This ambitious, provocative book presents a new impression of classical theatre, from its earliest records in ancient Athens to its gradual decline and sudden overthrow in late Christian antiquity, as an ongoing process of loss, reconstitution, and memorialization. The lore of ruins is that they are traces accidentally left behind and just as accidentally discovered, remnants that call upon those who encounter them to make something of them again. But Ruins: Classical Theater and Broken Memory, surveying a millennium of remembering and re-membering Athenian and Roman drama, argues that the ruins of what we recognize as classical theatre did not come about by accident. Their ruining was contemporaneous, ongoing, tactical, deployed to obscure other traces, to hide scars, to set clues or indictments. Making ruins is one way those who occupy any historical moment shape both its past and its future. Classical theatre not only grew from its ruin, it sustained and transformed itself by its ruining.
Ruins reminds us first of classical theatre's scope. Its slow and varied wreck lasted a millennium and spanned the Mediterranean basin and much of Europe, from Spain to Turkey, England to Egypt. New Comedy in particular was “the most pan-Mediterranean experience in the whole Mediterranean” (104), a unifying force first for Hellenistic culture and then for Roman Empire. Classical drama, or at least some recollections of it, continues to shape performance theory and practice worldwide even today. With its division of tragedy and comedy as the two essential dramatic arcs, its glances at untraceable origins in inexplicable rituals and uncontrollable passions, ancient drama continues to offer boundary lines and asymptotes for performance. Above all, it leaves us absence as a hallmark of performance as well as of antiquity: both persist in their ruins and, if they are recovered, seem to spring from them. While the history of classical theatre is vast, though, it is not universal; it emerges fitfully, contingently, and its influences continue in the same uneven ways. Rather than taking classical theatre as a stable benchmark for performance, Ruins offers a series of historically specific accounts of disappearance and transformation as theatrical phenomena in the classical world.
Ruins covers a lot of territory, proposing incisive possibilities for grasping classical theatre; it is a series of core samples and wound probings rather than a systematic or exhaustive survey. It does not include many conventional readings of plays, in or out of contexts. Instead, it reframes the contexts in which we might place most ancient genres, not only both comedy and tragedy, both Greek and Roman, but also satyr plays, theatre architecture, pantomime, and a host of other forms of performance and representation. It works through the telling detail, sometimes an anecdote but more often an artifact: graffiti on ancient theatre walls, lead tablets buried by slaves cursing their masters, even the texts by which favored anecdotes of ancient theatre reach us. A refrain is the phrase “I am fascinated by . . . ,” and its experience of capture becomes the reader's guide.
Several themes or figures recur with marked rhythm; fascination is only one of them. Many others are, of course, kinds of ruin: the scar, the defaced memorial, the consumed feast, the way loss itself is remembered by being forgotten, in a dynamic of amnesty and amnesia. Ancient theatre was made of forceful, repeated gestures of forgetting and re-membering its own history and that of its changing worlds, a production of gaps, fragments, and sutures. Marks of oblivion are where this book hunts most of its stories, and foremost among these is ancient theatre itself, continually betraying its origins but also recalling and meditating on its betrayal, more adept at remembering its last crisis than seeing current ones. The result is an account of ancient drama that is both long range and close up, intimate and encompassing.
Like the protean classical theatre it presents, Ruins is so rich and varied that it defies easy summary. Its chapters offer not a unified argument, but powerful pictures that call on readers to reimagine what they think they know of ancient theatre. Its “Prologue: The Unmixed Prior” and first chapter, “Domesticating Dionysus,” show how ancient writers on theatre remembered its past as a seductive, terrifying, and increasingly remote ecstatic communion. They took their own theatre to be a shadow of this passionate origin, in a constitutive fantasy of a better, vanished theatre that reappears in accounts of performance from the seventeenth century onward. The second chapter, “The Fining of Phrynichus: Shaping Memory and Genre in Athens,” explores how under penalty tragedy was turned from the lived experience of Athenians to representing those of its Others, from opening one's own sufferings—and one's own misdeeds—to more insulated kinds of sympathy. The next three chapters—“Broken Shards and Buried Barbs: Ostracism and Weaponized Comedy,” “The Serene Face of Menander; or, ‘The Dipper Dipped,’” and “Unspeakable Histories: Terror, Spectacle, and Genocidal Memory on the Roman Stage”—trace ancient comedy from the vicious local politics of Aristophanes’ Old Comedy through Menander's reassuringly anonymous and anodyne New Comedy, then to Terence's Roman adaptations of Menander, where the painful edge that Menander conspicuously blunted flickers through muted representations of those—like Terence himself, an African enslaved and brought to Rome—conquered in Rome's genocidal expansion across the Mediterranean. Roman terror renders comedy's politics of survival and protest existential even as it muffles them.
The next three chapters—“Mapping Rome: Becoming Togati,” “Mapping Rome: Shitting on Romans,” and “Mapping Rome: Rules for Borrowing Memory”—show how the institutions of theatre, from scripts to buildings and performers, became tools to impress Roman identity on Rome's conquered and colonized territories, and how populations around the growing Empire both resisted and accommodated this “weaponization of theater” (133). “Savage Cuisine / The City of Always,” and “Antiquity's Last Supper” show how later writers on theatre, especially Pausanias and Athenaeus, imagined histories of theatre that regularized it and safely sealed it off from demands of the present, rendering the past as a collection of familiar quotations, better for nostalgia than engagement. The last chapter, “The Damnatio and the Gods: Theater and Resistance in the Pagan Holocaust,” looks at how theatre, which had been the cultural face of the Empire, was taken by Christianity as a representative of paganism and an opponent as the interests of Christianity and Empire converged. Both of these responses to performance—idealizing its force in its past, demonizing its present forms as weak or depraved—persist well into modernity. As one of the book's aims, Johnson claims “a more just allotment of memory” (122). Ruins does not ask for an account that could be decisive; it sees its histories too well. Instead it offers a different story of classical theatre's enduring, transforming powers, from ruin to ruin, strength to strength. This is not just a book for specialists, though its meticulous and startling detail will engage them as well. It is a book for scholars and practitioners whose work has felt the impress of classical theatre—which is to say, as Ruins shows, nearly all of us.
