This volume brings together twelve essays by scholars from Europe, Asia and the United States that explore the concept of gentility in Chinese culture from roughly 1500 to the present. Here gentility is broadly defined as “the perceptions, social aspirations and cultural ideals that the image of the gentleman or gentlewoman evokes” (p. xv). In their introduction to the volume, editors Daria Berg and Chloë Starr trace the concept of gentility from the early Confucian idea of the junzi (gentleman), the cultivated and civilized Confucian scholar-official, as well as from the equally important Daoist notion of the recluse, a figure who retreats from the crass and cutthroat competition of social and political life to the private cultivation of the self through artistic pursuits. The essays are grouped under three general topics: 1) “Event,” focused on particular occasions for the display of gentility; 2) “Reflection,” centered more on definitions of gentility having to do with correct or moral behavior; and 3) “Transmission,” which treats the cultivation of gentility precisely through writings about genteel events and artifacts.
Ellen Widmer begins the volume with a perceptive comparison of three pieces of early twentieth-century literature: a 1903 travelogue by a diplomat's wife, Shan Shili 單士釐; a 1904 novel by the woman writer Wang Miaoru 王妙如; and a 1907 novel aimed at women (and men) by the male writer, Siqi Zhai 思綺齋. All of these works reflect the themes of new horizons for women at the turn of the twentieth century, particularly in terms of traveling, living and studying abroad. Widmer underlines the transitional nature of these writings, which show not only new and broader horizons for elite women but also considerable anxiety and ambiguity over such issues as courtship and the freedom of travel and of marriage for women.
Building on the work of Craig Clunas, Timothy Brook and others, Alison Hardie demonstrates the importance of landscape gardens as sites for the expression of female gentility in the late Ming era when elite gatherings there served to demonstrate and thereby enhance a family's status. In addition to women's participation in social gatherings in gardens, elite women also cultivated silkworms and grew fruits and vegetables in gardens. In this way, elite female gentility embodied such virtues as industriousness and frugality as well as aesthetic refinement. Elite courtesans were also important participants in the garden craze of the late Ming, and a few courtesans actually owned gardens “as a demonstration of cultural capital and as a repository of actual capital” (p. 55).
“The Literature and Art Tea Talk Meeting” was a literary salon that met on Sundays in Shanghai for a few years during the 1930s. Michel Hockx documents the organizers' interest in “sophisticated entertainment”, and the combination of traditional Chinese elite models along with the European, particularly French, salon as inspiration for this weekly networking of urban artists and intellectuals. While women were included in these gatherings, Hockx notes, men were the main sponsors and the main participants. The men saw themselves as chivalrous defenders of women's right to socialize in public with men, but they were primarily advertising gentility as a sign of their own cosmopolitan status, and as a commodity which they could market, sell, and thereby spread to other areas of urban China.
Daria Berg analyzes the Banana Garden women's poetry club (Jiaoyuan Shishe 蕉園詩社) of seventeenth-century Hangzhou. Berg highlights the open and public nature of the Banana Garden club, and argues that it gave its elite women participants “public recognition, fame and immortality, without diminishing their veneer of gentility” (p. 89). She emphasizes both the public influence of this poetry club in the seventeenth century, as well as the disappearance of such clubs in the eighteenth century, caused in part by state-sponsored Neo-Confucianism and the Chinese literati fascination with the solitary tragic heroine of talent, beauty and fatal frailty.
Supplementing her previous work on mothers and daughters, Ping-chen Hsiung contributes an impressive essay on gentility as seen in mother–daughter ties in the Ming and Qing. Hsiung examines narratives by and/or about women as mothers and daughters, and narratives by men about their own mothers and sisters. She documents in particular the close relationship between the famous courtesan Liu Rushi 柳如是 and her daughter, as well as the relationship between the wife and daughter of Zeng Guofan 曾國藩, the famous statesman of the nineteenth century. While noting that mother–daughter conflicts too are easily found, especially in legal records, Hsiung sees in elite women's writings most often the performance of a gentility that emphasized the transmission of literary and poetic skill from mothers to daughters, and the close emotional bonds between mothers and daughters.
Kenneth Hammond emphasizes the moral aspect of gentility in analyzing the case of Yang Jisheng 楊繼盛 (1516–1555), the Ming official who twice risked his life by publicly criticizing the powerful Prime Minister Yan Song 嚴嵩. After he was sentenced to death, his wife Ms. Zhang, with the assistance of the famous scholar-official Wang Shizhen 王世貞, memorialized the throne requesting to be executed in place of her husband. Her petition was denied and Yang executed. There are conflicting accounts as to whether Ms. Zhang then herself committed suicide. In any case, Wang Shizhen later successfully petitioned for the exoneration of Yang Jisheng, and a play on the evil Yan Song was written portraying Ms. Zhang's dramatic suicide. This is a form of gentility far removed from questions of aesthetic taste and life style.
