Inspired by Margaret Morganroth Gullette's appeal, “About age as a performance, we need to start the arguments” (quoted on 1), Valerie Lipscomb and Leni Marshall present a collection of essays that offers insightful analysis of the performance of age from an interdisciplinary perspective. Taking the position that age is both “performance and performative” (1), Lipscomb and Marshall propose a theoretical approach that considers traditional aspects of performance while taking into account that the performance of age is also affected by biology and society (2). Relying on Judith Butler's insights in Gender Trouble, the editors establish that, like gender, age is, in part, socially constructed; however, they also remind us that the physicality of aging (i.e., the constantly changing body) cannot be separated from issues of power and Western cultural anxiety about growing older. In their effort to move age studies from the margins to the mainstream, Lipscomb and Marshall seek to expand interest in the field by engaging scholars and encouraging further development of theories that consider the biological, sociocultural, political, and psychological components of age, aging, and ageism. This inclusive approach is credited to Gullette, who extended the limited scope of previous studies of “aging” to include “all aspects of the age spectrum” (3). To that end, the essays in this text consider the perception and performance of age from the perspectives of both sexes, and from childhood through middle to older age (3). Since performance and the performative are Lipscomb and Marshall's primary focus, their book's selected essays center on analyzing the performance arts—theatre, film, and dance—through an exploration both of the biological and social effects of performance, and of perceptions of the performance of age (2).
The book contains three parts presenting essays—on theatre scripts, film plots, and dance choreography—by an array of international scholars from humanities- and arts-oriented disciplines, as well as from the fields of sociology and psychology. The book's first part, which focuses on film, begins with Heather Addison's essay, “‘That Young, Fresher Woman’: Old Wives for New (1918) and Hollywood's Cult of Youth.” Addison provides a brief historical overview of the social constructs contributing to the performativity of age from the Victorian era to the early twentieth century, discussing the emergence of Hollywood together with its emphasis on youthfulness and how this “new standard of behavior, appearance and lifestyle” became one “to which the public was to aspire” (13). In Chapter 3, “Old Cops: Occupational Aging in a Film Genre,” Neal King examines ageist patterns in casting middle-aged and older male actors in Hollywood films, specifically “retirement-age cops” stories, to reveal that occupational limitations of aging are not limited to the female population (60).
Worth noting in Staging Age's first part is Chapter 2, E. Ann Kaplan's essay, “The Unconscious of Age: Performances in Psychoanalysis, Film, and Popular Culture.” Kaplan employs a psychoanalytical approach to explore the “unconscious of age” from Freud to Blum to King, and uses case studies to illustrate Pearl King's observation that “middle-aged and elderly patients may be functioning within a number of different time-scales,” and that these may include “a chronological time-scale, a psychological one, and a biological one, alongside the time-scale of unconscious processes, which are, paradoxically, timeless” (quoted in Kaplan, 31). Through an analysis of May, the middle-aged widow in Roger Mitchell's film The Mother, Kaplan outlines this unconscious process and the staging of age and sex. Although not explicit in all of the remaining essays, the idea that individuals are always consciously or unconsciously negotiating these “time-scales” substantiates both the performance and performative aspects of age for both the professional and nonprofessional. In other words, all of us are “staging age.”
In the book's second part, the editors shift their focus to the live theatre; the essays that appear here are centered on the performance and perception of the physiological components of performing age (i.e., voice, body image, and age markers) as well as its psychological components (i.e., power and desire). Of particular interest is Chapter 4, Janet Hill and Lipscomb's “Performing Female Age in Shakespeare's Plays,” an analysis of interviews with seasoned Shakespearean actors such as Sandra Voe, June Watson, Sorcha Cusack, Sinéad Cusack, and Harriet Walter, in which the authors explore both Shakespeare's stage treatment of female age as well as contemporary cultural perceptions of age. Lipscomb and Hill's analysis employs Karen Woodward's theory of a “mirror stage of old age,” which is patterned after Lacan's mirror stage, and which posits that aging adults reject and deny the “mirror image” of the aging body—the aging self—and focus instead on the “inner self” to avoid Western culture's marginalization of the elderly (104). In Chapter 5, “Mediating Childhood: How Child Spectators Interpret Actors' Bodies in Theatrical Media,” Jeanne Klein moves away from an analysis of depictions of age to examine instead the reception by child spectators of these depictions. In Chapter 6, Ruth Pe Palileo delves into vocal aging studies with a discussion of the physiological aspects of voice production, and the perception of the “aged voice,” through her examination of Beckett's use of “vocal restraints” (129); and in Chapter 7, “Molière's Miser, Old Age, and Potency,” Allen Wood applies a new-historicist approach to examine issues of age and power through an analysis of Molière's Harpagon.
The book's final part, which considers dance, perhaps has the most to offer on the question of the negotiation of the biological, psychological, and cultural aspects of performing age. Essays by Jessica Berson (Chapter 8, “Old Dog, New Tricks: Intergenerational Dance”), Barbara Dickinson (Chapter 9, “Age and the Dance Artist”), and Wendy Oliver (Chapter 10, “Still Tapping after All These Years: Age and Respect in Tap Dance”) examine perceptions of intergenerational dance to illuminate a wide range of concerns about performances by older adults. These essays also investigate and analyze the performances of older, seasoned dancers who grapple with, and must balance, a “separation from the younger self” which signals “the physical progress of age,” and the “gifts” they possess as performers, “which at [their] age go far beyond the achievement of movements performed in a technically proficient manner” (Dickinson, 197–9).
Staging Age is neither the first word nor a foundation text in the area of age studies; rather, it offers a selection of essays that provide a broad overview of the performance and performativity of age that will benefit scholars, researchers, educators, and performers interested in innovative theoretical approaches to, and analyses of, these subjects. The editors' introduction and the selected essays covering theatre, film, and dance provide significant discussions of foundational theories and texts that will both enable the emerging scholar to join the conversation as well as provoke the experienced scholar or critic. If there is a criticism to make of Staging Age, it is that it attempts too much in too little space, which at once serves Lipscomb and Marshall's intention—and hope—that the publication stimulate conversation in a nascent field of study.
