Reconstructing the forgotten past of society's most marginalized children poses significant challenges for even the most gifted historians. Indeed, the creaking edifice of time has cast long shadows on Oakland's charitable landscape. Fortunately, Marta Gutman has found a way to make water flow from rock, re-creating the lost world of Oakland's child-focused charities and the women who created them. A City for Children investigates the relationship among reform women, architecture, and charity for children in Oakland over the course of a century. Gutman guides readers through the establishment of orphanages, homes for abandoned children, settlement houses, kindergartens, playgrounds, day nurseries, and segregated charitable organizations, as well as state-directed distribution of assistance in the Progressive and New Deal Eras. Much like the charity women who transformed old to new, Gutman breathes new life into our understanding of women, children, and architecture—adding, raising, and repurposing theoretical and historical scholarship—to make an important contribution to our understanding of charity in the American West.
During the nineteenth century, middle-class charity women employed domestic gender ideology to claim moral authority over the problem of modern urban poverty—a condition seen to afflict disproportionately women and children. Driven by the sentimentalized conviction that children might be saved (or destroyed) by external influences, reform women constructed and repurposed buildings to socialize children in middle-class values. Decisions to rent or purchase property reflected competition between men and women for public space. Physical spaces offered women footholds into the public sphere, allowing them to transform traditionally male spaces into feminized outposts of reform. A saloon became a kindergarten. Houses and cottages became homes for abandoned and orphaned children. Construction and renovation projects carried women further into the public sphere as they sought funds from municipal, state, and private sources. Although free kindergartens and settlement houses depended upon wealthy donors, the state grew to rely on women to provide care to dependent children by providing subsidies.
The form of charitable buildings was as important as the services rendered within. Childhood does not simply exist within physical space, Gutman notes, “rather space and childhood are mutually constitutive” (29). Reformers carefully structured each institution, orphanage, kindergarten, settlement house, playground, and community center—nodes within the charitable landscape, in Gutman's terminology—to suit their goals. Charities gradually replaced large, imposing purpose-built mid-nineteenth century institutions with smaller buildings that more closely resembled middle-class homes and families. The repurposed structure was central to this effort. Guided by a paucity of funds and desire to operate within multiethnic and multiracial working-class communities, women repurposed buildings nearest to community institutions, including schools and churches. For instance, free kindergartens expressed the belief that even working-class children were entitled to a childhood replete with specialized spaces, toys, and learning. Educators combined place and pedagogy to combat the perceived evils of immigrant communities: mixed-use spaces that fostered defective domesticity and offered few spaces for children. Settlement houses offered training in the domestic sciences and organized leisure activities to children. Such repurposed buildings also provided working-class families with models of middle-class domesticity. Hoping to impart within their immigrant and minority clients a sense of Anglo Saxon refinement and frugality, reformers adorned cottages, kindergartens, and clubhouses with the material culture of the middle class.
As its subtitle suggests, the text focuses far more on reformers than the objects of reform. Readers interested in the perspectives of children must wait eight chapters and seventy-five years into the narrative to learn how individual children experienced institutional life. The addition of these voices lends a strength and nuance absent from earlier chapters. Their recollections from the late 1920s are predictably grim, even as California unleashed progressive reforms designed to combat mistreatment, rigidity, and conforming practices common within congregate orphanages. Guided by the conviction that children deserved a protected childhood and individual identities, reformers directed policy away from providing subsidies to private orphanages toward issuing mothers’ pensions to keep needy families together, as well as placing children in foster care and constructing smaller cottage institutions to provide closer alternatives to biological families. Modernization came with a price. Such reforms entangled charities in new regulations and inspections, subjected children to objectification by the state, and hardened practices of racial segregation.
Oakland's charitable landscape was shaped by its ethnic, racial, and religious pastiche. During the nineteenth century, charities and institutions sorted children according to categories of delinquency and dependency, race and ethnicity, and religion. These considerations affected the type of care children received, as well as where they received it. In many cases, Catholic institutions served as bulwarks against the efforts of Protestant charities to reshape immigrant culture. Sorting often transcended practical considerations. For example, Gutman notes that sorting instituted in a home for unwed mothers and illegitimate children employed “the social power that comes from knowledge, to act on the subject, and to define the sense of self from within” (123). Such practices hardened, rather than alleviated, categories of illegitimacy for children and illicit motherhood for their mothers. Although charities introduced racially integrated spaces to the charitable landscape by the end of the century, these too deferred to the prerogatives of white privilege and Americanization. Progressive reforms undid trends toward integration. In particular, children's agents scrutinized Catholic orphanages that failed to adequately Americanize the children of Mexican and Eastern and Southern European immigrants. Americanization was less of a priority for nonwhite children who were regarded as dubious candidates for citizenship, and California encouraged the creation of racially segregated orphanages. By the New Deal, the color line divided the charitable landscape; by the 1950s, many institutions for nonwhite children dissolved.
Readers learn much about charitable, institutional, and architectural practices of urban centers elsewhere in the United States—most thoroughly in the second chapter, which deals with precursor charitable landscapes in Chicago, New York, and San Francisco. Gutman also depends on scholarship detailing cultural shifts in how Americans perceived childhood as a social category and distinctive stage of life. However, the tight focus on reformers and charitable institutions leaves less space to fully explore these ideas. As a result, the text will feel most comfortable in the hands of those already familiar with the literature on the history of childhood.
This thoroughly enjoyable and informative read is likely to find a place on the shelves of those most interested in the history of architecture, childhood, women, and reform. Gutman's penetrating analysis plugs a gaping hole in our understanding of the charitable landscape of the West and United States more broadly.
