In this well-researched monograph, the author seeks to extend recent revisionist studies that question conceptions of the ʿulamaʾ as reactionary relics irrelevant to the story of modernity in Muslim societies. Focusing on the ʿulamaʾ of al-Azhar during the late 19th and early 20th centuries, the author argues that the ʿulamaʾ faced “a relative rather than total crisis” in their engagement with modernization and the rise of the modern nation–state (p. 171). The difference between relative and total crisis lies in the fact that “subservience to state authority . . . [and] the loss of the monopoly over the judicial, educational, and intellectual realms did not mean marginalization” (p. 8). This lack of marginalization is driven by the fact that “they retained a considerable degree of moral influence in society” (p. 171). Hatina's “moral” is not a substitute for the private, however, as in his view the ʿulamaʾ maintained a considerable public and political presence well after Muhammad ʿAli's early 19th-century modernization reforms.
Hatina's research on the discourses and political activity of the ʿulamaʾ during the late 19th and early 20th centuries does much to advance this argument. The chapters on the ʿUrabi revolt, in particular, bring into clear view an ʿulamaʾ class that is integrally involved in the social and political fabric of Egyptian society. This does not mean, as Hatina is careful to stress, that the ʿulamaʾ were of one mind on how to deal with the tumultuous events of the period. Some chose to support ʿUrabi and the rebels, others sided with Khedive Tawfiq, and many simply abstained from direct involvement (pp. 56–59, 172). Furthermore, Hatina demonstrates that choosing sides for the ʿulamaʾ was not simply a matter of “political affiliations and power struggles” but was also intimately linked to different understandings of the legal implications of the duty to obey a Muslim ruler (p. 56).
Hatina takes his revisionist argument further, arguing that the “roots” of the much touted late 20th-century vitality of the ʿulamaʾ “go back to the second half of the nineteenth century and the early twentieth century” (p. xi). This formulation, however, seems to cap the roots of this vitality at the mid-19th century and suggests, in doing so, a discontinuity with the prior period. Although Hatina reasonably casts Muhammad ʿAli's modernization reforms as a key moment of change, it is not clear how the mid-19th century represents a discontinuity in terms of the ʿulamaʾ's sociopolitical activity.
Hatina himself highlights a number of poignant anecdotes in the first chapter that indicate an active and sociopolitically assertive ʿulamaʾ class in the late 18th century. For example, he narrates a fascinating 1794 incident in which a group of farmers from the Sharqiyya region presented grievances against tax exploitation to the Shaykh al-Azhar, ʿAbdullah al-Sharqawi. Using the authority of his position, al-Sharqawi assembled the ʿulamaʾ and proceeded to lead the residents and shopkeepers of the region in a series of boycotts and protests. Reflecting upon this and other incidents, Hatina remarks that the ʿulamaʾ often made mosques and madrasas “available as a starting point for demonstrations and protests” (p. 24). The fact that the ʿulamaʾ were politically involved during both the late 18th and the late 19th centuries does not necessarily mean that the articulation and practice of this involvement were the same. Yet, it does lead us to question the singling out of the mid-19th century as a foundational period for the ʿulamaʾ's modern sociopolitical activity.
Hatina does gesture at a point of discontinuity, however, in his brief discussion of al-Azhar and the 1919 revolt. He remarks that in contrast to the pivotal role played by the ʿulamaʾ in past political upheavals up to and including the ʿUrabi revolt, “the ʿulamaʾ no longer served as primary spokesmen in the events of the 1919 revolt” (p. 142). Instead, the Westernized elite occupied positions of political leadership, and mosques were replaced by colleges and factories as the focal points for assembly and protest. By the mid-20th century, this shift was so significant, according to Hatina, that the ʿulamaʾ had to keep “a low profile in domestic political affairs” and even employed “a tactic of damage control,” such as when Shaykh al-Azhar Mahmud Shaltut endorsed the Islamic credentials of Arab socialism in order to “curtail the drift of Nasserist policy towards sweeping secularism” (p. 154).
Here Hatina indicates that something had radically changed in the Egyptian ʿulamaʾ's political assertiveness. This shift seems to have occurred between the ʿUrabi revolt of 1882 and the 1919 revolution. Identifying this shift, if only obliquely, is a helpful contribution. But how or why this happened receives limited attention. If the ʿulamaʾ had successfully weathered the changes brought about by Muhammad ʿAli's modernization program, as Hatina argues, what changed in the post-ʿUrabian moment that led to their marginalization in the 1919 revolt?
Hatina provides glimpses of a late 19th-century narrative that held politics to be outside the jurisdiction of the ʿulamaʾ. As Khedive Tawfiq put it in his address to a group of ʿulamaʾ after his victorious return to Cairo in 1882, “You are men of letters and not politicians” (p. 73). Similarly, the interrogation of pro-ʿUrabi scholars after the British invasion proceeded on the basis that the ʿulamaʾ's “very presence in the political sphere . . . constituted an absolute deviation from their official duties as scholars” (p. 77). Analyzing how this narrative was deployed in a post-ʿUrabian era, while also contextualizing it within both the broader Islamic tradition and the specific history of Egypt, could have shed further light on the dynamics of the changing sociopolitical role of the ʿulamaʾ in Egyptian society during this period.
At times, the work's broader argument is also refracted through analytical binaries that flatten some of the complexities and nuances of the rich source base. For example, Hatina does a comparative reading of two fascinating travelogues of Egyptians traveling through turn of the century Levant. One is by Muhammad al-Qayati, a religious scholar, and the other is by ʿAbd al-Rahman Sami, an Egyptian merchant. Although Hatina's reading brings to light a number of fascinating details of the individual accounts, the analytical frame for their comparison is an undertheorized binary of tradition and modernity. This leads Hatina to conclude that al-Qayati's and Sami's narratives serve as stand-ins for, alternatively, the rejection and acceptance of modernity (p. 89).
Seen in its entirety, however, Hatina's work is a useful contribution to the study of ʿulamaʾ in the modern period, the evolving role of al-Azhar, and Egypt in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Its rich detail and extensive source base will be of interest to students and scholars alike, providing numerous avenues for further research and exploration.
