Johan Svendsen (1840–1911) was the major Scandinavian symphonist of his time. Led by conductor Neeme Järvi, the Bergen Philharmonic Orchestra, one of Europe's finest and also one of the world's oldest (est. 1765), renders at the centennial of Svendsen's death a splendid tribute to his music and masterful orchestration. The recordings by Chandos offer a compelling overview of the composer's orchestral works, including his mainly forgotten violin and cello concertos – among his most lyrical works – performed by two of Norway's stellar performers, violinist Marianne Thorsen and cellist Truls Mørk.
Svendsen was born in Christiania (now Oslo) in the early years of Norwegian Romanticism, when people were fervently searching for national identity by collecting folk music, folk tales and old Norse sagas. Contemporary sources describe Svendsen as charming and ebullient. A first-rate violinist, he entered the Leipzig Conservatory in Fall, 1863. However, after injuring his left arm, he turned to composition, receiving the Conservatory's first prize in Spring, 1866, for the first movement of his newly written Symphony No. 1, op. 4, in D major, and later conducting the last three movements at the Gewandhaus before leaving the Conservatory in Summer 1867. The symphony was received with great fanfare. The Dresdener Telegraph wrote that nobody in the audience was in doubt about his future musical career; he was praised for his ‘freshness, vitality, confidence’ and ‘clear artistic consciousness and a noble feeling for the beautiful forms’.Footnote 1 Critics noted similarities with Mendelssohn and the Danish composer Niels Gade, as well as elements from Beethoven and Wagner.
The symphony, in its entirety, premiered in Oslo in fall 1867, with Edvard Grieg, who became Svendsen's close friend in Leipzig, in the audience. Astounded by its quality, Grieg wrote in a review, ‘Today Norwegian art has celebrated one of its triumphs. … He takes you with him into the fantastic, the humorous, the enchanted land of Romanticism. … [His] instrumentation is as perfect as any to be found’. He mentioned the national colouring of the Scherzo, finding it inspired and humorous, and argued that ‘the composer demonstrates that gigantic powers slumber within him in the introduction to the Finale, where he boldly reintroduces the principal theme’. The New York premiere of the symphony, by the legendary Theodore Thomas in Central Park in 1873, laid the foundation for Svendsen's international fame. The Bergen Philharmonic Orchestra plays the symphony with splendid gusto. In particular, the wind instruments are magnificent through the many transparent passages in which melodic material is passed between the voices in imitation.
Unable to find a position in Christiania, Svendsen settled in Paris, a city that would soon become his favourite. Befriending a number of French composers, he became thoroughly impressed with the conducting and orchestration skills of Berlioz. There he met the American singer Sarah (‘Sally’) Levett, marrying her in 1871. Despite living in a culturally stimulating environment, Svendsen composed very little in Paris, completing only his Violin Concerto, which was begun in Leipzig.
This Violin Concerto, op. 6 in A Major and the later Cello Concerto, op. 7 in D major, were experimental works for which Svendsen had high hopes. The Violin Concerto premiered at the Gewandhaus in February of 1872 with the composer conducting. Knowing that Svendsen was an excellent violinist, both critics and audiences expected a virtuosic romantic work; however, to their dismay the concerto lacked virtuosity, brilliance, and a solo cadenza. The Violin Concerto was received positively only in the United States, where, after its premiere in 1876, the Baltimore Bulletin wrote, ‘It is a superb work, as richly instrumented and as elaborately treated as a symphony, and the solo part written by a man who evidently is a master of the violin in all it resources’. Under Järvi's baton, Thorsen is technically masterful, but lacks, in this listener's view, the passion and assertiveness that the work demands.
The Cello Concerto, written after Svendsen's return to Leipzig in 1870, fared even worse. In a bold experiment, possibly modelled on Liszt's first piano concerto, the composer replaced the common three concerto movements with one long movement in modified sonata form; because the first and third parts of the concerto are very similar in content, the work sounds monotonous. In addition, Svendsen takes the cello down to the absolute bottom of its register, giving the work an almost ominous character – a failing that not even Mørk, with his beautiful phrasing and clarity of tone, can rescue.
Svendsen's next major work, Carnival in Paris, premiered in Oslo in October. It is among the finest of Svendsen's early compositions; both critics and audiences, Grieg included, were thrilled by the exuberant display of rhythms and forms, not to mention the composer's phenomenal handling of orchestral resources and experimentation with new forms. During the following years, new works constantly flowed from his pen: Zorahayda, op. 11, a symphonic poem dedicated to King Oscar II and based on Washington Irving's ‘The Legend of the Rose of Alhambra’; Festival Polonaise, op. 12, commissioned for the ball at the crowning of King Oscar II and Queen Sophie of Sweden-Norway; Norwegian Artists’ Carnival, op. 14, subtitled ‘Prince Carnival's Marriage to the Daughter of the Mountain King’, written for the Artists’ Association Festival in 1874; the much anticipated Symphony No. 2, op. 15; Romeo and Juliet, op. 18, a fantasy for orchestra based on Shakespeare's play; and the four Norwegian Rhapsodies, opp. 17, 19, 21, and 22, modelled after Liszt's Hungarian Rhapsodies, two of which Svendsen had orchestrated. All are included in the present recordings. Of special note is the lyricism of the strings in Carnival in Paris, as well as the flowing violin solo in Zorahayda; both examples are wonderful testaments to the orchestral resources of the Bergen Philharmonic.
Svendsen's Symphony No. 2 in B-flat major was greatly anticipated and warmly received. At its premiere in Christiania in 1876 the movements were individually applauded; the Scherzo, filled with Norwegian folk music idioms, had to be repeated. Audiences were once again astounded by Svendsen's idiosyncratic orchestral innovations, including his constant oscillation between dense and transparent textures, melodic material flowing seamlessly between inner and outer voices, his use of intricate rhythms, and flowing chromaticism. The critics were unanimous that Svendsen had created his best work. To an even greater extent than the first, the second symphony places heavy demands on the woodwinds in particular, a task the performers superbly manage. The work is arguably the finest symphony written by a Nordic composer in the nineteenth century.
In 1881, having travelled extensively in Europe for three years, Svendsen composed his most famous work, the hauntingly beautiful Violin Romance in G major, op. 26, which is still performed worldwide. The Romance's soaring melodic line and expressive lyrical quality place it on a par with Dvořák's Romance in F minor, op. 11. Thorsen, an avid performer of chamber music, plays more from within the orchestra than as a soloist and adds a lightness and Norwegian-like tone colour to the Romance that is new to this listener.
At century's end, Svendsen's audiences eagerly awaited his rumoured-to-be-finished third symphony. But it was never performed: in a fit of jealousy over a love letter from his mistress, Svendsen's wife threw the newly finished score into the fire, an incident memorialized in Henrik Ibsen's Hedda Gabler. Why Svendsen did not rewrite the score we will never know, but its destruction dealt a final blow to his creativity, marking the end of his career as a composer. Svendsen spent the following 25 years in Copenhagen as the artistic director of the Royal Theatre Orchestra, composing only works commissioned for special events. By the turn of the century, Svendsen was regarded as Europe's finest conductor.
The present recordings of Svendsen's orchestral works in the Grieghallen in Bergen, with its splendid acoustics, do wonders to Svendsen's innovative orchestration and festive bursts of joie de vivre, masterfully conveyed by the Bergen Philharmonic Orchestra. Chandos's well-crafted and comprehensive collection of Svendsen's orchestral music will deservedly rekindle the enthusiasm shown for his musicianship within his lifetime.
