolute necessity, not only for Christians, but for all minorities in the Arab East. Christian presence leads to a civilizational and cultural interaction with the West” (p. 29; emphasis added). Her assertions that Lebanese Muslims are different from Muslims in other countries because of their interaction with their Christian counterparts (p. 44) and that they now feel “increasingly responsible for the preservation of the Christian presence in Lebanon and in the rest of the Arab world” (p. 47) are also highly debatable.
Hence, this work is not fit for the classroom. However, it is a valuable account of events never dealt with before, such as the Synod for Lebanon organized by the Holy See (chapters 6 and 7) and the visit of the pope to Lebanon and the implications of this visit for the future of Lebanon (chapter 12). The ideal target audience for this book is, I believe, experts on Lebanon who need some light shed on the role of the Holy See in Lebanon and on the soul-searching of the Maronite community. Researchers working on postwar Lebanon can also get a general idea of the situation in the country—once they do away with the main thesis.