This book is the first general history of the political development of the Later Han dynasty in English, written by a veteran scholar in the field. For over half a century, Rafe de Crespigny has devoted great energy to studying the Later Han and promoting the study of it, which still lags far behind in depth and breadth compared with that of the preceding Former Han dynasty. Of his long list of publications, mainly political history, some of them have already become must-read on the topics; he has therefore made his name a synonym for the Later Han studies in Anglophone scholarship, so as Michael Loewe for the Former Han. de Crespigny is thus arguably the most suitable person to write such a general account of the dynasty. As a former student of the late sinologist Hans Bielenstein (1920–2015), a pioneer of Western studies of Later Han history in the twentieth century who produced a series of book-length studies of the dynasty, de Crespigny crafted this book as a continuation of the legacy left by Bielenstein, as well as a kind of dialogue between the late teacher and his disciple. One would be impressed by the great respect de Crespigny paid to Bielenstein by only reading the first few pages; as the reading proceeded, the reader would find that Bielenstein's works were frequently cited and discussed, especially in the first half of the book. Given Bielenstein's detailed research on the establishment and early years of the Later Han, the author only provides a brief account of the reign of the first monarch of the dynasty, while setting the main focus on the period from the second emperor onward. Nevertheless, even though Bielenstein had laid a solid foundation on the subject, the frequent consultation with his works might impose hurdles in understanding the incipient period of the dynasty for those who are not familiar with his voluminous writings.
As the title of the book tells, the history being narrated is centered on the imperial city of Luoyang. de Crespigny gives detailed account of the geographical and architectural settings of Luoyang and its surroundings in general and the palaces in particular in the first chapter. It is an important step of setting the stage to navigate the reader through, as the story unfolds, numerous coups d'état, court intrigues, and assassinations taking place at different halls and gates of the palace compound and the city. The book then moves chronologically, beginning with the establishment of the dynasty in 25 AD and concluding with the abdication of its last sovereign in 220 AD. de Crespigny uses the reigns of the emperors for the warp and a variety of incidents for the weft, which together weave the complex picture of the rise and fall of the Later Han empire over the course of two centuries. Following the traditional format of the chronicles of emperors in the standard dynastic history, disparate people are mentioned and thus bound together through the activities they took part in during a certain monarch's reign. While the account of politics, especially in Luoyang and at the imperial court, constitutes the common thread, the book branches out, when necessary, to provide information on relevant administrative and economic institutions, military systems, philosophical thoughts, and religious beliefs, as well as neighbouring peoples and their cultures, for a comprehensive view of the era.
Partly inspired by Bielenstein's classic study of Luoyang, de Crespigny sets the city as the centre of this book since it was the “political and spiritual heart of the state” and “the fate of the dynasty itself depended upon events at the palaces” (p. 3). In imperial China, the capital where the emperor and most of the ruling elites resided was indeed the head and heart of the empire and any unfavourable incident which happened there might inevitably wreak havoc on the whole realm. The imperial capital, however, was not always the sole epicentre which radiated effects outward. Sometimes it was the other way around. There were interactions between the capital and regions, centre and peripheries, and also between people in different areas. As a political history focusing on Luoyang, this book limits itself mainly on the study of high politics, with the actions of and struggles for power among high-ranking government officials and elite politicians, thus paying insufficient attention to the groups outside the central elite circles. Besides, there were various regional cultures, identities, and interests under the façade of a unified empire which played crucial roles in triggering the final disintegration of the Later Han, but focusing on the melodrama and its actors in Luoyang downplays their importance to some extent. Such a focus also limits the scope of primary sources to be employed in the book. While received traditional texts have been exhaustively used, archaeological findings are mainly limited to those excavated around Luoyang while stele inscriptions scattered across the imperial realm do not necessarily fit into the account. Moreover, the book would have been more informative if the works of reference could be expanded. For example, much ink was spilled in the book on the growth of scholar-officials during the Han times and the merits and demerits of the bureaucratic systems of recommendation and recruitment. However, the detailed analyses along these lines by the Chinese historian Yan Buke in his 1996 and 1997 monographs, which are highly relevant to the subject, were surprisingly not consulted, not to mention other more recent Chinese scholarship.
