Introduction
Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation (SLAPPs) are legal suits that are meant to silence critics. While anti-SLAPP defenses have gained considerable traction in the United States (U.S.) and more recently across Europe and the United Kingdom (UK), their comprehensive integration into African legal frameworks remains to be fully realized.Footnote 1 This contribution examines the role of civil society actors in resisting SLAPPs within the context of business and human rights litigation in Southern Africa. The prevailing understanding of SLAPPs typically involves a powerful corporate entity initiating legal proceedings against activists and journalists in response to public statements concerning the corporation. More recent trends from the Global South, however, indicate that SLAPPs manifest in various forms, encompassing both criminal and civil legal actions initiated by influential corporations and/or elite individuals against activists, journalists, and bloggers who have publicly expressed concerns about them. Footnote 2 This essay focuses on Southern Africa’s civil society interventions and the role that these interventions have played in shaping the emerging anti-SLAPP jurisprudence. This is evidenced through doctrinal engagement with courts, strategic coalition-building, and normative advocacy grounded in international human rights standards. The analysis focuses on the SLAPP case law and offers a practice-oriented framework for understanding how civic action can counter legal harassment by corporate and politically connected actors in fragile institutional contexts.
The Power Imbalance
Systemic power and financial imbalances between corporate litigants or elite individuals and less powerful defendants often pervert legal processes into instruments of exhaustion and insolvency, thus diluting their protective purpose. Even in instances where a justice system is geared toward fairness, the legal threats and lawsuits can become a tool of harassment. This power imbalance is more pronounced in cases where judicial systems are vulnerable to manipulation. In such instances, the effectiveness of the legal system to uphold justice is eroded, and the SLAPP victim is even more vulnerable.
Many Southern African jurisdictions exhibit structural weaknesses in institutional protections, including constraints on judicial independence and accountability mechanisms.Footnote 3 This situation leaves SLAPP targets at the mercy of a judiciary that blurs the lines of independence and buckles to politics when pressures mount. The World Justice Project Rule of Law Index shows a low ranking for institutional checks on executive power across Southern Africa.Footnote 4 South Africa is ranked better in terms of constraints on power, whereas Botswana and Namibia exhibit moderate institutional robustness. Malawi, Zambia, and Zimbabwe, however, are much lower on the list. These indicators, while not determinative, illustrate structural conditions that may increase the susceptibility of legal systems to SLAPP abuse.
These structural weaknesses are compounded by the concentration of SLAPPs in sectors such as mining, agriculture, and oil and gas, which dominate Southern African economies and are closely linked to political power.Footnote 5 The South African Gupta corporate family case illustrates how deep entanglement between political elites and private economic actors can erode institutional independence and enable the use of legal processes to shield their interests from scrutiny.Footnote 6
The close and often opaque relationships between political elites and private economic actors in Southern Africa create conditions in which legal systems may be vulnerable to manipulation. Where corporate interests are closely aligned with executive power, judicial independence risks being compromised, particularly in cases involving public-interest scrutiny. For civil society, resistance to SLAPPs therefore becomes part of the broader struggles for democratic accountability and economic justice. Footnote 7 In this context, strategic engagement in litigation assumes increasing importance as a means of advancing remedies for those targeted by SLAPPs.
Doctrinal Approach
The concept of SLAPPs is rooted in the injustice that is brought about when a public issue, which is typically the underlying trigger for the legal action, becomes the subject of a direct private action against the person or organization who publicized the issue. Such legal actions go against the rule of law principle of public participation, which serves as a fundamental pillar for the freedom of expression and access to information. Not only do such legal actions harm the realization of human rights, but the use of courtrooms to facilitate the harms undermines the role of the legal system. This section traces the emergence and evolution of the SLAPP doctrine within Southern African legal systems. Rather than developing through formal legislative reform, the recognition of SLAPPs in the region has unfolded through litigation, judicial reasoning, and sustained civil society engagement. Civil society actors play a significant role in maintaining the integrity of the legal system by participating in legal actions as amicus curiae and bringing attention to the fact that the case is a SLAPP.
