In After Khomeini, Saïd Amir Arjomand, a prolific writer and a leading sociologist in Middle East studies, presents a sophisticated analysis of Iranian politics and society from the death of the founder of the Islamic Republic, Ayatollah Khomeini, in 1989 to the present. In many ways, the author's recent work should be seen as a continuation of his earlier book, The Turban for the Crown (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1988), in which he argues that the 1979 Iranian revolution was a result of complex social transformations, including the expansion of educational institutions, urbanization, state centralization, and changes in the Shiʿi hierocracy. In that book, Arjomand also provides a historical-sociological account of the consolidation of the Shiʿi Islamist theocracy in the early postrevolution years. A tense battle occurred over the new political order's constitutional definition, and the clergy eventually gained the upper hand. Along with Ervand Abrahamian's Iran between Two Revolutions (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1982), The Turban for the Crown remains the definitive scholarly work on the 1979 revolution to this day.
In After Khomeini, Arjomand continues his 1988 argument, though now with an emphasis on the dynamics of constitutional politics that led to a new form of factionalism within the state apparatus over the past two decades. He argues that with the death of Khomeini, the Iranian revolutionary state continued to experience a struggle among the “children of revolution” despite the introduction of new amendments to the constitution in 1989, which were meant to serve as a routinization of charismatic authority but in effect enhanced the constitutional authority of the Mandate of the Jurist (vilāyat-i faqīh). The post-Khomeini tale of struggle between various factions reveals the importance of the interpretative and contentious ways through which the revolutionary state has undergone a series of legitimacy crises over domestic and international affairs. For the most part, as Arjomand correctly observes, postrevolutionary Iran continues to experience changes that entail unpredictable consequences. With the rise of the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) and their growing involvement in politics, the clericalist structure of the regime is radically changing, opening up new domains of elite struggle over Khomeini's revolutionary legacy. With the increasing fissure between the clerical and the military-security apparatus since the unrest associated with the 2009 presidential elections, the future of Iranian politics in many ways remains unpredictable.
After Khomeini consists of ten chapters, with a useful appendix that outlines two theoretical models of revolutions. In Chapter 1, Arjomand begins his study with a discussion of Khomeini's life and his politicotheological thought in terms of clergy–state relations since the Constitutional Revolution (1906–11), showing how the Islamic Republic's constitution experienced problems of legitimacy under his rule in the 1980s. The chapter's discussion of Khomeini's constitutional politics in the early years of the revolution is illuminating, as Arjomand recounts the struggle over the drafting of the constitution. The latter topic is one that he extensively covered in The Turban for the Crown, though this time he does so in light of developments since the constitutional amendments of 1989, which ultimately led to the post-2009 election conflict. Chapter 2, “Dual Leadership and Constitutional Developments after Khomeini,” expands on the notion of dual authority of clerics after the 1989 constitutional amendment and argues that the pro-Khomeini clerical domination faced major challenges from clerical figures such as Grand Ayatollah Husayn-Ali Montazeri, Hojjat al-Eslam Mohsen Kadivar, and Abdollah Nuri, who questioned the role of clerical involvement in state power. Chapter 3 traces the rise of the IRGC amid economic and technological developments under the Rafsanjani presidency in the 1990s. This chapter provides a detailed and clearly written account of factional politics that subsequently led to the emergence of struggles between reformists and conservatives in the late 1990s.
Chapter 4 discusses the rise of reformists as a sociocultural movement that, armed with a distinct Islamic ethos, articulated politics in terms of the discourse of civil society and democratic rule. The central contribution of the reformist movement, led by Islamic activists and thinkers who challenged the theocratic-populist ideology of the Islamic Republic, was the formation of new spaces of dissent. For those interested in the intellectual history of postrevolutionary Iran, the chapter provides a well-written account of the emergence of “new religious thinking.” Chapters 5 and 6 look at the waning of the reformist movement and its social and political consequences. Chapter 6 is particularly interesting because it analyzes various social transformations, particularly in education and urbanization, and brings to light the critical role of provincial politics, especially in local and parliamentary elections.
Chapter 7 shifts the attention to Iran's foreign policy. It looks at the country's transregional activities in the context of Iran–U.S. relations and argues that Washington has largely failed to engage with Tehran when it has shown signs of moderation, especially under Rafsanjani in the early 1990s and after the election of Khatami in 1997. Chapter 8 examines the rise of the “new political class” of hardliners, which was bolstered by the victory of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad in the 2005 elections. Arjomand provides an interesting analysis of the relationship between populism, revolutionary revivalism, and the military-security complex. The 2009 presidential elections and the Green Movement are also briefly discussed here. Chapter 9 turns to the supreme leader of the Islamic Republic, Ayatollah Khamenei, and shows how the growth of his extraconstitutional authority, especially since the 2009 elections, has injected instability into the Islamic Republic. In Chapter 10, “The Hardliners, Foreign Policy, and Nuclear Development,” Arjomand returns to Tehran's foreign policy and provides a broad history of the factional politics behind Iran's nuclear policy. This chapter should be particularly interesting for students of international relations because it discusses Tehran's nuclear program in close connection with the country's domestic politics and state power structure.
With an engaging overview of the ideological transformations and political changes since 1989, After Khomeini offers an accessible and yet sophisticated analysis of Iranian politics in its postrevolutionary reconstruction phase. The book constitutes a major contribution to the study of Shiʿi Islam and constitutional politics and is a well-informed addition to literature on the comparative sociology of revolutions. I recommend Arjomand's volume to all scholars and especially to students of the Middle East.
