Framing research is still in its early stages as a subfield of political communication. That fact is no better demonstrated than in the studies in this book on framing effects. This edited volume includes disparate research examining the origins of decisions regarding framing, as well as the impacts of framing on various audiences—policymakers, voters, and the public generally. It encompasses framing both directed at the mass public and intended for elites. These chapters offer case studies of framing effects in several contexts, including presidential communication, electoral campaigns, and general public policymaking. The contexts vary from framing related to support for a publicly funded casino, to framing the policy debate over intelligent design, to framing the estate (or death) tax. These studies include framing toward the mass public by various elites, including political parties, presidents, and interest groups, as well as framing directed toward elites. Moreover, they address not only the antecedents of frames but also the ways in which framing affects attitudinal change as well as cognitions in the direction of the frame.
Some of the chapters discuss the effects of frames on public attitudes toward a candidate or an issue, leading to public support or opposition. For example, Taylor Ansley and Patrick J. Sellers analyze the relationship between the availability of decentralized campaign tools and framing of public discussion about the campaign in newspapers and the political blogosphere. (These decentralized tools included Web features for supporters, such as how to donate money, host a house party, and promote the campaign through the blogosphere.) They concluded that decentralized campaign tools by one candidate led to greater discussion of issues supportive of the candidate in the public debate. In a nonelectoral setting, the debate over intelligent design (ID) has been characterized by attempts to frame the issue on several different value dimensions. The chapter written by Thomas E. Nelson, Dana E. Wittmer, and Allyson F Shortle addresses these value dimensions in frames in the public debate, discussing how both sides sought to frame values to shape public opinion. They found that certain frames used by proponents of ID were effective in changing public opinion.
Not all of the framing attempts are successes, however. For example, Jessica C. Gerrity's chapter on interest-group framing demonstrates how the National Abortion Rights Action League failed to blunt the pro-life community's frame of “partial-birth abortion.” Presidential and congressional issue framing, as studied by Michael W. Wagner, apparently failed to create party-identification change among voters.
Nor are changing frames necessarily the product of overt actions by specific individuals or groups. While some reveal a conscious decision to frame an issue, others suggest a collective change that emerged from a series of events. Frank R. Baumgartner, Suzanna Linn, and Amber E. Boydstun show the effects of framing of the issue of the death penalty on public policy. They demonstrate shifting themes in media coverage, from the morality and constitutionality of the death penalty to an “innocence” frame, that is, whether the justice system can function to avoid executing an innocent person. Their longitudinal analysis of New York Times coverage of the death penalty indicates that the change in frame occurred gradually, not suddenly. They do not attribute it to a specific cause, but rather to a societal change. They conclude that this frame shift has affected public opinion and, in turn, public policy. The implementation of the death penalty—the number of death sentences imposed—has seen a dramatic decline as this innocence frame has emerged in recent years.
Other research is directed at whether frames shape perceptions of mass audiences. The study by Brian F. Schaffner and Mary Layton Atkinson on the framing of the “death tax” illustrates how frames can affect perceptions of the content of an issue. The estate tax applies to a small percentage of Americans. However, by labeling the estate tax as a death tax, Republicans were able to reframe the debate as one affecting most Americans. Schaffner and Atkinson demonstrate how the death tax label became a mantra for Republicans and helped shape the debate over the repeal of the estate tax. In a survey experiment, they found that respondents' perceptions of the tax changed with the labeling of the tax. However, they also found that the credibility of the source of the frame matters. Partisan sources were more likely to be accepted as credible by their own partisans, and therefore the frame was more likely to be accepted as well.
I have some quibbles. The editors had two primary objectives. One was to increase linkages between those scholars who concentrate on elite-based framing and those who study mass-based frames. The other was to clarify framing as a concept. They succeeded in the former but not in the latter. They admit their failure candidly. Nevertheless, I wish they would have worked toward a more uniform definition of framing that would have helped unify the chapters further. The field is beset by conceptual messiness. Some of the individual chapter authors attempt to define framing, but no overarching definition is achieved, or even attempted. The volume's introduction could also have benefited from a more extensive review of the literature on framing and the major questions that have emerged in the field. Particularly for the novice in this literature, that context would have been useful. Also, since the role of the media is critical in framing, it was surprising that more of the chapters did not address that role. The tools of framing, particular the media, should have been accorded more treatment.
Overall, Schaffner and Sellers succeed in presenting a volume that is well focused in terms of its purpose: demonstrating the variety of applications of framing research and linking those various study emphases in one place. There is much that we still do not know about framing, but Winning with Words makes an important contribution by placing together in one volume a range of interesting framing studies and spurring further research.
