No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 September 2004
Coal is nearly invisible to consumers today, but this short book reminds us of coal's enormous historical importance. Barbara Freese has written an entertaining survey that hammers home two themes. First, coal was critical to the industrial revolution and subsequent development of the modern economy. Second, people have persisted in using coal for centuries despite substantial direct health costs to users and external costs to their neighbors.
This is a trade book, not a scholarly volume. There are no tables or graphs, though there is a large bibliography. The author draws mostly on secondary sources, and little in this book will surprise an economic historian. But like a good speaker, Freese sprinkles her story with lively anecdotes, striking analogies, and curious facts that will grab the attention of the nonspecialist.
After an introductory chapter, the author devotes three chapters to the history of coal in England, where coal was first used extensively in the West. Chapter 2 documents the use of coal for heating as early as the 1100s, and the complaints that followed soon after about its soot and odor. Chapter 3 describes the dangers of early underground mining, including the flooding problem that motivated the development of the Newcomen and Watt steam engines in the 1700s, and surveys the subsequent interdependent growth of coal, iron, and steam power. Chapter 4 contrasts the two sides of England's coal-fired economy of the 1800s: on the one hand, growing cities, factories and railroads powered by coal; on the other hand declining urban health caused in large part by air pollution from burning coal. A natural conclusion to this part of the book would report England's twentieth-century experience with coal—the rise and fall of coal unions, the drastic changes in environmental regulation, and the declining use of coal at the end of the century—but the author skips that story and instead jumps across the Atlantic Ocean.
The next three chapters are devoted to America, where coal deposits are larger than in any other country. Chapter 5 describes how bituminous deposits were discovered in the mid-1700s in the Ohio valley and anthracite deposits were discovered later in eastern Pennsylvania, permitting the growth of a native iron industry and encouraging development of railroads and canals. Chapter 6 briefly surveys labor conflicts in coal, highlighting the Molly Maguires, and Presidents John Mitchell and John L. Lewis of the United Mine Workers. The chapter also reports early concerns about coal's impact on the health of city dwellers, especially in the bituminous-using Midwest. Chapter 7 jumps forward to efforts at pollution abatement in the late twentieth century, when coal use in America was largely confined to power plants. Although emissions of sulfur dioxide have been substantially reduced, in spite of steady increases in the amount of coal burned, scientific studies have showed remaining sulfur dioxide emissions to be more dangerous than originally suspected. Nitrous oxide, mercury, and carbon dioxide (the author's special interest) also remain problems in America.
Chapter 8 surveys the history of coal in China, where coal has been used as fuel longer than in any other country. China's production of coal, coke, and iron was much greater than Europe's at the time of Marco Polo, but China fell behind during Britain's industrial revolution. Coal output has grown rapidly again in post-Mao China, but pollution problems are severe by contemporary standards. The author draws some striking comparisons between China, America, and Britain. For example, in all three countries, initial successes in pollution abatement came from more efficient use of coal.
The final chapter outlines the author's view of the future of coal. At this point, the author's story takes an unexpected turn. Coal has absolutely no future, according to the author. Burning coal, however carefully and efficiently, must inevitably release carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas. Global warming must be stopped at all costs, the author feels, and carbon sequestration is impractical. Alternative fossil fuels such as petroleum and natural gas also release carbon dioxide, although in smaller amounts. So the only solution, concludes the author, is to switch completely to renewable energy sources such as solar power and wind power.
Economists trained to expect interior solutions to optimization problems will be surprised at this extreme conclusion, which moreover seems at odds with the two themes that pervade the rest of the book. Restated in economic language, those themes are first, that the benefits of burning coal were very large historically and second, that the benefits of coal were historically seen as worth those pollution costs. So why the complete reversal in the twenty-first century? The author's argument gets lost in the emotional “excitement” over new, decentralized energy technologies “closer to the Jeffersonian ideal” (pp. 245–46). Readers expecting a dispassionate analysis of optimal coal use in the face of global warming should skip this chapter and turn to the large economic literature on the topic.
Nevertheless, this well-written, accessible book will surely encourage greater appreciation for the significance of coal in a society where most people in their daily lives no longer see even a lump.