I am among those who believe that although a gap between the academic and policy worlds is inevitable—we are distinct fields with our own mission and organizational culture—it is much too wide. Bridging it is difficult but possible—and beneficial to both sides.
I have written numerous articles that analyze the causes and consequences and that make proposals for bridging the gap (Jentleson Reference Jentleson2002; Jentleson and Ratner Reference Jentleson and Ratner2011). Footnote 1 Based on that analysis and toward that end, along with colleagues, we developed the Bridging the Gap (BtG) Initiative. Steve Weber (University of California, Berkeley) also was a cofounder; we were joined by Jim Goldgeier (then of George Washington University and currently Dean of the School of International Service, American University), as well as younger colleagues who were then University of California, Berkeley graduate students: Naazneen Barma (currently assistant professor, Naval Postgraduate School), Brent Durbin (assistant professor, Smith College), and Ely Ratner (Center for a New American Security), and in 2014 by Jordan Tama (assistant professor, American University). Footnote 2 Our principal support is from grants from the Carnegie Corporation of New York, with crucial support from Stephen Del Rosso, director of the International Peace and Security program (Del Rosso Reference Rosso and Stephen2015).
For the purposes of this task force report, I summarize our BtG Initiative and its main programs, including a new book series launched with Oxford University Press.
BtG INITIATIVE OVERALL OBJECTIVES
Although difficult to trace its provenance, “bridging the gap” often is attributed to Alexander George—both for his book by that title and his overall intellectual leadership that encourages greater policy relevance in political science and international relations (George Reference George1993). The BtG Initiative is dedicated to strengthening the relationship between scholars of international relations/comparative politics and the broader foreign-policy community. Our goals are to support policy-relevant academic research about international politics and to provide professional development for those who want to pursue it. We define policy-relevant scholarship as research, analysis, writing, and related activities that advance knowledge with an explicit priority of addressing policy questions. Policy-relevant scholarship in no way means atheoretical work. It is oriented, however, more toward theories that are middle range in their level of abstraction in contrast to efforts of general theory and “isms.” It identifies policy challenges and only then turns to theories and methods to understand and manage them.
We pursue our objectives in four principal ways: (1) bringing together scholars who have been leaders in advancing policy-relevant international-relations research; (2) providing assistance to junior scholars who seek to engage in policy-relevant research or pursue careers in the policy world; (3) connecting scholars with policy makers from the diplomatic, defense, and intelligence communities; and (4) collaborating with other projects and colleagues with similar objectives.
NEW ERA FOREIGN POLICY CONFERENCE
The New Era Foreign Policy Conference is an annual three-day workshop for PhD students of international relations and comparative politics primarily from political science departments and Association of Professional Schools of International Affairs (APSIA) schools. The conference, which first took place in 2006, has the following three goals:
-
• bring together and continue building a network of policy-oriented PhD students who are interested in US foreign policy and international politics
-
• equip a new generation of international-affairs scholars with tools to conduct and disseminate policy-relevant research
-
• invigorate the foreign-policy community with fresh ideas and new avenues for future research
Rather than a presentation of papers with panels and discussants, the format of the conference is a series of workshops and scenario-analysis and -development sessions. Participants are asked to assess medium-term challenges and opportunities currently facing the United States and the international community by critically examining macro-level goals that underpin these issues and problematizing the strategies and policies meant to achieve them. At previous conferences, the PhD students have been joined by policy experts from the National Security Council, Department of Defense, State Department, RAND Corporation, Central Intelligence Agency, Brookings Institution, National Public Radio, US Mission to the United Nations, Foreign Policy journal, and Council on Foreign Relations. While the BtG principals oversee and participate in New Era, former participants run the conference; in recent years Rachel Whitlark (post-doctoral fellow, Harvard), Eric Lorber (lawyer, Gibson Dunn and Crutcher), Julia Macdonald (PhD candidate, George Washington University) and Michel Weintraub (assistant professor, Binghamton University, SUNY) have taken the lead. Appendix A is the 2015 conference agenda.
After attending the conference, participants are encouraged to generate and shape policy-relevant research ideas. In the past, these ideas contributed to their dissertation projects and resulted in conference papers, published academic articles, and policy-journal pieces. Many of the participants are now faculty, some now tenured.
INTERNATIONAL POLICY SUMMER INSTITUTE
The International Policy Summer Institute (IPSI) is a five-day professional-development program for professors (of all ranks) and postdocs in international affairs who want to build the tools and networks to produce and disseminate policy-relevant academic research. IPSI provides an intensive curriculum designed to teach participants how to develop and articulate their research for a policy audience, what policy makers are looking for when they assess international-relations scholarship, whom to target when sharing research, and which tools and avenues of dissemination are appropriate. IPSI also provides a forum for scholars to develop professional networks with their colleagues as well as with the broader policy community.
Sessions are facilitated by senior faculty and are held in various formats, including the following:
-
• workshops with executive branch and congressional policy makers, interest groups, nongovernmental organizations (NGOs), academics, and think-tank researchers that focus on policy processes and the roles of academic research within them
-
• colloquia with international-affairs scholars who have successfully engaged in policy debates
-
• sessions with editors of prominent policy journals and with scholars who are prominent bloggers
-
• interactive communications and media training, including mock news interviews with follow-on assessments by professional television and radio producers
-
• hands-on workshops to develop dissemination and influence strategies, using “live” research material
-
• network-building opportunities with policy makers and fellow scholars
Appendix B is the curriculum from the 2014 IPSI. Appendix C provides representative feedback from New Era Foreign Policy Conference and IPSI participants.
