As the preface states, the main focus of this book is “to unravel and bring clarity to the complex, elaborate, and secret world of Islamic charities that have financed terrorism. . .Our objective was to have the reader, when reaching the last page, have an appreciation for global extent, ferocity, and determination of the Islamists who are perpetrating crimes against humanity in the name of religion, and the role that certain Islamic charities have played in supporting those Islamists” (p. xi). The authors explicitly warn that their book is not concerned with the thousands of Islamic charities that do assist and support the poor and have nothing to do with terrorism.
The book opens with a general chapter on obligatory alms (zakat), voluntary alms (ṣadaqa), and religious endowments (awqāf). This chapter includes a section on the practice of almsgiving in Sudan, Egypt, and especially Saudi Arabia and provides an analysis of the role banks play in channelling funds to charitable organizations. The rest of the book is taken up with separate chapters on the relations between charitable organizations and terrorist organizations in Afghanistan, Sudan, the Balkans, Central Asia, Southeast Asia, Europe, and the United States.
The major benefit of the book is that the authors point out that billions of dollars are being collected annually with little demand for administrative transparency. They argue cogently that the distinction between supporting jihad in Afghanistan in the 1980s and promoting terrorism became “hopelessly blurred” (p. 29). To substantiate their argument they give different examples of the ways terrorism and charitable organisations have worked together.
Despite these benefits, there are major problems with this book. These are related to the aim of the book itself. Meant as a wake-up call, the study falls within America's war on terror and stresses the imminent threat that the relationship between charitable organizations and terrorism poses to the world. Another is related to the wide interpretation of the term terrorism. The danger this combination poses for a more neutral and scholarly approach to the subject is reflected in the difficulty the authors have in distinguishing between “radical” and “moderate” Islamist leaders and organizations. For instance, Sudanese Hasan al-Turabi and Tunisian Rachid Ghannushi are put in the same bag as Osama bin Laden and the Algerian terrorist organization Groupe Salafiste pour la Prédication et le Combat. Likewise, Yusuf al-Qaradawi is called “the radical Egyptian cleric and promoter of Hamas” (p. 70). All mujahidin who fought in Afghanistan were labelled terrorists, and when they returned to their countries of origin, “they founded or joined Islamist groups committed to overthrowing the government and establishing an Islamist state” (p. 77). Moreover, political organizations such as Hamas and the Chechnyan resistance and Islamist organizations supporting the Bosnian cause are uncritically designated as terrorist organizations because they are listed as such by the United States and Russia. By casting their net so wide and following American policy so uncritically, the authors are bound to come up with an inaccurate analysis of the phenomenon they set out to analyze.
The outcome of this inflated concept of terrorism is that all charitable organizations or banks linked in one way or another to these political organizations are tarred with the brush of terrorism. This applies to the Saudi Arabian Red Crescent Society, the Al-Haramain Islamic Foundation, and the Al-Barak Bank and the Benevolence International Foundation (US), which are accused of promoting “the radical Islamist agenda” or supporting Chechen “terrorists.” Even those organizations that had contacts with Bin Laden and the Taliban before al-Qaʿida was established are accused of illegal acts.
Oddly enough, when the authors do try to nail down their accusations, these are not always watertight. For instance, the authors state that in Bosnia “of the 250 NGOs active in the Balkans in 1996, fifty were Islamic; thirty of these were known to have terrorist connections but were ignored by the new multi-ethnic national police force” (p. 144). However, the authors provide very little information on these remaining thirty. The same goes for the Philippines, where the authors argue that “a dozen interlocking charities underpinned the Islamist movement” (p. 189). Where they do provide evidence it is much less than the book as a whole suggests.
In fact, much of the book does not deal with charities but with terrorism as such and more narrowly with al-Qaʿida, rehashing much that we already know, much of which is based on such flimsy sources as local intelligence reports and newspapers. The book, therefore, tends to fall prey to the maximalist interpretation of the power of al-Qaʿida as a ubiquitous organization extending its tentacles into every nook and corner of the earth. For instance, Ramzi Youssef, the mastermind of the World Trade Center attack in 1993, is regarded as a member of al-Qaʿida; in Somalia, Bin Laden wanted to “establish an Islamist regime” (p. 125); after the Dayton Accords, “Al Qaeda was alive and well in the Balkans” (pp. 145–46); in Kosovo, the Iranian Revolutionary Guards supposedly “joined forces with Al Qaeda and Egyptian Islamic Groups to support the Albanian insurgency” (p. 148); and finally in Tajikistan, “charities were usually run by Muslim outsiders and members of Al Qaeda to provide arms, cash, and supplies to jihad movements” (p. 163).
Although it has been proven that there are links between Muslim charitable organizations and terrorism, this is not the real threat to the world. Much more important is that many of these charitable organizations spread Salafism. As a “deculturized,” alien, transnational, sectarian creed, Salafi beliefs exacerbate the difficulty of integrating Muslim youth in Europe and have led to severe tensions between Salafis and adherents of indigenous forms of Islam elsewhere. It can, by means of its sectarian ideology, in some cases indirectly promote violence. This more fundamental problem of charitable organizations is only mentioned in the last two chapters on Europe and the United States.
