Accounts of early Christian martyrs portray saints dying, with prayers for their enemies and Christ on their lips. Dietrich Bonhoeffer, on the other hand, was a would-be assassin. He planned his enemy's execution. Furthermore, Bonhoeffer's own death followed his arrest and imprisonment for aiding Jews crossing the border into Switzerland. His actions (as actions which could have been, and were, performed by many non-religious Germans) are thus only indirectly related, at best, to the early martyrs’ explicit confession of Christ. Yet, there is an almost nagging insistence amongst post-Shoah Christians to hold Bonhoeffer up as a model of Christian witness in the modern world. We want to think of him as a martyr – indeed, as the martyr par excellence. But, as the author of this sensitive account of Bonhoeffer's witness admits, ‘if Bonhoeffer is a martyr, he is not an easy one!’ (p. 11).
Craig Slane, who teaches theology at Simpson College in California, deftly moves across three areas of concern: a history and analysis of martyrdom, an attempt to read Bonhoeffer's life and death in continuity, and a (somewhat implicit) discussion of the contours of modern Christian commitment. Though Bonhoeffer offers a test case in the plasticity and continuing relevance of the concept of martyrdom, it is always with a view to modern Christians being informed by the life and death of Christ.
Part One treats the question of Bonhoeffer's martyrological qualifications against the backdrop of the unfolding meaning of martyrdom. Slane is clear that this is not an exercise in ideological deconstruction but rather an attempt to query and, ultimately, ground Bonhoeffer's status as martyr theologically. We are reminded that the New Testament uses the term with reference to witness per se, without any necessary connection to witness unto death (though such a connection is certainly present in germ form). Martyrdom crystallises into a witness involving suffering and death, by the time of Polycarp in the mid-second century, such that the martyr's death is seen as the final fulfilment of an imitation of Christ which began in baptism. Indeed, baptism and martyrdom are seen as life's bookends, sharing an internal logic in their mutual participation in Christ's own death. Slane writes an ‘alphabet of martyrdom’ which sees it as a ‘dialectical witness of life and death’, an ‘act of freedom’ and a ‘response to evil and the demonic’. Martyrdom is ‘a collision of kingdoms’ (p. 248). This is a classical alphabet which gets expanded by modern martyrs in a more clearly political solidarity with and intervention on behalf of others, even when this paradoxically involves the martyr's blood being ‘stained with guilt’ (p. 68). Slane is clear in his conclusion: Bonhoeffer's was a life lived under the rubric of this alphabet.
In Part Two, Slane proposes a hermeneutic of martyrdom in order to read rightly ‘the passageway between [Bonhoeffer's] belief and behavior’ (p. 119). The ascription of ‘martyr’ is a postmortem judgement which a community makes on a person's life and death. Here Slane offers a remarkably clear account of Heidegger's ‘Being-towards-death’ to underwrite the continuity of Bonhoeffer's identity throughout his life and death. His was an authentic life lived freely in light of the limits of death. Drawing on Rahner, Slane argues for Christian death as the consummation of a life's assimilation of Christ's death. Living is, quite simply, dying. Thus, for the theologian of discipleship, ‘martyrdom is the hidden telos of his theology and ethics’ (p. 156).
Part Three tests the hypothesis. Chapters on Christology and ethics demonstrate that Bonhoeffer understood Christ as one who is present for others, while his ethics was an ethics of formation to the likeness of Christ. Slane argues persuasively for the mingling of Bonhoeffer's theology and ethics as well as for their deathward comportment. The book's final two chapters examine Bonhoeffer's involvement in the underground seminary at Finkenwalde in terms of its continuity with his martyrdom. How does this excursus into a monastic ‘life together’ which looks, prima facie, to be a ‘pacifist detour’ fit into Slane's picture of Bonhoeffer? It turns out that the ritual life of Finkenwalde was a ‘training for martyrdom’ (p. 227), a sort of dry-run for the real thing lived in the daily rhythms of communal living. So Slane points to Bonhoeffer's institution of personal confession at Finkenwalde as an attempt to ‘elongate temporally the death died at baptism and weave it tangibly into the structure of daily life’ (p. 234).
Slane's voice, like Bonhoeffer's, is a continual call to discipleship. Even at his most technical, his almost visceral urgency commends our daily ‘practice of death’, in which life is lived as ‘a free movement into the cruciform impression left by Christ’ (p. 152). This call, coupled with its cost, issues in a life and death which points back to the one whose life and death has given the martyr's its shape. In his argument and illustration of this, Slane has given us a thoughtful portrait of Bonhoeffer which both witnesses to Christ and effectively calls its readers to be conformed to the crucified and risen One.
