Ian Tyrrell's Reforming the World is a model of transnational scholarship that sheds new light on how moral reformers and their organizations operated as transnational agents from the 1870s to the 1920s. It argues that missionaries and moral reform groups “often thought of their work as analogous to empire—but a kind of Christian moral empire that rose above ‘nation’”(3). Working toward God's “moral empire” seemed nobler than the crass aims of the era's imperialists, bent as they were on “gold or glory.”
As Tyrrell notes, “missionary history has not been a fashionable subject” (34). This presents Tyrrell with an opening. He argues that new American understandings of the world emerged directly out of the mission experience. Reforming the World is composed of a series of short chapters arranged in five sections; moving roughly chronologically, they present a compelling account of individual Americans who formed the filaments of overlapping transnational networks of moral reform.
The first section explores networks of empire, looking at both what Tyrrell terms “webs of communication” and the lives and experiences essential to the articulation and operation of those webs (13). The account of the sisters Mary and Margaret Leitch is particularly fascinating. Evangelical from childhood and deeply committed to radical abolitionism, they left a voluminous paper trail in the archives of the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions (28). The “Misses Leitch” touched on all the major causes of the day: famine relief, literacy, medical aid, prohibition, and anti-opium activism; and they met virtually all the other major figures and organizations, including YMCA leader and later Nobel Peace Prize recipient John Mott. Their narrative mirrors the shifting dynamics of the moral reform empire of the age.
The second section examines the origins of American empire, showing how humanitarianism “became a central principle of evangelical reformers' work through famine and refugee relief” (98). Tyrrell demonstrates that these efforts took hold earlier than generally believed; by the late 1890s there was a dynamic humanitarian mission field led by groups such as the Women's Christian Temperance Union.
According to Tyrrell, a crucial moment in the development of the moral reform ethos was the establishment of a more formal American empire in the wake of the Spanish-American-Cuban-Filipino War. Moral reformers around the world grappled with the damage done by the American colonial project, particularly in the Philippines but also beyond.
Moral reform movements had striking commonalities. Leaders and foot solders alike hoped “to create a moral state and a moral empire” (124). Yet mission workers were conflicted about their relationship to the state even as they adopted the language of “empire.” In light of the rampant paternalism and racism in their ranks, many reformers sought purity beyond the state. Some, such as the Leitches and Mott (in part), rejected the U.S.'s military force, racial hierarchies, and crony capitalist practices, though they benefitted from state connections. Still others, especially by the 1910s, confronted their own biases and transformed into radical advocates of racial liberal internationalism, pushing for the withdrawal of U.S. forces from the Caribbean, Philippines, and elsewhere.
The third part delves into these challenges to American colonial projects and efforts to reform or protest expansionism. Here we encounter progressive moral reforms designed to ameliorate colonialism. Tyrrell adeptly elucidates Ida Wells's activism along these lines in chapter 8. She mounted a radical protest to “puncture the sometimes self-congratulatory tone of ‘humanitarianism’” and thereby aimed to “turn the task of social reform inward toward changing the budding American empire at its source” (166).
The fourth section turns to the First World War era, what Tyrrell dryly terms the “Wilsonian World Order,” and the worldwide pursuit of temperance (189). These final chapters detail new directions in seeking morality in governance, such as anticorruption activities and peace activism. Reforming the World reveals an epochal shift in the era from roughly 1913 to 1921, which amounted to a kind “of merger of morality and American statecraft” presided over by Wilson and approved of by most missionaries, and a zealous effort in the post-WWII era of disillusionment to regenerate through “making a dry world” (201, 209).
All of this had religious significance. The period's high-profile split between liberals and fundamentalists created a theological chasm in moral reform movements. Institutionally a new challenge arose with the ascent of competing organizations such as Rotary International and the Rockefeller Foundation, which usurped power, prestige, and purpose at a critical moment for mission work in the postwar world. But it was “prohibition's demise” that “was a critical blow to the Christian moral reform enterprise that had flourished for more than thirty years because the dry crusade had become the flagship evangelical reform” (227).
The new internationalism of the post-World War I years was still dominated by nation–states and international agents and actors, rather than the sorts of transnational networks the moral reformers had built for decades. A process of statist cooptation that had been ongoing since the 1890s became ever more visible by the 1920s. As Tyrell eloquently puts it, a “subtle dialectic took place between American power and the extension of the nation's moral influence” (244). The challenge of moving beyond national identification, that transnational mission of moral reform empire, now seemed impossible for many missionaries and reformers.
By the 1920s, American moral reformers had “stamped their own imprint upon conceptions of the nation's global role” (3). Ian Tyrell's Reforming the World is a path-breaking exploration of transnational moral reform networks and their relationship to American empire and internationalism. By focusing on individuals and groups as they built up transnational networks, Tyrrell reveals the intricate balancing act they had to play between private “voluntary sector” initiatives and state power to achieve their objectives. These interconnections and this delicate balancing were what ultimately generated the networks that constituted American imperialism. We continue to live with that legacy. This book deserves a wide readership.
