As the book's title asserts, in Voice of America: A History Alan Heil sets out to provide an extensive and seemingly exhaustive account of the Voice of America's (VOA) often tumultuous sixty-plus-year history. Heil does precisely that, chronicling the early days from the VOA's birth to the present post-9/11 world where, he argues, the need for the VOA remains crucial. For the most part, Heil presents his historical treatment chronologically, recounting the VOA's development (technological as well as philosophical) and use in the various hot spots in the world since it first went on the air in 1942. For example, he talks of how “the Voice” (its affectionate nickname) reached out to the people of China during the Tiananmen Square events and how the great majority of the Chinese relied on VOA broadcasts to get a factual and full picture of what was going on. Heil also spends considerable time discussing the turbulent modern history of the Middle East and the VOA's efforts to report all sides of the story there. He honors the talent and integrity of news staff and reveals that many VOA reporters faced difficulties as journalists—often denied access granted other reporters or refused press accreditation by authorities of other countries.
This book tells the story of America's voice as seen through Heil's own eyes, which have more than thirty-five years of observations and experiences on which to rely. From 1962 until he retired in 1998, Heil worked for the VOA as a foreign correspondent, chief of news and current affairs, and deputy director of programs. For the years before he joined the VOA, Heil relies heavily on archives and interviews with former VOA staffers and government officials to describe its transformation from a small propaganda organ during World War II—it was closely linked to the Foreign Information Service and the Office of War Information, and many employees were “drafted” into service—to a respected radio broadcaster that reaches populations whose own state-run news organizations are reluctant to report news they may deem politically sensitive. Heil witnessed firsthand the VOA's further adaptations, as the Voice ultimately became a global multimedia giant encompassing radio, the Internet, and more than 1,500 affiliated broadcasters around the world.
Heil is also experienced and makes repeated references to the VOA's ongoing struggle to demand and defend its claim for journalistic independence, despite relying on public funding. Heil details the often acrimonious debate between various U.S. administrations and VOA directors about the necessity of maintaining objectivity and about the VOA's need to remain completely free of U.S. government influence if it is to be received with any credibility in foreign countries, the only recipients of the Voice's broadcasts. He presents many examples of government interference and censorship and notes that even when the VOA finally got its charter in 1960, which gave it the green light to be candid and objective, its independence was short lived. As soon as the United States was facing turbulence in a foreign land, censorship and control returned. For example, he writes that when the VOA was not reporting what the American government wanted during the first Gulf War, it was accused of being pro-Saddam, a claim that subsequent investigations proved false.
In another, more recent example, Heil talks of a VOA coup to interview the Taliban leader Mullah Muhammad Omar, an interview the station was planning to air with other material, including President Bush's address to Congress, to ensure that its coverage was balanced. However, the State Department stepped in and refused it permission to go ahead, claiming that a station funded with public money should not be providing a platform for terrorists. As on previous occasions during times of delicate (and acrimonious) U.S. global maneuvering, the VOA faced interference, which Heil critically questions, insisting that the VOA's role was to be a forum for all views. He writes of an unnamed reporter's exchange with State Department Spokesman Richard Boucher during a press conference at the height of the controversy (p. 414):
Question: What can you say to VOA listeners out there who now may have questions about whether the news that they're listening to is going to be impartial and present all sides of the story?
Boucher: I'm going to say: “You're going to get the news, as you always have, from VOA.”
Question: Unless the State Department objects to it.
Moreover, and according to the VOA news branch stylebook, the Voice is “… not in the business to amuse, entertain or simply inform our listeners. Nor are we in business because news is an end in itself. The United States is in the midst of a serious struggle for the mind of mankind and the only purpose of the News Branch as well as the entire Voice of America is to contribute toward winning that struggle” (p. 32). Heil never takes issue with this statement; he fails to examine it critically or to consider its implications particularly for those on the receiving end.
In one of the final chapters, the author refers to the VOA as “America's Voice.” However, for a significant portion of the world's population—and in precisely those regions where the VOA is targeted—there is a growing need to separate the voice of the American people from that of their government. Here again, Heil fails to recognize the actual, on the ground conditions of those countries where the Voice is being heard.