Sarah Dauncey examines writings and paintings on women's fashion in the late Ming, and reveals how complicated the quest for gentility could become when there arose conflicting definitions of gentility and the status it was accorded. As some gentry became impoverished in the competitive society of the mid-Ming, many merchants became prosperous enough to support the kind of genteel lifestyle formerly confined to the gentry. In response, some long-gentrified authors attempted to redefine true gentility as modest and simple attire, even at weddings and funerals, those occasions that always tempted families to indulge in conspicuous displays of consumption. Given these cross-currents of social, economic and cultural change, one person's gentility was another's vulgarity – or perhaps nothing more than symbolic compensation for the faded glory of a once-proud elite.
The malleable and protean quality of the concept of gentility is also seen in Chloë Starr's essay on courtesans in late nineteenth-century fiction. Much of Starr's analysis centers on the gritty realistic 1892 novel, Haishang hua liezhuan 海上花列傳 by Han Bangqing 韓邦慶, who portrays mainly “the demise of gentility” in late Qing society. There remains in Han's depiction a veneer of gentility, but the reality is that even the pretense of elegance has mostly disappeared. His protagonists are often reduced to lowly prostitutes for sale, yet he portrays a few courtesans who, against all odds, manage to preserve their own sense of self-worth and dignified gentility.
Yasushi Oki expertly analyzes textbooks on aesthetic life in the late Ming. The very existence of such a genre of books shows the great social fluidity of late Ming society when a wide variety of people could aspire to the kinds of gentility once available only to the scholar-official elite. Oki pays particular attention to Chen Jiru 陳繼儒 (1558–1639), who styled himself as a hermit while making a living publishing guidebooks for the uninitiated on the aesthetic lifestyle of the literati.
Ann Gerritsen discusses two nineteenth-century scholars, Chen Wenshu 陳文述 and Ye Naiqin 葉乃溱, who each worked to memorialize and publicize the short tragic life and moving poetry of the late Ming girl-poet Ye Xiaoluan 葉小鸞 (1616–1632). Gerritsen notes the Ming loyalist implications of this fascination with late Ming tragedies, but sees in the cult of Ye Xiaoluan a deeper quest for a male self-identity in which one's connoisseurship of the talented and tragic female poet could help establish a man's reputation as a genteel, sensitive and cultured literatus.
The 1930s woman's magazine, Linglong 玲瓏 (Elegance), was one of the most outspoken feminist periodicals of the early twentieth century. Barbara Mittler explores the contradictions and tensions in this magazine as seen in its essays, fiction, cartoons and advertisements. Here was a periodical with an edge, actively promoting what Mittler calls “misandria: a distaste for men” (p. 209). With humor, irony and sarcasm, Linglong promotes a new kind of gentility for women. They may still be elegant and sophisticated in their cultural tastes, but at least in the pages of Linglong, they are now independent of men, and they see through the pretenses and hypocrisies of earlier forms of gentility.
The final essay by Jeesoon Hong explores the relationship between the writer Ling Shuhua 凌叔華 (1900–1990) and the Bloomsbury Circle, particularly Julian Bell and Virginia Woolf. Hong illustrates the difficulties of maintaining traditional gentry-inspired notions of gentility in an age of imperialism, commercialism and social revolution.
The most striking lesson of this book is how it illuminates social and cultural changes and continuities over the last half a millennium. As seen in the above discussion, gentility is a very malleable concept that could at times be used in contradictory ways by different sectors of society. In that sense it illuminates precisely the ways that different and competing groups of people tried to position themselves as advantageously as possible in times of rapid change. It is no coincidence that, as Yasushi Oki observes, the Song period witnessed the first books on gardens and the scholar's tools of inkstone, brush, ink and paper, for that was when status became tied primarily to examination success. In this regard, it is also instructive that so many of these essays deal with the late Ming period, and with the very late Qing and early Republican eras, for these were precisely the times of most rapid social and intellectual change. Those changes provoked the status anxieties that stimulated such fascination, even obsession, with gentility and the status it was accorded.
The notion of gentility might not take us “beyond gender and class” as the title of the volume promises, but it certainly elucidates the dynamics of class and gender in the Ming, Qing and Republican eras. By my count, nine of the twelve essays here deal with gender issues. These essays shed light on the ways women were embedded in the class structure and status competition of Chinese society. It is interesting, in this regard, that the status of women in elite society (even as courtesans) seemed higher in some ways in the late Ming and early Qing than in the late Qing or Republican eras. Ironically, the Banana Garden poets of the seventeenth century seem more autonomous and appreciated than the women participants in the Shanghai salon of the 1930s, though as Ellen Widmer's essay shows, elite women's horizons expanded substantially around the turn of the twentieth century. Dynastic decline and Western power threatened the Chinese elite and led the most progressive Chinese males to see Chinese women as symbols of their culture's weakness. So when they called for greater gender equality (or greater social equality between classes), their real concern was not gender or social equality but national wealth and power. Elite women remained subordinate to the interests of their own class or of the “nation”.
Taken together, these essays show there was no irrevocable break with the Confucian past in the Republican era, even among those who claimed to be the most modern and anti-Confucian. Rather, through the May Fourth Movement and beyond, prior patterns of class and gender relations found continued expression in the assertion of gentility as a powerful status marker. This welcome volume provides trenchant commentaries on the evolution of Chinese self-perceptions in elite and middle-class circles over the past half a millennium. The essays collected here make valuable contributions to the study of Chinese literature, Chinese society and Chinese gender relations in the early modern and modern eras.
