Historical geography in Israeli academia and in the emerging field of Israel studies around the globe has undergone intellectual, methodological, and ideological reassessments during the last two decades, parallel to the much broader and well-known post-Zionism debate. Two schools of thought emerged from this reexamination. The first school, dubbed here the “Zionist-oriented school,” may be recognized by its declared goal of conducting “objective” scholarly studies by its keen commitment to thorough archival research and by its supposedly “neutral” stand toward the conflict between Palestinian Arabs and Zionist Jews. The second school, which may be termed the “post-Zionist-oriented school,” is characterized first and foremost by the central place it gives to the “other” and to the ethnic and national conflict in Palestine/Israel. Associated with scholars such as Oren Yiftachel, who identify the Israeli regime in Israel/Palestine as an “ethnocracy,” this school is also distinguished by its commitment to distinct theoretical frameworks, by its multidisciplinary approach, and by its insistence on seeking evidence “on the ground.”
Mandated Landscape by Roza El-Eini is a thoroughly researched and ambitious study. Its stated objective is to “analyse the impact of British imperial rule on the landscape of Mandate Palestine during the years 1929–48” (p. xxxi). It contains 670 pages of text, which are divided into six chapters, not including the introduction and the conclusion. The chapters are “Town Planning and the Urban and Rural Landscapes,” “Agriculture,” “Forestry,” “Land,” “The Partition Plans,” and “The Shephelah: A Case Study.” El-Eini's attempt to produce a comprehensive study is illustrated by the prominence of the auxiliary material in the book—appendices, bibliography, and the like—which together compose almost half of the tome.
Because El-Eini views ideology as the prime factor that shaped British “policy formation, planning, and plan implementation” (p. 28), Mandated Landscape is declared to be “an examination” of “the imperial British ideologies expressed in Palestine. . .and how this influenced their activities there” (p. 28). However, the author's a priori assumption that “there is no doubting the galvanising impact that the thirty-one years of British rule had on the landscape of Palestine” (p. xxxi) guides her examination in the direction of this premise. Indeed, in his groundbreaking study, Gideon Biger has clearly proven this point regarding the formative years of British rule in Palestine (1917–29). However, the British impact during the tumultuous later years of the Mandate (1929–48) requires more careful assessment.
In certain spheres, signs of imperial power inscribed in the landscape are well documented by El-Eini, as in the brief discussion of “Symbols of British Rule in the Urban Landscape” (pp. 62–64) or in the section on the British government's decision to make the use of local stones compulsory in the facades of urban buildings (p. 55). However, such aspects are minor considerations in Mandated Landscape.
The bulk of the book is dedicated to a discussion of topics that El-Eini views as central. One may wonder about her choices. For example, although the British government showed “a minimal interest. . .in Palestine's Forestry” (p. 242), El-Eini devotes an entire chapter to this topic. At the same time, central matters like transportation, the existence of army camps in the countryside and in cities, the central role that ethnically mixed towns played in shaping Palestine's landscape, and so on are marginal in the book. By the same token, zoning of urban centers—an important consideration for shaping the urban landscape—is given a similar number of pages as beekeeping, poultry, or “Upgrading Village Livestock.” In addition, the a priori assumption with regard to the “galvanising impact” of the late Mandate period on Palestine's landscape leads the author to present one-sided data, many times detached from any balancing context. Only at the end of chapters and subchapters do the readers discover that in most of the cases discussed this “impact” was limited or nonexistent.
Mandated Landscape clearly reflects its author's adherence to the Zionist-oriented school of historical geography. Hence, the book is abundant with original documents gathered from archives in Israel and Great Britain. Although this documentation is important and may provide source material for analysis and further research, the prominence given by the author to plans, schemes, ordinances, memoranda, and written documents in an effort to comprehend the reality behind them leaves the purpose of measuring the “impact” on the landscape only partially fulfilled. In addition, following the Zionist-oriented school, El-Eini makes a great effort to remain “neutral” toward the Palestinian–Zionist conflict. Although the ethnic and national battle is not ignored, of course, it is treated in a marginal way, as if it were just another factor that influenced the geographical–historical setting that the author examines. This is mostly evident in the chapter on “Town Planning and the Urban and Rural Landscapes” and elsewhere throughout the book.
Finally, the theoretical framework of the book is so broad that its binding interpretational powers remain very limited. One is tempted to speculate that had the author felt an obligation to look beyond the documents she has examined, to pose theoretical questions from the “other” school, and perhaps to adopt a more committed theoretical framework, the reality of the British Mandate's imprint upon Palestine's landscape would have been more clearly exposed.
Notwithstanding these remarks, students and scholars will find in Mandated Landscape detailed discussions of plans and programs as well as illustrations and maps, appendices, and an extensive bibliography that may serve as an important springboard for further research.
