This book provides an overview of goddesses known as Yoginis within scholarship about Ancient India. The author, Anamika Roy, traces the origin, history, sculpture and architectural representation of Yoginis based on pre-modern Tantric and Nātha texts. She, however, separates Yoginis from other contemporary Hindu goddesses, such as Matrikās. While Roy accepts that Yoginis and Matrikās are mentioned together in various texts (p. xxii), she continues to treat Yoginis as epistemically separate. She argues (Chapter 4) that Yoginis are accorded primacy as individual goddesses in Tantric literature and are only linked to Matrikās in sculptures (p. 75). She does not, however, explain why she valorises Tantric text over sculptural evidence. Neither does she explain why she does not accord primacy to other texts that treat Yoginis and Matrikās together.
The book, consisting of ten chapters, is divided into four parts, in which Roy attempts to address concerns about the Yogini's social identity. However, social identity for Roy is based within Hindu anthropological imagination that links goddesses with fertility, power and sexuality. This link between ancient history and anthropology produces Yoginis within binaries of the rapacious and the docile, and locates them as static and orientalist. Roy asks potentially interesting questions, like why did Yoginis dance (Chapter 1), or whether their ferocious faces were masks (Chapter 2), or why they constituted ‘terrifying beauties’ (Chapter 9). But her answers are invariably reduced to the binaries she attempts to explain. She proceeds to describe Yoginis as ‘tribal’, their dancing movements as encoded within ritualistic magic, folkish secrecy and esotericism and finally as sexualised expression (p. 91). Even as Roy perceptively detects the dehumanised depiction of Yoginis to express orthodoxy, she describes their ‘weird’ faces (p. 44) to result from ‘tribal’ assimilation into Hinduism. She rationalises Yogini animal-like faces as masks and subsequently, identifies these masks as early evidence of female shamanism. She views these masks to play the social role of concealment that disguised female shamans and camouflaged their ritual life from their quotidian. Roy (Chapter 3) identifies Yoginis as giggling village goddesses, who synthesised with Shiva and Shakti cults (p. 67), even as she concedes that it is difficult to associate Yoginis and Tantra rituals with clearly demarcated Shaiva or Shakta cults. Roy also explores possible linkages between Yoginis and tree-spirits or Yakshinis, living on ‘Kaula trees’, in contradiction to White's (Reference White2003) definition of ‘Kaula’ constituting the clan worship of goddesses. Though Roy notes the silence surrounding royal inscriptions in Yogini temples, she reads this silence as an expression of royal secrecy about Yogini worship. But, if inscriptions in Yogini temples were absent due to their secret rituals, how were other Tantra rituals depicted in medieval temple sculpture? Roy explores (Chapter 5) linkages between Yoginis and goddess worship in the Himalayas, Shabar mantras, occult practices and possession, wherein her acculturation theory describes a downward flow, of ‘higher’ Tantric culture percolating to ‘lower’ traditions. Roy does share an obvious interest in anthropological allegory, as she unhesitatingly associates Yoginis with regional Devadasi traditions in Orissa, Assam, in Himalayan temples, and in Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka (Introduction, Chapters 3, 5 and 6).
Roy's exposition on Yoginis begins somewhat in the middle of a larger theory on goddess-origin. However, because of her insistence on Yogini's constituting an anthropological community: a biologically-associated caste, clan group or tribe, Roy loses interest in understanding Yoginis as a political category produced by Tantric texts, as vehicles of medieval kingship. Instead, she remains preoccupied with their physical appearance as community-markers, that is based on a variety of colonial-racial proto-typing. She classifies Yoginis and their worshippers as ‘tribal’ based on physical features, which not only assumes the ethnicity of worshipping communities, based on Yogini's sculptural representation that is ‘othering’, but also produces orientalist assumptions about ‘tribal religion’, based on Yogini sculptures. Roy (Chapter 6) explains the origin and location of Yoginis within ‘tribal’ belts of central India and presents them as Shudra and lower-caste deities. She explains Yogini rituals as lower Shamanistic involvement with upper-caste Brahminical Hinduism that led to their gradual assimilation within ‘high’ religion that was recognised as Tantrism. Through this theory, she explains goddess worship among Scheduled Tribes and Dalits to reflect ancient Yogini worship. She proposes that kings built Yogini temples to please ‘aborigines’ and accommodate their deities within Brahminical Hinduism, and that their non-Sanskrit names justify more than their aggressive nature, belying aboriginal origin (p. 103). This view, apart from demonstrating a gross caste-bias, promotes a materialist framework (Dandekar Reference Dandekar2016). Roy's materialist analysis of reducing Yogini origins to state/social formation (Chapter 4 and 6) is functionalist. Such explanations of functionalism ‘retrieve’ the pre-modern based on prefigured anthropological categories. In Chapter 7, Roy discusses whether Yogini temples constitute a deviant architectural form. She identifies the circular and open-to-the-sky structure of the Yogini temple as unique and interprets this design as a meeting point between ancient folk traditions dating to the upper Palaeolithic period and the transformative energies represented by Hindu Tantric geometric forms. In Chapters 8 and 9, she explores the political patronage of Yogini temples, especially in the Kalachuri and Chandela period, along with the importance of Khajuraho and the importance of Yogini temples for war, fertility and kingship. Roy discusses many temple complexes and their sculptural representations, describing their emergence at the confluence of historical, regional, local and ‘tribal’ processes. Finally, Roy asks the gender question. She blends Yoginis with the history of marginalised women, who, according to Tantric texts, could be worshipped as or instead of goddesses. She asks whether Yoginis could be imagined as proto-feminists, important for motherhood, ancient feminine power and agricultural magic. A gradual picture emerges from Roy's book, which can be summarised as follows: Roy views Yoginis as fluid cults assimilated to Tantra from ‘tribal’ sub-stratums. Yoginis travel between Hindu Brahminical, local and regional forms, becoming actualised as village goddesses and as metaphors of social and sexualised ritual roles benefitting kingship, through bhakti (p. 219) and Tantra. Marginalised women from subaltern communities, associated with Yoginis and acculturated within Brahminism and political empire are empowered for Roy.
Roy's conjectures are contentious, as she fetishises goddesses, women and subaltern communities. She promulgates a view of women and subaltern empowerment, which is based on primitive and tribal ‘elevation’ through civilisational and assimilative contact. Roy's imagination of this religious and politically assimilative contact is colonialist, and caste-ist. Roy's data is, however, extensive. This book is important for its overview of primary data, its discussion of prevalent historical debates on goddesses, and its presentation of photographic and visual materials.
