Muhammad's Heirs chronicles the rise of a Muslim scholarly class through the lens of its evolving use of writing as a medium for the preservation and transmission of knowledge in the first three centuries of Islamic history. Framed in large part as an intervention in the “sanguine/skeptical” debate over the utility of the Islamic literary tradition in reconstructing this period, the book seeks to provide secure boundaries within which this debate might take place by focusing closely on the available material evidence, consisting of no more than thirty manuscripts of authored works (arranged in a useful appendix), alongside much more numerous Qurʾan fragments, administrative papyri, coins, inscriptions, and architecture. Although the book as a whole hews closely to the material evidence, Brockopp does not advocate setting aside the literary sources altogether, and each of the book's five chapters also contains a handful of poignant anecdotes drawn from biographical sources in order to better illustrate the developments under discussion.
The argument of the book revolves around three interrelated transformations: 1) a social transformation in the role and status of individuals recognized as possessing authoritative knowledge regarding Islam; 2) a cultural and methodological transformation in the manner in which written texts were used as communicative mediums between scholars and students and among scholars themselves; and 3) a pedagogical and institutional transformation that enabled the stable transmission of systematic written works across time. The first transformation has to do with the transition from “proto-scholars,” defined as individual savants who taught in an informal manner, to scholars, whose authority and instruction were more inherently collaborative and who came to constitute one of the most influential classes in the early Muslim polity. The second transformation hinges on Brockopp's definition of a book (distinct from the protean Arabic term kitāb) as “a literary text produced in a single redactional effort passed on intact to later generations” (84). The best material evidence available does not allow us to securely identify such books until roughly the turn of the third/ninth century, since it does not preclude the possibilities of later pious forgery, notes compiled and edited by students, and/or an open text that continued to be under redaction for an unknown period. Beginning in the middle of the third/ninth century, the quantity and quality of material evidence for scholarship improves dramatically due to the third major transformation identified by Brockopp, namely the emergence of communities of scholars and students whose authority and pedagogical methods now centered around the production, study, and transmission of books. This last development is supported by an abundance of material evidence from the Kairouan manuscript collection, in which 23 of the 30 third/ninth-century manuscripts identified by Brockopp are preserved. Through the Kairouan collection, Brockopp offers a contemporaneously and meticulously documented glimpse of the scholarly activities of the city's mid-to-late-third/ninth century and early- fourth/tenth century Mālikī communities, which included authoring books, producing “critical editions,” and documenting their efforts in transmission and audition records that can be used to verify, correct, and augment the biographical sources. Brockopp shows that the significance of the Kairouan collection extends far beyond the immediate community that produced it in both time and space, since we can more or less reliably infer from it the veracity of authorial activities of scholars in late-second/eighth century Egypt, whose works are partially represented in the collection, as well as those of scholars from Spain, Iraq, and other parts of the early Muslim empire.
The fact that Brockopp's argument is woven so tightly around the material evidence makes for firm conclusions in many respects and also opens up possibilities for further exploration of the methodological and substantive implications of his work. At the methodological level, Brockopp points out that subsequent investigations of early Muslim scholarship will require more probing engagement with literary sources, but the question of how this might best be carried out remains unresolved. Brockopp is generally noncommittal regarding the historicity of the anecdotes he invokes, using them to illustrate themes that either concur with the material evidence or perhaps are so widely attested in the sources that they are likely to reflect broad historical trends. Beyond this, his discussion treads a fine line that leaves the reader uncertain as to whether anything more concrete may be gleaned from the literary sources. On the one hand, Brockopp expresses something short of a full endorsement of the results obtained by a scholar like Harald Motzki (20) and acknowledges that his own method in dating Islam's first identifiable book overlaps to some extent with isnād-cum-matn analysis (128–9). On the other hand, he does not directly engage the conclusions of isnād-cum-matn scholarship in his discussion of the use of writing in the late Umayyad period, where its proponents believe they have found firm historical grounding but where the material evidence that constitutes the backbone of his method is lacking. This does not mean, however, that Brockopp is altogether averse to historical reconstruction primarily on the basis of literary sources, since he relates the personal backgrounds and activities of several of Muḥammad's companions with some degree of confidence (45–7).
Thus, while Brockopp succeeds to a large extent in transcending the sanguine/skeptical divide at the methodological level through his careful use of the material evidence, for subsequent research on any number of substantive historical questions that can only be addressed using the literary sources, the devil still waits in the details. Among the questions more or less directly implicated by Brockopp's account are the following: single authored epistles and khabar reports dated on the basis of internal evidence, the (native) controversy over the use of written materials in the transmission of hadith, the lively milieus and fractious debates that have been depicted in works like van Ess's Theologie und Gesellschaft, and especially the socio-political and ideological factors that enabled the ʿulama to become one of the most influential classes in Muslim societies. In providing a rigorously documented, carefully reasoned account of the evolving role of writing and textual production as it correlated with the broader phenomenon of the rise of Muslim scholarship, Muhammad's Heirs will serve as an important historiographical foothold at the nexus of these and a variety of other core issues in the development of early Islam.
