No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 August 2004
The Islamist movement in Turkey has gained more global relevance since a center-rightist offshoot of the conventional Islamist Milli Görüs came to power in 2002 and expressed willingness to cooperate with the United States for the occupation of Iraq. Living Islam is a timely contribution at a conjuncture when both scholars and the English-speaking public want to know more about the ideological, social, and political background of the movement. Ayşe Saktanber introduces the book with a relevant conceptual intervention in the field of Islamist studies. Arguing that the now fashionable “cultural Islam versus political Islam” dichotomy is not very useful, she posits “living Islam,” which she defines as the strategy by which the cultural is channeled into the political, as an alternative concept. Saktanber contends that differentiating between “the political” and “the cultural” by attributing danger to the former and naïveté to the latter ultimately leads to “forgetting” the significance of Islam and Islamization in recent Turkish history.
The Islamist movement in Turkey has gained more global relevance since a center-rightist offshoot of the conventional Islamist Milli Görüs came to power in 2002 and expressed willingness to cooperate with the United States for the occupation of Iraq. Living Islam is a timely contribution at a conjuncture when both scholars and the English-speaking public want to know more about the ideological, social, and political background of the movement. Ayşe Saktanber introduces the book with a relevant conceptual intervention in the field of Islamist studies. Arguing that the now fashionable “cultural Islam versus political Islam” dichotomy is not very useful, she posits “living Islam,” which she defines as the strategy by which the cultural is channeled into the political, as an alternative concept. Saktanber contends that differentiating between “the political” and “the cultural” by attributing danger to the former and naïveté to the latter ultimately leads to “forgetting” the significance of Islam and Islamization in recent Turkish history.
In conjunction with this intervention, the main argument of the book is that Islamism is a type of “life politics” that produces an alternative intelligentsia and an alternative middle-class countering those of the secularist Turkish republic, thereby inducing a moral transformation and a thorough change in everyday life. According to the author, these changes in the meaning of the “political” have coincided with the blurring of the boundaries between “the public” and “the private” in the new global society to render the role of women exceptionally central. Consequently, religious Muslim women have gained power to construct themselves and the movement, thus belying their Orientalist perception as passive and obedient recipients. Living Islam is in part a study of the implications of this new configuration of gender relations within the Islamist movement.
Saktanber extends these arguments through the ethnographic analysis of a residential complex in Ankara (the capital city of Turkey) built and exclusively inhabited by Islamists. The place is more particularly dominated by followers of the Milli Görüs (the main Islamist current in Turkey, represented by the banned Welfare and Virtue parties), some of whom are members of two separate communities of the Nakshbendi religious order. The author's observations of the site cover the time frame from 1989 to 1993. Her story of entering the field (chap. 2) and building trust among the inhabitants is both engaging and informative. Saktanber has tactfully interwoven analysis and narrative in this chapter. While relating the obstacles and restrictions she has faced, she also gives a complicated analysis of the meaning of “seclusion” for this community. Since this story also gives an idea about Turkish culture, the place of Islamists in Turkey, and their political rationale for seclusion in an entertaining way, it could serve as introductory reading for the uninitiated who would like to have some sense of the Islamist experience in Turkey.
Chapters 5 and 6 constitute the core of this book, where Saktanber develops her analysis of the religious residential complex. In Chapter 5, the author argues that Islamists in Turkey express what Richard Sennett calls “ressentiment” in face of secular domination: they protest against the perceived impersonality and lack of warmth of the urban, where they feel themselves to be unjustly excluded. As Sennett points out, the politics of ressentiment does not aim at transforming inegalitarian structures; it is based on the hope that the excluded and dominated party will somehow replace the old elite and come to occupy a central role. Communal ties of the Nakshbendi order provide the residents of the complex with the warmth and intimacy they feel are lacking in modern Turkey. The model of the prophet and the golden age of Islam supply them in turn with the moral order that they imagine will replace the secular and immoral order of the country.
In Chapter 6, the author analyzes how the Muslim residents attempt to build an Islamic way of life in face of modern pressures. Their hesitance regarding sending their daughters to school, watching television, and participating in the social life of non–Muslim environments all exemplify the difficulties of “living Islam” in a society where the secular way of life is accepted as normalcy. This chapter gives a good idea about popular Turkish customs and how religious customs differ from them, while the footnotes make the analyses much richer and fill in some gaps for the less well initiated reader.
The insights developed in this book are very valuable for both those trying to develop a preliminary understanding of Turkish society and those interested in the functioning of religious activism in contemporary Turkey at a deeper level. However, the sequencing of the arguments does not always lead to a well-structured narrative: the chapters do not flow logically, and there is often a disconnect between parts of the book. The most problematic parts are the extended literature reviews, which are thorough and satisfactory but not always well integrated with the theme of the book. Although there are exceptions to this (pp. 30–36, 48–52), the author often does not go beyond paraphrasing what other scholars have said on a particular issue (pp. 3–6, 44–48), without linking these to her main argument or to her analyses.
Even though the book makes important conceptual revisions in a field where many commonplaces are repeated without reflection, it cannot escape reproducing one dimension of the new scholarly common sense regarding the Islamist movement in Turkey. For the past fifteen years, scholars have over-reacted to the dominant Kemalist paradigm, which pictured proponents of Islamism as poor, rural, and thus ignorant, and have alternatively portrayed them as middle class, upwardly mobile, and “conscious.” Although this reaction was partially justified, it missed the creative (not simply “rural” and “ignorant”) input of non–middle-class sectors in the movement. Living Islam reproduces this new academic common sense to the extent that it treats Islamism as a new “middle-class ethos,” without reflecting in-depth on the fact that this study is conducted within the confines of a place that is exclusively and intentionally middle class.
The nature of the field site also restricts the ethnographer's capacity to observe differences within Islamism and how these are negotiated. (The only exception to this consists of a few brief notes about the differences between the members of religious orders and those who do not subscribe to a particular shaykh.) Moreover, observations of this residential complex inhabited exclusively by religious people do not provide any firsthand information about how Islamists interact with non–Islamists (secularists as well as non–Islamist religious people). This prevents the author from analyzing Islamism in the midst of a variety of interactions. As a result, the position of Islamists in the wider society and their relations to their “others” are filtered through the narratives of the Islamists themselves. Hence, what we end up with is a description and analysis of how Islamists would like to see themselves (“conscious,” “moral,” and “modest”) instead of a rich depiction situating the voices of Islamists amid the “noise” of Turkish social and political life.
Despite these restrictions, Living Islam is a thorough analysis of the quotidian of middle-class Islamism in Turkey. It will be an important source for students, scholars, and the interested public who want to explore the middle-class dimension of Turkish Islamism.