Across the region, a series of disputes displaying SLAPP characteristics have emerged in the recent past. In some instances, the litigation has not been formally identified as such. In 2020, a Zimbabwean independent newspaper was threatened with legal action by a Dutch company, Integrated Energy BV. The threat arose from a public interest story that had been published about the company’s operations in Albania, shortly after the government’s announcement that the company had been awarded a tender in Zimbabwe. Although no proceedings ultimately followed, the threat was reported by an independent media outlet as amounting to a SLAPP. Footnote 8 In 2021, a South African case, First Quantum Minerals v. Southern Africa Resources Watch (SARW), was initiated in response to a public interest report issued by SARW on the Canadian company’s operations in a Zambian community.Footnote 9 The matter was later withdrawn by the company; the media had also reported the matter as a SLAPP. Taken together, these disputes illustrate the core SLAPP dynamic of corporate actors invoking legal processes to deter scrutiny. The framing of these disputes as SLAPPs in public discourse reflects an informal articulation of the doctrine that would later find expression in judicial reasoning.
The South African courts’ formal, explicit recognition of a SLAPP defense in the 2022 case of Mineral Sands Resources (Pty) Ltd and Others v. Reddell and Others Footnote 10 marked a doctrinal turning point in the region. The case has stirred the discourse around the concept of SLAPPs, and its success was largely influenced by the strategic advocacy actions of civil society actors. The decision catalyzed broader engagement with SLAPPs as a legal concept and reflected the influence of sustained civil society advocacy. Beyond South Africa, a 2024 stakeholder engagement convened by the Campaign for Free Expression in Malawi documented the routine use of defamation laws, cybercrime legislation, and litigation threats to intimidate journalists and civil society actors in the absence of an anti-SLAPP framework.Footnote 11 Although no reported judgments explicitly recognize SLAPPs elsewhere in the sub-region, the findings in the Malawian report confirm a pattern of business-linked legal intimidation producing a clear chilling effect on public-interest expression in that country.Footnote 12
The pattern is also reflected in a 2025 decision of the Zambian High Court that set aside an interim interdict obtained by the Chinese Chamber of Commerce in Zambia against the media house News Diggers following the release of a trailer for an investigative documentary. The court reaffirmed that prior restraint is not justified where the media intends to rely on a defense of justification in the public interest. Although the Zambian court did not label the matter a SLAPP, the litigation displayed its defining characteristics, including the use of urgent civil procedure by a powerful business association to suppress public-interest reporting.Footnote 13
The South African jurisprudence has affirmed that a SLAPP may be raised as a preliminary defense (in limine), enabling courts to terminate abusive proceedings at an early stage without engaging the merits. The incremental adoption of the recognition of the SLAPP defense in that jurisdiction has been through targeted civil society intervention in notable cases that link public participation, the constitutional right to freedom of expression, and the prohibition of abuse of process. The historic Constitutional court ruling in Mineral Sands laid the foundation for the widespread recognition of SLAPP defenses in common law and was later expanded to criminal proceedings.Footnote 14 In that case, most notably the Centre for Applied Legal Studies (CALS), as amicus curiae, set out the nature and treatment of SLAPP suits in foreign jurisdictions, focusing on the tests used in foreign jurisdictions to identify and address cases presenting as or alleged to be SLAPP suits. The South African Constitutional Court consequently upheld the validity of SLAPP as a legal defense, grounded in the doctrine of abuse of process and the constitutionally protected right to freedom of expression.
The Mineral Sands decision served as a benchmark for subsequent cases in South Africa. In Maughan v. Zuma, the KwaZulu-Natal High Court reinforced the recognition of the SLAPP defense, extending it to criminal proceedings. Civil society actors again played a prominent role, with several organizations admitted as amici curiae. The Court’s finding that a criminal prosecution could constitute a SLAPP further expanded the doctrine’s protective scope.
