On page 5 of her book, Hallie Eakin makes a statement that can serve as the focus and raison d'etre of her excellent monograph:
In academic circles, vulnerability to climate and vulnerability to economic change have, until quite recently, been considered as independent and unrelated processes. In research on climate vulnerability and adaptation, the social context of climate impacts has often been held constant or, for the sake of simplicity, is assumed to change gradually and linearly. The opposite can also be said of research on social change: if mentioned at all, climate is often considered to be part of the physical background against which social and institutional upheavals occur. Rarely are global political-economic and global environmental change considered together as dynamic and interacting drivers of local vulnerability.
This book is unusual in that it addresses this neglect, and does so through rigorous empirical and ethnographic analysis of small farmers' behaviour and preferences. Although there is a mountain of material on peasant farmers' behaviour in Latin America, and a growing and considerable literature on climate change and agriculture, there are few studies which combine the two and, in addition, seek to explore the cumulative risks to which farm families are exposed, especially with the onset of anthropogenic climate change.
Eakin does not assume that farmers make calculations about their practices and the combined effect of both political economy and climate. Instead, she lets the producers identify the linkages for themselves, and by adopting a livelihoods approach ‘recognises that the assets on which livings are based are not simply financial resources and physical property, but also social networks, bonds of trust and investment in institutions and organisation (social capital)’ (p. 10). She notes that rural areas are co-evolving with urban areas, and increasingly need to be understood in terms of urban change. She finds that the livelihood approach facilitates the analysis of the multiple points of stress which constrain household choices. Indeed, vulnerability and adaptive capacity are presented as two sides of the same coin. Households are inhibited in their capacity to adapt, and in this lies much of their vulnerability. In an eloquent section, Eakin argues that: ‘their vulnerability reflects the coincidence of climate shocks and opportunity constrained by history, politics and economics, and the resources available to them before, during and after the moment of crisis’ (p. 13).
The book ranges from the global and conceptual to the highly detailed and ethnographic. The first chapter provides an excellent summary of the links between climate uncertainty and the small farmer. Chapter Two then examines agriculture and climate in the Puebla-Tlaxcala Valley, the primary focus for the empirical research. The following chapter (Three) is one of the best accounts I have read of the impact of neoliberalism on agrarian restructuring in Mexico. It examines the context provided by the Green Revolution research, and the debates surrounding the ‘via campesina’, the survival of the ejido, and the alternatives with which politicians and commentators have toyed as a consequence.
This chapter explores the effects of the withdrawal of the Mexican state from many areas of agriculture and, notwithstanding this retreat, the re-emergence of the Mexican state in new and myriad forms in the last decade. There is a useful section on NAFTA and Mexican agriculture, concentrating in particular on the capacity for retrenchment in rural areas. The continuing and increasing importance of migration, and the bridging of rural and urban economies, are seen as the necessary adaptation made essentially by the Mexican rural and urban poor, in the absence of policies to make restructuring more humane and defensible. Eakin is no conspiracy theorist, and argues that in some respects at least, this restructuring, which has shifted and altered clientelism and opened up new networks of information, also carries opportunities for Mexican small farmers and migrants.
Chapter Four documents three communities in Central Mexico, that constitute the key case studies and, in Chapter Five, the impacts of climate on the strategies available to people in the region are considered. Chapter Six deepens this analysis by considering the importance of land scarcity in these cases, and the subsequent chapter looks at market exposure, employment alternatives and risk management. Eakin's conclusion is quite radical, at least in the context of policy which has systematically ignored it for decades. This is that the possession of an adequate amount of land for subsistence is the best single ingredient of rural survival strategies in the area. Even though the policy community has sought to transform the rural subsistence producer, since s/he is seen as part of the problem, in fact it is subsistence production that has enabled rural households to survive the rigours of transition and increased vulnerability to the market. She views subsistence as ‘a core component of the resilience of the rural sector’ (p. 195).
The book makes good use of black and white photographs, has a useful appendix on methodology and an excellent bibliography. Not the least of the author's accomplishments is a first-rate review of the recent literature on adaptation to environmental risks, which in fact serves to inform those who work in the urban sector in addition to those principally concerned with the rural areas of Mexico. She concludes by saying that the pursuit of one model of agriculture to the exclusion of all others has cramped and restrained Mexican agriculture. There needs to be much more sensitivity among policymakers of the importance of enabling and facilitating adaptation, rather than pressing forward with large scale global food production alone. This is an excellent, intelligent and beautifully crafted volume. It adds much to what we know about Mexican agriculture today – not least because the warnings were there thirty and more years ago, before the neoliberal experiments were advanced.
