In Argentina: A Modern History Jill Hedges presents a brief and concise history of Argentina covering a period reaching from colonial times to Cristina Kirchner's first presidency. The book is divided into 13 chapters. The narrative strategy to compress this long history into fewer than 300 pages is to describe every presidency, with each section analysing the political and economic characteristics of one or various presidencies. In all cases the author explains in detail the context in which the presidential changes were produced, and the consequences of those transitions. The chapters present the reader with specific data on economic policies and political developments. The author also offers meticulous insights on the positions, calculations, careers and backgrounds of the ruling leaders. This means that Argentina: A Modern History emphasises the role taken by political elites in setting up the path of the country. The fact that five of the 13 chapters are dedicated to Peronism is not fortuitous. In the introduction to the volume the author states that the book will devote considerable space to this political phenomenon ‘in a bid to explain a historical movement which has successfully reinvented itself over time to represent the changing aspirations of large sectors of society’ (p. xvii). In order to fulfil this aim Hedges sketches the social and economic changes that preceded the rise of Perón and links them to the vote for him. She portrays the alliance of the working classes with Perón as a rational move, as the latter provided subaltern sectors with tangible, as well symbolic, benefits. Although she highlights the fact that this regime represented a watershed in Argentina's history, Hedges concludes that the rise of Perón marked ‘neither the end of oligarchic exploitation … nor the birth of a revolutionary new Argentina’ (p. 116). At the same time, the author devotes significant attention to the personal biographies of both Eva and Juan Domingo Perón. From chapter 9 onwards, Hedges describes the political events that followed the end of Perón's government. She closes the book stating that in the present day certain approaches of Argentine political thinking, namely ‘short-termism, personal gain and zero sum attitudes’, remained untouched, undermining ‘any prospect of unpopular reform that might bring long-term benefit’ (p. 291).
The book provides a chronological and extensive account that would be helpful to readers who are looking for a factual history of Argentina. However, this monograph would be less useful for those who expect a more critical and nuanced history. First, the book makes a range of assertions that could have perhaps been developed more in the text. For example, Hedges ascribes Argentina's reversal of fortune at the beginning of the twentieth century and the later rise of Perón to the lack of an inclusive identity. To appeal to such a slippery concept as ‘identity’, without defining it, explains very little. It also simplifies a complex history to a single cause. Additionally, most of the volume illuminates cases of poor internal politics. The part played by external conditions or shocks is downplayed in Hedges' narrative. While the volume is illustrated with numerous anecdotes and rumours, the reader wonders whether the stories uncovered by Hedges should occupy quite so many pages. For example, gossip about Perón's sentimental life occupies more space than the analysis of topics such as the rise of anarchism among the labour movement, which is almost absent. Indeed, the very use of those anecdotes is perhaps questionable as, for example, the author uses information from the press and from popular repertoires without distinguishing this from factual data and academic explanations. For instance, how can Menem's success be linked to the ‘national admiration to the chanta’ (p. 260) and the previous experience of hyperinflation at the same time?
One of the most problematic aspects of the book is that it does not acknowledge the historiographical debates that have taken place in the academic history of Argentina in the last few decades. This means that for much of the time the account provided by Hedges is slightly too unilateral. Two examples regarding Hedges' descriptions of Argentina's most important political parties illustrate this. Hedges portrays the Unión Cívica Radical (Radical Civic Union, UCR) as a political party of the middle class that represented the rise of a new social sector. But there has already been much work, such as Paula Alonso's book on the early years of the UCR, in which class occupies a less important role in the rise of Yrigoyen than previously believed, something Hedges' text chooses to ignore. Most surprising is the fact that she does not acknowledge Ezequiel Adamovsky's claim that the UCR did not appeal or identify with the middle class, even though she quotes him recurrently in the book. Hedges also does not mention the debates over how much the UCR did, or did not, renovate political practices, the economy or the social structure.
Regarding Peronism, Hedges claims in the introduction of the book that this political movement has usually been described either as an incomprehensible phenomenon or a form of Latin American fascism. But there is an extensive bibliography on Peronism produced in recent decades that has debated and abandoned those visions. This means that hers is not a fair description of the existing literature. Moreover, Hedges' treatment of this phenomenon ignores all the historiography that has been published on the cultural and societal changes brought by this regime, which has given us a better understanding of a phenomenon that cannot be easily encapsulated in clear-cut categories. Her interpretation of Peronism is narrowed to the images that the antiperonistas constructed. For example, she claims that Perón celebrated national identity ‘in the form of the native-born working class … disparaging the oligarchic concept which favoured all things European and despised its darker skinned compatriots’ (p. 87). But historical work, focused on the cultural history of Peronism and well summarised in Matthew Taylor and Oscar Chamosa (eds.), The New Cultural History of Peronism (Duke University Press, 2010), has already shown that Perón appealed to established notions of ‘good taste’, celebrated classic culture and was not as democratic in racial terms as Hedges implies in her comment.