The NEI workshop uses scenarios and other methods that encourage participants to move beyond their own national, disciplinary, and occupational perspectives.
NEW ERA INTERNATIONAL
The first New Era International (NEI) workshop was held in December 2013 in Singapore in collaboration with the School of Social Sciences at Singapore Management University. NEI is designed to convene leading thinkers from academia, business, NGOs, and government and international institutions from key strategic regions to go beyond the issues of the day and address consequential political and economic choices that will drive global foreign policy in the next five to 10 years. The 2013 workshop concentrated on the changing dynamics of global public goods provision in Southeast Asia, specifically focusing on regional public health and energy governance. The NEI workshop uses scenarios and other methods that encourage participants to move beyond their own national, disciplinary, and occupational perspectives. The goal is to draw on everyone’s distinctive expertise while diminishing the influence of their functional biases. Appendix D is the agenda from the 2013 NEI workshop in Singapore.
OVERALL BtG NETWORKING AND SYNERGIES WITH LIKE-MINDED INITIATIVES
More than 300 people have participated in the various BtG programs. As noted previously, many initiate their own collaborations. We now have staffing that allows a more consistent and creative use of our website and other ways to institutionalize our networking. For example, alumni who publish op-eds or similar articles can have them distributed to all BtG-ers, which can have an incentivizing demonstration effect. We hold receptions at major annual conferences (e.g., the American Political Science Association and the International Studies Association), and we are increasing our efforts to make the network a dynamic one.
We also collaborate with what is beginning to emerge as a quasi-consortium of like-minded programs. These include the Tobin Project (based at Massachusetts Institute of Technology); the Notre Dame International Security Program (Professor Michael Desch); the Scholars Strategy Network (founded by Professor Theda Skocpol at Harvard University); the Syracuse Maxwell School-MIT Security Studies Project, “Towards a New Approach to the Advanced Study of Security and International Affairs” (Syracuse University Dean Jim Steinberg, MIT Professor Frank Gavin); and the College of William and Mary Teaching and Research in International Politics Survey (TRIPS, led by Professors Mike Tierney and Sue Peterson).
Our niche consists of books in which policy concerns frame the formulation of the central research question, that are integral to the analytic framework structuring the book, and that are addressed prescriptively with a degree of specificity.
“BRIDGING THE GAP” BOOK SERIES
Working with David McBride, Social Science Editor at Oxford University Press, we recently established a “Bridging the Gap” book series under the editorship of Goldgeier, Weber, and Jentleson. The series features books that exemplify high-quality policy-relevant scholarship in international relations. Our niche consists of books in which policy concerns frame the formulation of the central research question, that are integral to the analytic framework structuring the book, and that are addressed prescriptively with a degree of specificity. These criteria will be applied rigorously in selecting, editing, and approving manuscripts. Leading senior scholars will be featured, as well as promising junior scholars engaged in policy-relevant scholarship. For more information visit http://www.american.edu/sis/BTG/btgseries.cfm
CONCLUSION: BENEFITS AND RESPONSIBILITIES IN GAP-BRIDGING
The policy relevance of political science is often underestimated. But we should not delude ourselves that it is enough. My colleagues and I approach our gap-bridging efforts with three main convictions. First, political scientists can make meaningful contributions to policy. Certainly, we are not “smarter” than policy professionals. Rather each of us has knowledge to bring to the table consistent with what might be considered our respective comparative advantages. Second, we have much to gain as both teachers and scholars from engaging more in policy questions and as appropriate in actual policy positions. Finally, as such important institutions in society, universities have a responsibility to use the acquired methods and knowledge to contribute to the daunting challenges that pervade our times.
2015 New Era Foreign Policy Conference Agenda

2014 International Policy Summer Institute Agenda

Bridging the Gap Programs: Examples of Participant Feedback
NEW ERA INTERNATIONAL SURVEY RESPONSES
-
• “The most helpful part of New Era was its role in creating a network of like-minded academics and policy professionals. I continue to draw on that network for collaboration on research and to provide my research with a policy outlet.” New Era International participant
-
• “The group brainstorming and discussion sessions on pressing policy issues at New Era were especially stimulating, and showed me that I would prefer to work in a team-based problem-solving environment than as an isolated researcher.” New Era International participant
-
• “I learned that to be truly successful in bridging the gap between policy and academia, one needs to make a conscious and deliberate effort to do policy-relevant academic work. This was not obvious to me as a graduate student in a political science department. I didn't appreciate how important it was to be strategic in one's choice of projects, and how important it was to set out explicitly to do policy-relevant work, as neither relevance nor influence will happen accidentally.” New Era International participant
-
• “It was a great experience. I learned a lot, especially, as you put it, from the cumulative logic of the event. You are good people for putting it together.” New Era International 2014 participant
INTERNATIONAL POLICY SUMMER INSTITUTE SURVEY RESPONSES
-
• “IPSI forced me—and gave me space—to think through specific policy recommendations and implications of my research.” IPSI 2012 participant
-
• “I really appreciated how balanced the week was. It's a pretty rigorous few days, but I felt that it stayed fresh the whole time. I've returned home with lots of ideas for spinning off some policy implications from my work!” IPSI participant
-
• “...your seminar gave me a new perspective on what I am doing, and, even more importantly, the tools to go about my objectives.” IPSI 2014 participant
-
• “The workshop was a very useful experience and has made me think much more systemically about how to approach the policy world.” IPSI 2014 participant
APPENDIX D
New Era International Agenda
CONFERENCE COSPONSORED BY THE SCHOOL OF PUBLIC POLICY, SINGAPORE MANAGEMENT UNIVERSITY DECEMBER 9–10, 2013

