Self-governance has long been at the heart of the American political tradition, but the progressive movement called into question the adequacy of such a practice as well as the limited government designed by the Founders in light of what some believed to be dramatically different conditions from those present at the founding of America. Will Morrisey offers an impressive and ambitious examination of the three presidents whose tenure in office coincided with the advent of the Progressive Era. The scope of the book, however, goes well beyond a study of how each one was influenced by Progressive thought during his presidency. The book provides in addition a wide-ranging discussion of both classical and modern principles of political philosophy that offer opposing views to progressivism as well as the intellectual foundations of the movement. A discussion of self-government in America in the preface is followed by a thorough inquiry into progressivism in the introduction. Each of three subsequent chapters is devoted to one of the presidents—Roosevelt, Taft, and Wilson—and his understanding of self-government with respect to several different topics. The concluding chapter returns to the topic of self-government, “the progressivist dilemma.” Morrisey argues that while the three presidents contributed to the building of the modern state in America, each had a different response regarding how to sustain self-government under conditions of increased statism and how to resist the impact of statism on the regime.
The sovereign authority in the American regime rests with the people, but the Progressives do not see the people as made up of individual citizens and families, but rather as a whole. Morrisey explains the origin of this reconceived notion of the people by looking to philosophy. To grasp the dramatic shift in thinking brought about by the Progressives, Morrisey begins with definitions of the two concepts from classical political philosophy that are central to the practice of self-government: self-mastery and self-rule. His discussion about the importance to self-government of mastering the passions of the soul and then of liberating the soul from excessive desire for material goods focuses the reader on the behavior of the individual citizen. Aristotle's definition of politics, the condition of ruling and being ruled reasonably, directly correlates to this requirement of the citizen's ability to rule oneself. The challenge of containing the passions of the majority in a regime requires the practice of self-mastery and self-rule. In America, the principles of federalism and republicanism that were established by the Founders are among the solutions to a potentially passionate majority that would be destructive of the liberty of the people and endanger the regime. Morrisey draws upon the teachings of Tocqueville, whose observations highlight other American institutions that advance the practice of self-governance. In particular, the practice of township governance that was established during the colonial era throughout parts of America provided the opportunity for the citizenry to learn to rule and be ruled in turn and thus practice self-governance. Machiavelli, the third political philosopher discussed in the preface, provides the contrasting example that modern Europeans employed to address factionalism: the institution of statism. Such a practice establishes sovereignty not in the people, but in the state: “separate the state from civil society, thus enabling the state to stand over civil-social factions as an arbiter” (x).
Morrisey continues his inquiry in the introduction as he traces the origin of progressivist thought to philosophers who had previously denied the moral and political authority of religion and diminished the significance of human nature. Hegel redefined history as the source of authority; the purpose of human activity is seen in the course of human events themselves, in the form of progress toward freedom and mastery of nature. The movement forward by the people as a whole is accomplished in the modern state where a bureaucracy or administration can direct it. Self-governance takes on a dramatically different cast under these conditions. Morrisey then shifts his inquiry to progressivism in America, identifying several significant figures who introduced progressive and historicist ideas in the United States. He also includes a careful examination of several episodes in American history since the Founding in a section entitled “What Progressivism Is Not,” thus completing a comprehensive view of progressivism from its origin to its rise in America.
The heart of Morrisey's book is the engaging inquiry into how the three presidents understood self-government. Morrisey accomplishes this by subdividing each chapter into multiple sections on wide-ranging topics such as the modern state, the American Constitution, the American nation, political economy, foreign policy, the military, national order, empire, history, and others. Drawing upon the speeches and writings of each president and chronicling their policies and actions in public and private capacities, the author meets his goal of understanding them as they understood themselves (31). Morrisey's endeavor is not to judge, but to allow the reader to assess each president on his own merits and in light of the particular circumstances that each had to face during his presidency. With respect to progressive thought, self-government, and the American regime, their unique understandings are highlighted. To mention just a few of the various points made about each of the presidents: Morrisey describes Roosevelt's progressivism as limited; although he embraced several of the principles of the American Founding, his view that contemporary social conditions required a strong executive, albeit one that must be held in check by a self-governing, virtuous people, laid the groundwork for a stewardship view of the executive that played into progressive thought. Taft is described as a legalist who, in contrast to the Progressives, recognized the limited powers of the Constitution and the necessity of respecting the rule of law. Self-governance is fostered through moderation, prudence, and restraint. In contrast to the other two presidents, Wilson did not embrace the Founders' views on natural rights and constitutional self-government. Morrisey argues that Wilson historicized American nationhood, with history also taking the place of nature. Self-governance for Wilson no longer involves mastering the passions, but becoming impassioned, directly contrary to the classical view. The organization of these three chapters allows the reader to compare the presidents on specific issues or study each independently in light of the philosophical discussion of progressive thought and classical principles at the beginning of the book.
Readers who are interested in the rise of progressive thought in America and the response of the presidents who served in the era when the movement took root in public sentiment will find a thorough analysis in this book. It both complements Morrisey's earlier work, Self-Government, the American Theme: Presidents of the Founding and Civil War and expands the scope of studies of the Founding principles of the United States and challenges to them. Morrisey's contribution to the debate about how best to preserve the foundation of American liberties and the efforts by the progressives to alter dramatically the role that government plays in the lives of the citizenry is very timely. Understanding the actions and policies of the three presidents who served at the beginning of the Progressive Era focuses our attention not only on the role of government, but also on how institutions can mold the citizenry.
