Lee's contribution to the Blackwell series advertises a focus on the army's relations with society and a turning away from the interests of conventional military history in strategy, tactics, organization and equipment. He continues an established trend of historical investigation in recent years of looking at the military's position within social, political, economic and ideological networks. Such approaches establish the army in context and although such a trend does not necessarily devalue other approaches, technical studies of the military are now but one part of our understanding of the military. The result of this historiographical shift is that as opposed to two decades ago, the history of the military is now far more mainstream, and of interest to a wide range of historians.
Understanding of the army of Late Antiquity has perhaps benefited more from this change in approach than research into the armies of other periods and this is probably a reflection of the particular problems of studying the late antique army: the literary sources are diverse and complex; the archaeology is increasing in quality and quantity, but still something of a Cinderella area compared with other periods; and the absence of a large body of epigraphic and iconographic data means that methods employed to understand the army of the Roman imperial period cannot be used.
In establishing the status quaestionis L. allows us to reflect on the issues confronting researchers, many of which remain fundamentally unresolved. For example, L. argues that warfare plays a role in the decline of frontier zones (a key issue in current historiography), but concludes by stressing that it is very difficult to disentangle warfare from other factors, and that warfare appears to have the most deleterious effect when associated with other cataclysmic events. Similarly, L.'s discussion of the economic drain of military finance quite reasonably leaves the question open after citing widely divergent estimates for the proportion of the imperial budget spent on the army (no help here in considering whether the ‘idle mouths’ ate away the economic base of empire). Was military service to be avoided? There is evidence for conscription, but also for individuals actively seeking military appointments. Was there hostility between soldiers and civilians? There are plenty of complaints and some vitriolic treatments of soldiers, but also evidence that soldiers and civilians lived alongside each other without particular friction.
The problems in understanding the army are fundamental, but are difficult to resolve in isolation from the historical debates that animate study of Late Antiquity. For example, understanding the costs (and economic benefits) of the military depends on an understanding of the size of the late antique economy (which in turn depends on estimates for population) and the tax-take of the late antique state. The issues of social and political structure, the role of the city, the continuities of aristocracies, and the effect of Christianization are all particularly controversial. ‘Change factors’ in Late Antiquity are endlessly debated. Further, the primary sources are often partial. The legal texts inevitably concentrate on particular problems. The literary texts are often contentious: what do we make of Libanius complaining at one moment that the military are taking over, and at the next that the soldiers are forced to live in rags? What do we make of his complaints that the curial élite are being oppressed and bankrupted, alongside archaeological evidence of the great wealth of at least some in Antioch, and what appears to have been a historically unusually oppressive system of peasant domination? It is also difficult to balance literary accounts with the documentary material (limited and partial though it is) which appears to show a very different picture.
I fear that these difficulties stem in part from our approaches to the army and Late Antiquity. There is a tendency to see both as ‘semi-discrete entities’, when in all likelihood the position was rather more complex. It is difficult to believe that the army of the fourth century was very similar to that of the seventh century. But is also seems likely that the fourth- and sixth-century's armies were varied organizations. The soldiers that we see in the documentary records from Arabia and Egypt may have been somewhat different from those in the field armies. Further, the soldiers themselves were probably very varied. Soldiers of different social status, of different ethnicities, different levels of integration into ‘host’ societies were existing within (or outside) social and political systems that must have varied considerably, from the villages of Egypt, to the Near Desert of the Eastern frontier, to the forts of the Danubian and Gallic provinces, to the great cities of the Empire.
Such reflections are not to detract from L.'s contribution in this volume. L. ably surveys this material and has produced what will be an indispensable handbook for students and researchers new to the field. He carefully delineates historiographical disputes and discusses the available material. Yet, the Late Roman army and society remain a puzzle, or perhaps many different puzzles, awaiting solutions.