Courts in other Southern African jurisdictions have yet to develop clear jurisprudence recognizing SLAPP defenses. Nonetheless, the South African doctrinal stance on SLAPPs stands to have a catalyzing effect on neighboring jurisdictions. By framing SLAPPs in terms of abuse of process, South Africa’s approach allows courts to recognize the defense within existing procedural law. Given the shared Roman-Dutch and common-law traditions across much of Southern Africa, South African judicial reasoning is highly persuasive in neighboring jurisdictions, including Namibia, Botswana, Zambia, Zimbabwe, and Malawi.Footnote 15 Historically, these legal systems of South Africa’s neighboring countries are aligned in ideology, method, approach, and content.Footnote 16 In this respect, the South African experience provides a legal blueprint that civil society actors and courts elsewhere in the region may adapt in resisting the misuse of legal processes to silence public participation.Footnote 17
Finally, comparative experience beyond Southern Africa reinforces the central role of civil society in shaping anti-SLAPP doctrine. In both the United States and Canada, the development of anti-SLAPP protections has been driven by sustained advocacy from journalists, environmental organizations, and public-interest groups.Footnote 18 These experiences underscore that civil society intervention operates not merely as a defensive response to individual cases but as a deliberate mechanism for influencing legal doctrine and institutional practice. The question that follows is how civil society can further translate this emerging doctrine into broader and more durable forms of protection beyond individual cases.
Strategic Approaches
The doctrinal evolution of SLAPP jurisprudence, as signaled by the Mineral Sands case, provides an essential legal foundation upon which civil society can build broader strategic interventions across the sub-region. However, doctrinal development alone is insufficient to counter the systemic misuse of legal processes to silence public participation. The recognition of SLAPPs has therefore functioned not as an endpoint, but as a catalyst for coordinated strategic action by civil society actors seeking to entrench protective principles beyond individual cases.
These strategies have taken multiple, mutually reinforcing forms, including carefully selected test cases, amicus interventions, and constitutional framing. Far from being a purely doctrinal evolution, the recognition of SLAPPs in South African jurisprudence reflects a broader influence of activism by journalists, environmental defenders, and public interest organizations targeting a systemic issue. This section outlines the strategic approaches that civil society has taken to mount pressure around the judicial recognition of SLAPPs in the region.
One such approach has been the development of legislative models to address SLAPPs directly. CALS and its partners have developed an anti-SLAPP model law. This model is proposed as a holistic framework to prohibit SLAPPs, establish a definitive legal test for their identification, and assign the burden of proof. It also mandates the creation of expedited judicial mechanisms for the early adjudication of SLAPP allegations, provides courts with definitive procedural guidelines, and stipulates robust remedies for victims, such as protective costs orders.Footnote 19
The adoption of legislation can be prolonged, as its realization is ultimately contingent upon legislative lobbying and a degree of political cohesion. This is often absent in contexts where repressive regimes are in power. Consequently, the lack of political will to address the misuse of the judicial system for retaliatory purposes will likely serve as an impediment in the Southern African states where repressive tendencies are common. Model laws such as that developed by CALS and allies, however, can shape judicial imagination to influence future decisions. To support the legislative approach, public awareness campaigns are useful in reframing SLAPPs as a matter of general public concern.
Civil society can spearhead campaigns in their various forms. This may range from public platforms for dialogue with key actors, such as affected communities, academics, and legal experts, to joint public statements condemning SLAPPs to demonstrate widespread support and legitimize the defendant’s cause. Public exposure of SLAPPs can disrupt the power asymmetry on which such litigation relies, amplifying the position of defendants and reframing disputes as matters of public concern.
Coalition-based initiatives such as the Coalition Against SLAPPs in Africa (CASA) reflect the growing recognition that countering SLAPPs requires institutionalized solidarity. Although still in its early stages, CASA’s value lies in monitoring trends, supporting affected actors, and functioning as an early warning mechanism within the region.Footnote 20
Taken together, these strategic approaches demonstrate that resisting SLAPPs requires more than doctrinal recognition. Their effectiveness ultimately depends on sustained regional coordination and a shared understanding that SLAPPs threaten not only individual litigants but also the broader conditions necessary for democratic governance and economic justice.
