Given the scope of Iranian history, Gene Garthwaite took on no small task in drafting The Persians as the fifth volume of Blackwell's “Peoples of Asia Series.” Challenged to author a complete and concise origins to present history geared toward nonspecialists and general readers, Garthwaite has competently crafted a 2,500-year survey spanning the Achaemenian era through the present.
As a succinct survey, The Persians offers a straightforward, chronological, and nearly comprehensive presentation of rulers, dynasties, and major political developments, yet with precious little nuance and detail. Considering the mandate of the series and the vast historical terrain to cover, perhaps it is to be expected that the text at times reads like an extended encyclopedia entry, although Garthwaite's emphasis on political elites and the lack of a central unifying thesis contribute to this character. Whereas the book is successful as a general introduction to Iranian political history through the fall of the Safavids—constituting approximately two-thirds of the work—the limitations of such a brief overview become evident in the breakneck ninety-page treatment of the Qajar Era, the Pahlavi period, and the Islamic Republic.
Following an introductory chapter that offers essential background on Iranian geography, ethnic diversity, political culture, historiography, and basic terminology (such as “Iran/Iranian” vs. “Persia/Persian”), the book's seven subsequent chapters are broken down by successive governments or groupings thereof. The bulk of the work is drawn from secondary sources in English, which are lightly footnoted throughout the text, and described in an annotated bibliography. In addition, the author interweaves his own interpretations of several primary sources for the Achaemenian through Pahlavi periods with those of other specialists. Liberally interspersed throughout the work are excellent black-and-white photographs and images—the majority taken by Garthwaite himself or derived from his collection of artifacts and memorabilia—depicting a vast array of subject matter spanning Iranian political history.
Although no overarching thesis binds the entire work, one theme that is pursued explicitly in the first six chapters is the evolution of elite representations of authority and successive efforts to establish and maintain political legitimacy. Garthwaite demonstrates how Iranian rulers from the Achaemenians to the Safavids used authenticating titles, language, and symbols to locate themselves in a lineage of rulership and to legitimate their rule in relation to previous dynasts, whether such a lineage or continuity existed—and especially when it did not. Garthwaite draws on Pamela Crossley's concept of “simultaneous rulership” or multiple legitimacies to help explain the ways in which different representations or personae of the ruler—whether Persian, Islamic, Turko–Mongolian, or all of the above—were used to create legitimacy and enable rule over an ethnically and geographically diverse terrain. Illustrating with analyses of primary texts, inscriptions, and reliefs, and at a brisk but manageable pace, The Persians shines as an introductory survey in its first six chapters, and Garthwaite's passion for the material is palpable.
Some specialists of ancient through early modern Iranian history may lament the absence of certain features, institutions, or findings of recent research. For example, there is no mention of qanats, the craft guilds, or recent research on conversion during the 10th and 11th centuries. Nevertheless, the target audience will learn general information about irrigation, craft production, and conversion to Islam in Iran, and be introduced to many other significant features, institutions, and historical interpretations.
It is when we arrive at the modern period in chapters 7 and 8 that the continually accelerating pace of the text becomes problematic, and the challenges posed by the necessity for severe summarization and generalization are brought into sharp relief. That the multitude of cultural and social developments across diverse elements of Iranian society since the late 18th century could not possibly be covered with depth or complexity in less than 100 pages is a given, especially in a survey primarily focused on political elites. However even the political narrative loses cohesion in this sprint through the history of the Qajars, Pahlavis, and the Islamic Republic, which suffers from two interrelated problems. First is the lack of sufficient specific detail and interpretation essential to a comprehensible and nuanced account of pivotal events and political developments. The second problem is various observations and analogies that—in their brevity and lacking additional detail and explication—may confuse and/or mislead the nonspecialist reader.
For example, after stating that the formation of the Cossack Brigade in 1878 ended Qajar reliance on tribal levies, the brigade disappears from the narrative until 1920–21, when it appears suddenly to reassert governmental control in Tabriz and assist Reza Khan and Sayyid Zia in their coup d'etat. Without a few words regarding the structure, purpose, and uses of the brigade (that it was despised by many Iranian nationalists and constitutionalists as a blatant instrument and symbol of imperialism; its position during the Constitutional Revolution; and especially its role in 1909 when it was used to bombard the majlis, to arrest parliament members, assert martial law, and ultimately to engage the forces of nationalism marching on Tehran in battle before their defeat), the nonspecialist reader misses out on important dynamics of domestic and foreign policy during the late Qajar era and one of the basic problematics of Pahlavi legitimacy. The question, therefore, arises as to the efficacy of such a skeletal narrative and its utility as assigned reading on modern Iran. Moreover, Garthwaite's rather unorthodox analogies between Ataturk and Khomeini, or Reza Shah and Jamal al-Din al-Afghani potentially might be entertaining and challenging for seasoned students of Iran and the Middle East to ponder and debate, but such associations will be confusing to readers who are just beginning to grasp the root ideologies and legacies of these seminal figures.
Similarly, in the twenty-two pages devoted to the Islamic Republic, Garthwaite lacks the time to describe the nature and extent of United States support for Iraq during the Iran–Iraq War of 1980–88 or to mention related events such as Operation Praying Mantis (the largest U.S. naval operation since World War II, in which half the Iranian navy was sunk in a 24-hour period), the downing of Iran Air flight 655 by the USS Vincennes, and the Iran–Contra scandal. Crucial aspects of Iran–U.S. relations and Iranian foreign policy subsequent to the war, and details regarding the Islamic Republic's relations with Hezbollah and Israel, are also neglected. Without such critical background, it is difficult to explain the sense of anger many Iranians feel as a result of past U.S. actions and policies and the nationalist sentiments that they generate. The uninitiated will likely be unable to draw the link between the history of ancient Iran and the evolution of Iranian identity that Garthwaite eloquently describes in earlier chapters to the essences of anti-imperialism and independence that pervade contemporary Iranian nationalism. Without such detail, it is doubtful that the passing mention of Iran's “extreme ‘Great Satan’ rhetoric,” “support for terrorism,” and its inclusion in Bush's “axis of evil” will be illuminating or meaningful.
The Persians could serve well as a core textbook for a ten- or fifteen-week survey of Iranian history. Gaps in coverage can become the subject of alternative readings and/or addressed in lectures and discussion. Selected chapters would also work very well as supplementary reading in courses on premodern Iran and ancient world civilizations. Although not comprehensive regarding the most recent scholarship, the annotated bibliography and suggestions for further reading are useful, and the maps, tables, and images cover many important rudiments of Iranian history.