Throughout the book, de Crespigny puts forward two main concerns. The first is to promote the study of the Later Han as an empire on its own terms and be cautious in following the trend of making comparison between the Han empire and its Roman counterpart, which might be of limited value. The second is to trace the causes of what eventually brought down the empire. He attributes the failure of the Later Han to two major aspects: firstly, a series of short-lived emperors—most of them died early and were usually succeeded by underage boys—which led to unceasing power struggles and political purges between distaff families, eunuchs, and the bureaucracy, which significantly destabilised the transition of power between every reign and consequently undermined the authority of the throne; secondly, the unrestricted growth of the great landowning families and their increasing participation in the imperial service gradually bred conflicts between family loyalty and loyalty to the state, which always resulted in the triumph of the former and further encouraged the development of centrifugal forces.
While sharing de Crespigny's first concern, I would like to make an even bolder suggestion. As I have argued elsewhere, the Later Han dynasty was not a lacklustre continuation of the Former Han depicted in the conventional historical account, but a very different regime. Given the facts, among others, that the founding emperor of the Later Han was only a descendant of the collateral branch of the Former Han imperial house, the compositions of ruling elites of the two Han dynasties were strikingly different, and the predecessor's institutions and systems were altered and abolished, the Later Han was an empire only in the name of Han, which used the cloak of rhetoric of being a revival of the Former Han as a tool to win legitimacy in the civil war preceding its establishment. Moreover, through examining the history of the rise and fall of the Later Han, de Crespigny tries to show that the Later Han was as endurable and strong as the Former Han and the Roman empires, of which I have no doubt. However, I would also like to suggest that perhaps new research would shift the paradigm by not following a rise-and-fall trajectory. In fact, there was no glorious rise of the Later Han; it was in constant troubles like border warfare (with the Qiang wars lasting for over a century), banditry, rebellion, political purges, and even natural disasters. By taking a different perspective of studying the Later Han as an embattled empire from the onset and examining how it tackled challenges with the resources available and struggled across the two centuries of its mandate, we might be able to avoid some of the long-standing prejudices against the regime derived from the conventional rise-and-fall narrative, and even rethink some of the explanations of the ‘fall’ of the Later Han. The two causes of the failure of the empire concluded by de Crespigny are customarily analyzed and nothing beyond. For example, the Chinese historian Qian Mu (1895–1990) had coined the “degeneration of the unified state” for the first cause and the “concept of duality of lordship” for the second in the 1940s.
As a book on Chinese history, it is for the reader's convenience to provide Chinese characters along with pinyin. Unfortunately, the book is full of wrong Chinese characters. Here are only some examples: the Chinese character of the posthumous title of the Former Han's second emperor “Hui” should be 惠, not 愚 (p. 6); the Clear Terrace should be 清臺, not 清壹 (p. 36); likewise, the Cloud Terrace should be 雲臺, not 雲壹 (p. 224); the “Account of the Western Qiang” should be 西羌傳, not 西羌傅 (p. 136); the temple-name of Emperor Shun of the Later Han “Jingzong” should be 敬宗, not 恭宗 (p. 267); the former officers “guli” should be 故吏, not 古吏 (p. 326); the cultured gentlemen “shi” should be 士, not 史 (p. 486); the two places Taiyuan and Wuyuan should be 太原 and 五原 respectively, not 太厡 and 五厡 (p. 511).
All in all, this book will provide a comprehensive overview to advanced graduate students and scholars who are interested in but not familiar with the political history of the Later Han empire, whereas those who are already working in the field might be able to explore new perspectives and themes based on this solid work.
