With Rebirth of a Nation, Jackson Lears presents an extremely intriguing yet ultimately frustrating interpretation of the pivotal Gilded Age and Progressive Era decades. It is Lears's stated goal to trace “the interplay between private desires and public policies” in order to see the private, moralistic origins of the reform undertakings of this period. Understanding this era in such a way, according to Lears, reveals that both a national rebirth and the international “impulse to conduct a world crusade began in the recesses of the Protestant soul” (4–5).
Lears begins his analysis by linking the era to “regenerative” Protestant evangelical movements of earlier periods in U.S. history, including the Civil War. “The pervasiveness of evangelical Protestantism in Gilded Age America made it the dominant, indeed the inescapable discourse of American public life” (10). For the Gilded Age, ambivalence about the emergent market culture of capitalism provoked a yearning to find a way to justify acquisitive desire with the personal control that would satisfy this Protestant soul. Social discontent produced by feelings of “loss of dignity and standing” in this new commercial society were attributed to “a lack of thrift and of a rigid commercial morality,” symptoms of “a widespread defect of character” (190). Outbreaks of “nervous invalidism,” a neurasthenia epidemic provoked by “the headlong race for success,” could only be solved through a “profound regeneration” of individuals and society as a whole (69).
The Gilded Age/Progressive Era, according to Lears's analysis, was the midpoint in a continuum of yearning for moral regeneration that dissipated after World War I, only to be revived in the Cold War and during the “war on terrorism” of the present day. Such waxing and waning of a regenerative spirit, he concludes, “still stalks our lives like an uninvited guest,” leaving in its wake enduring fantasies about saving the world, about the “revitalizing power of combat,” and of pursuing “the cult of manly toughness in foreign policy” (11). Anyone who studies U.S. history from 100 or more years ago will recognize the force that such fantasies have had on that history and in constructing a particular vision that has been preached by some Americans of the place of the United States in the world. This larger analytical framework makes the book a seductive pleasure to read. In most everything that Lears examines, the past connects to the present.
Looking for the evidence of private desires does limit the types of sources Lears can use to make his points. He draws his primary materials largely from the writings, speeches, and pronouncements of major literary figures, philosophers, political actors, and reformers. All the recognizable persons of note appear: Henry and William James, Henry Adams, George Santayana, E. L. Godkin, Henry Grady, Frank Norris, and Jane Addams, among others, are quoted extensively for their views on the need to revitalize American society. Lears has also scrupulously combed magazines such as Harper's, Scribner's Monthly, The Atlantic Monthly, and The Nation for his evidence. Even the feminist icon Charlotte Perkins Gilman is viewed as afflicted with the longings of the Protestant soul. Assessed as suffering periodically from “nerve bankruptcy” owing to a “chilly disciplinarian” mother, she spent her life searching for self-discipline. According to Lears, Gilman “preserved Protestant habits of mind while she groped for new language to express them. Tapping into a divine ‘reservoir’ of ‘limitless power,’ she aimed to harness that force to the regenerative regime of work” (242).
Lears is a brilliant writer and original thinker. This combination results in the book's overall fascinating aspects. There is some truth in every facet of his interpretation of this era. Nevertheless, contrary to Lears's claim, this element of truth cannot be sustained as “the” interpretation. There was surely an underlying Protestant ethic that recoiled from the materialistic and acquisitive lack of control produced by capitalism. On the other hand, so many of Lears's examples expose an underlying fear of sexuality that has never been reserved to Protestantism, nor to the United States. There is the “rational capitalist” John D. Rockefeller's determination to manage his “erotic longings for money” (61). There are the writings of men such as Frank Norris in which “the emerging worship of force” embodied in the cult of “manly revitalization” is used to justify racial superiority (109). The search for “real life” through “religion of experience” rather than the “blandness of Protestant liberalism” is viewed as intersecting directly with “male anxiety” about “emasculating domesticity” (232–33). Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness with its “striking Congo woman” as the protagonist's “dominatrix and queen” is proffered as the example to expose the “sexually charged ambivalence at the heart of the culture of empire” (290). Beyond the fact that Conrad is not American, there is the problem that nowhere in this book does Lears confront the possibility that fears about masculinity were provoked by women's increasingly public presence and determination to have an official voice in democratic government. Moreover, it was not just white women making these demands but also black Protestant women who carefully linked social regeneration, not to self-control or the market, but to gender equality.Footnote 1
Finally the word “rebirth” suggests the renaissance of an older ideal, as was the case for the “rebirth” of a tradition of literature in Europe of the fourteenth and fifteenth century. Jane Addams's vision of a new society that cared about all of its people cannot be directly equated with Theodore Roosevelt wish to revive a more “manly” culture of combat, for example. Roosevelt's “military tent” was a far cry from Addams's cry for peace and bread. Furthermore, in Benedict Anderson's concept of the nation as an “imagined community,” a great many Americans were involved across the Gilded Age and Progressive Era in imaging what that community might be, and they by no means agreed with the Protestant soul, not the least because they were not Protestant.
Such frustrations aside, Rebirth of a Nation, is definitely worth reading and pondering. It does not function as the new synthesis of the time period but rather as an attempt to rethink how a “romantic nationalist creed” fulfilled the desires of those Americans possessed of a “changing Protestant mind and soul” (392).
