Many of the claims for restitution of land and political autonomy made by indigenous and oppressed peoples against colonizing powers continue to rest on the assumption of an unextinguished sovereignty, but there have been increasingly complex debates about what sovereignty actually means. Looking particularly at the way the idea of sovereignty has played out in the New World, Jonathan Elmer has brought together a fascinating range of historical and literary material from and about early America, and finds the idea from the beginning inextricably related to issues of race, in “a racialized logic of personification that conjoins individual and collective identities” (258). He sees Native Americans and African Americans occupying different but complementary roles in what he calls “the political imagination of Atlantic modernity” (3). At the same time that the Indians' claim to the land was being politically and practically nullified, their mythic relation to the land was being developed, and Elmer shows through the figure of “Chief” Logan, and the use made of his famous speech by Thomas Jefferson and others, how the trope of the last Indian, or what he calls “the lingering last,” was used as part of a process of ‘projection, identification and disavowal’ in the development of American thinking about itself. In contrast, Elmer argues, Africans in the Americas are uprooted, deterritorialized and inescapably modern, so come to be used as a complementary disguised projection in this same American debate over national identity, and Elmer explores the figure of the royal slave or captive king particularly through Aphra Behn's Oroonoko, and Olaudah Equiano. The idea of the captive king contains the idea of individual sovereignty but also of absolute powerlessness. Through these two complementary racialized tropes (lingering and last, or royal slave), then, the idea of the free sovereign self is obliquely shown to be both desired and yet in irreconcilable conflict with American civilization. Elmer draws productively on the work of Agamben and Carl Schmitt, as well as of Deleuze and Guattari and Badiou, to explore the problems that occur when we try to equate personal and state sovereignty, as his chosen tropes do. His book shows how the positions of African Americans and Native Americans reveal in different ways Agamben's “state of exception” as the foundation of the American system, but a foundation which must be obscured and mythicized.
While the ultimate focus is the way that racialized tropes reveal and reflect the complexities of sovereignty in America in American texts, one distinctive aspect of the book is its transatlantic dimension, and we are given a good sense of the British connections, not just in the use of Aphra Behn but in the final chapter on the transatlantic sentimental novel, using Godwin to set up Brockden Brown's Edgar Huntly and John Neal's Logan; A Family History. Where all the themes come together most successfully, though, is in the fine central chapter on Melville, where Elmer brings together Billy Budd and Moby-Dick quite brilliantly, and weaves together his chosen theorists and Melville's own profound insights to exciting effect. This is an ambitious and often challenging book, which, for the suppleness and originality of its argument and the subtlety of its readings of the texts, will repay careful reading.