Toward a Normative Framework
The doctrinal and strategic responses to SLAPPs reveal the need for a normative framework capable of addressing the structural conditions that allow such litigation to flourish. Without a shared rights-based foundation, efforts to counter SLAPPs risk remaining fragmented, reactive, and confined to individual cases. A normative approach enables the transformation of anti-SLAPP advocacy from a series of defensive legal interventions into a coordinated project aimed at systemic accountability.
At the core of this framework is a reorientation of both corporate and state responsibilities. For corporate actors, it requires a shift away from the typified approach of treating public scrutiny as a commercial risk to be neutralized. Rather, it requires a move toward recognizing civic oversight as integral to sustainable and responsible business practice. For states, it demands proactive measures to protect civic space and human rights defenders, rather than a passive reliance on remedies or complaint mechanisms that only offer protection after the occurrence of or threat of a SLAPP. This dual reorientation aligns with the United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (UNGPs), which provide an established normative architecture for balancing economic activity with democratic accountability.Footnote 21
Viewed through the UNGP framework, SLAPPs represent a failure across all three pillars. Under Pillar I, the state duty to protect is compromised where judicial harassment is tolerated or facilitated through weak procedural safeguards and legislative gaps. Under Pillar II, the corporate responsibility to respect human rights is breached when legal action is used to suppress freedom of expression and public participation. Pillar III further exposes a critical gap, as SLAPP targets often face insurmountable barriers to remedy due to cost, delay, and procedural disadvantage.Footnote 22 Together, these failures underscore the systemic nature of SLAPPs and the inadequacy of purely defensive legal responses.
Within this normative framework, civil society assumes an expanded role that requires ongoing efforts. The systematic documentation of SLAPPs enables civil society actors to engage more deliberately with the structures that sustain legal harassment. An evidence base allows advocacy to move upstream, toward legislative oversight, judicial reform, and direct engagement with corporate actors on the legal, reputational, and financial consequences of abusive litigation. In this way, civil society’s role evolves from responding to individual attacks to advancing broader safeguards that protect public participation and accountability.
This approach is particularly relevant in Southern Africa, where civic space is limited and institutional checks are uneven. Regional human rights mandates reinforce the need for coordinated, cross-sectoral engagement. The 2023 Resolution on Business and Human Rights of the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights, for instance, underscores the importance of collaboration between states, civil society, and other stakeholders in addressing legislative and policy gaps that undermine accountability.Footnote 23 Within this context, civil society performs a dual function: monitoring compliance with human rights standards and advocating for the legal and institutional reforms necessary to prevent the misuse of legal systems against those engaged in public-interest work.
Framing SLAPPs within a normative business and human rights framework, therefore, does more than provide conceptual clarity. It legitimizes concerted action, aligns disjointed advocacy efforts around shared standards, and reinforces the understanding that protecting civic space is integral to both democratic governance and responsible economic activity.
Conclusion
South Africa’s recognition of SLAPPs illustrates how doctrinal development, sustained civil society engagement, and alignment with international human rights standards can converge to reshape legal responses to abusive litigation. It confirms that civil society actors are not peripheral to jurisprudential change but play a central role in identifying systemic harms and advancing corporate accountability where institutional safeguards are uneven. An effective response to SLAPPs in Southern Africa requires a coordinated regional approach grounded in mutually reinforcing elements. At a doctrinal level, treating SLAPPs as an aspect of abuse of process, drawing on South African jurisprudence as persuasive authority, provides courts with a principled basis to curb retaliatory litigation. At a strategic level, deeper coordination among civil society organizations, lawyers, and journalists remains necessary to support test litigation, consolidate evidence, sustain public engagement, and build political will for reform. Finally, embedding standards such as the United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights, together with the implementation of relevant African Commission resolutions, offers a framework for recalibrating the relationship between economic power, state responsibility, and democratic participation. Taken together, these approaches move responses to SLAPPs beyond ad hoc defense toward a more preventative and systemic framework that recognizes broader commitments to civic space, business accountability, and democratic governance.
